THE DAVID BOZE SHOW

Former Seattle Ethics Commission Chair calls I-122 flawed

Oct 21, 2015, 2:22 PM | Updated: 5:05 pm

If voters pass the I-122 initiative, the average Seattle voter would be allotted four $25 vouchers,...

If voters pass the I-122 initiative, the average Seattle voter would be allotted four $25 vouchers, which they could then give to the candidate of their choice. However, the program only budgets enough for up to 13 percent of those vouchers, or about 47,000 vouchers. (AP)

(AP)

The goal of Initiative 122 is to wipe out big money from politics in Seattle, but Robert Mahon, former chair of the Seattle Ethics and Elections Commission, said the initiative’s major flaw is that it will instead simply push money around to independent expenditures.

“What it is effectively doing is subsidizing the campaign spending of largely special interests,” Mahon told KTTH’s Dave Boze. “This is a system that is flawed in timing, it’s flawed in funding and it’s a recipe, I think, for subsidy of special interests in Seattle elections.”

The aim of the I-122 campaign, nicknamed the “honest elections” initiative, is to give power back to regular voters by creating a way to publicly finance city and mayoral elections.

Boze said he reached out to a proponent of the initiative, but didn’t get a response. Heather Weiner, with Honest Elections Seattle, told Jason Rantz that recent studies have shown that about half of the money candidates raise comes from the same .3 percent of Seattleites over and over again.

“Typically, these folks live in high-end neighborhoods with beautiful views and that’s where candidates spend most of their time — dialing for dollars and knocking on those doors, going to cocktail parties, and raising money from those folks,” she said. “If we level the playing field and say candidates can raise money from anybody, and that everybody has the ability to give candidates money, we think that will really improve our democracy.”

The initiative would place a $500 limit on the amount of money a person can donate to a candidate. The average Seattle voter would also be allotted four $25 vouchers, which they could then give to the candidate of their choice. However, the program only budgets enough for up to 13 percent of those vouchers, or about 47,000 vouchers.

“Everybody is paying for these vouchers, but only the first 47,000 voters are gonna have their vouchers funded, and it’s first come, first serve,” Mahon said. “So, if you’re a special interest who is looking to spend some money to support a candidate that you’d like, you’re gonna go out on Jan. 2, you’re gonna collect those vouchers and direct them to the direction of your candidate of choice. Which is probably gonna be a candidate who is either an incumbent or is well established with a particular organization. And that’s not healthy. And it’s a complete waste of taxpayer dollars.”

Although proponents estimate the system will cost $650,000 in administrative costs, Mahon thinks that number is on the low end.

“What that means is, for every $100 in vouchers that get used, $28 in administrative costs, which reduces, of course, the benefit that proponents say would flow to candidates and voters,” he said. “So, in other words, 47,000 of us are gonna get our vouchers cashed, the other 600,000 Seattle residents are gonna be paying for it.”

Mahon said the elections commission has been told that the measure would require three new employees. Proponents also designed it so it will eventually be turned into an electronic system.

“But of course, there’s no money in the budget to actually do that, and anybody who’s gone through an IT project &#8212 the notion that you could do that as cheaply as proponents claim, is just wishful thinking,” he said. “I suspect taxpayers are gonna be on the hook for further administrative costs.”

Boze asked Mahon whether there is actually a problem that needs to be addressed.

“No, I think the answer is there isn’t a problem,” he said. “It’s a solution in search of a problem.”

The David Boze Show

Seattle self-defense expert Lawrence Kane said the most common natural reaction for a person angry ...

Eric Mandel

Seattle self-defense expert: Would take a ‘miracle’ for Ben Carson’s story to be accurate

If the presidential race wasn't bizarre enough, we're now calling in experts to prove whether a potential American president lied about his ability to stab a friend.

8 years ago

After 13 years on the air, David Boze announces he’s leaving KTTH. (KTTH image)...

David Boze

David Boze announces he’s leaving KTTH

I leave the station I helped found in the hands of a great company and good people. I am incredibly grateful for the loyalty and kindness of my listeners.

8 years ago

Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson smiles during a campaign rally at West Memphis High Sc...

Jacob Rummel

Ben Carson tries to explain involvement with ‘propaganda’

It wasn't an intentional attempt to appeal to young voters, but Ben Carson did end up the victim of a situation youth fall prey to on a regular basis.

8 years ago

Bremerton football coach Joe Kennedy prays with players on the field. (AP)...

Jacob Rummel

Praying Bremerton coach garners support from legislators at state and federal level

As Bremerton football coach Joe Kennedy continues to defy the school district by praying at midfield after games, he's starting to garner support in legislatures at the state and federal level.

9 years ago

Mayor Ed Murray’s Move Seattle levy promises maintenance and repair, including bridge moderni...

Kipp Robertson

Move Seattle levy raises more questions than it answers

The proposed $930 million Seattle transportation levy might look good on the surface, but it doesn't go very deep.

9 years ago

Democratic presidential candidates from left, former Virginia Sen. Jim Webb, Sen. Bernie Sanders, o...

Kipp Robertson

Winner of Democratic presidential debate wasn’t anyone on stage

There was a clear winner of the Democratic presidential debate Tuesday night, too bad for those participating it wasn't anyone on stage.

9 years ago

Former Seattle Ethics Commission Chair calls I-122 flawed