RON AND DON

Aggressive immigration policy making things worse

Jun 19, 2018, 2:56 PM | Updated: 2:56 pm

A new CNN poll found that 58 percent of Republicans support separating children from their parents at the southern border. While the poll doesn’t delve into the reasons why, there are two popular lines presented by the White House: there is a crisis at our border with Mexico and by stepping foot in the US, people have broken the law, therefore they should be treated like the criminals that they are.

Now, if you are a hard-line anti-immigration person, I doubt I’m going to change your mind. I would like to offer up a few interesting points supported by facts and research.

But first, an emotional common sense plea. Can we all pause for a moment and ask ourselves why people are making the journey to the United States in the first place? They aren’t on vacation. How desperate would you have to be to literally walk to a country where you didn’t speak the language and had no guarantee of work or shelter? This is more of a rhetorical exercise in empathy. When many of these people do make it into the States, they end up working jobs that Americans refuse to do. Just go ask the apple growers in Eastern Washington if you don’t believe me.

Now, let’s talk crisis at the border. The notion here is that there is a flood of immigrants and embedded among them are MS-13 gang members and other criminals. Turns out, according to the Department of Homeland Security’s own statistics, arrests for border infractions has been in a steady decline for two decades.

There is an unexpected dynamic happening with immigrants the more that the U.S. clamps down. It actually makes things worse. In his most recent episode of Revisionist History, bestselling author Malcom Gladwell explores this with the help of the Mexican Migration Project. The MMP is the most comprehensive database on the movements of migrants across the southern border. Prior to the U.S. clampdown at the border, most migrants did not want to stay in the States. They would come north for part of the year, make some money, then return to their homes and families.

Once the U.S. started to clamp down, it actually forced people to make an impossible choice. Stay in the U.S. full time and not see their family, or try and figure out a way to bring the wife and kids north. By restricting their movements, millions of people felt compelled to stay in the U.S. permanently. It’s exactly the opposite of the intention of increased security. The Mexican Migration Project has calculated that if the United States had done nothing at the border, there would actually be a third fewer immigrants in the U.S. than we have now. It’s counter intuitive, right? It’s called circular migration, and just to reiterate: at least half of all migrant workers would work part of the year doing jobs Americans don’t want to do, then they would return to their homes.

It turns out that the more hardline we get, the worse the problem will be. Plus, do we really want to keep young children in cages?

Ron and Don

...

KIRO Newsradio Newsdesk

Ron and Don’s last show on KIRO Radio

Last night was Ron and Don’s last show on KIRO Radio.

5 years ago

Kelly Herzberg in her natural habitat. (Photo by Rachel Belle)...

Rachel Belle

In Seattle, a personal shopper and stylist who only shops at thrift stores

If you think you can't afford a personal stylist, head to the thrift store with Sweet Kelly Anne Styling's Kelly Herzberg who will pull hundreds of pieces for you to try on.

5 years ago

Viaduct waterfront...

Ron Upshaw

What do we do with the waterfront after the viaduct is gone?

After the viaduct is taken down, we'll be left with a choice: What do we do with one of the most beautiful waterfronts in the country?

5 years ago

(MyNorthwest)...

Ron Upshaw

Shower Thoughts: Ichiro can give Mariners fans something to root for

Rumor has it that Ichiro might make a comeback next year, and I for one welcome it.

5 years ago

Border wall...

Ron Upshaw

Trying to figure out why people want Trump’s border wall

A little over 40 percent of Americans now support the idea of a border wall, but what is it about it that seems so attractive?

5 years ago

Dan McCartney, Pierce County Sheriff...

Don O'Neill

Why you could hear kids’ voices on Pierce County Sheriff radios Monday night

Sometimes, "gone but not forgotten" isn't always how slain officers are remembered. But in Pierce County, a special effort is being made to commemorate a fallen deputy.

5 years ago

Aggressive immigration policy making things worse