AP: 6bd9a70a-8bb7-4bbb-a213-72e8c6a29a08
Fewer and fewer of people charged with crimes will ever get to the court room and plead their case to a judge. Attorneys have mixed feelings on the way these plea bargains are reached, or how some are pressured into the deals. (AP Photo/Mary Murphy, Pool)

You might also be interested in:
listen Listen: Is taking a plea bargain justice?
Our judicial system is so overloaded, said Fan, that plea bargains are seen as a quick way to avoid the time and cost associated with going to trial.

When you get charged with a crime in this country, you have the right to your day in court. But, more often than not, you won't get that far.

According to an article in the New York Times, the vast majority of felony cases nationwide end in a plea bargain before trial begins.

"Plea bargains have been common for more than a century, but lately they have begun to put the trial system out of business in some courtrooms," wrote Richard A. Oppel Jr. "By one count, fewer than one in 40 felony cases now make it to trial, according to data from nine states that have published such records since the 1970s, when the ratio was about one in 12."

Washington state appears to be somewhere in the middle. So far this year, 26,591 criminal cases have been filed in Superior Court. Of those, 1,100, or about 1 in 26, have actually seen trial.

"The reality is that the vast majority of cases are concluded by plea bargain," said Mary Fan, an assistant professor of law at the University of Washington and a former federal prosecutor. "In many jurisdictions you may have sort of systematic procedures to offer plea bargains, almost like an assembly line."

Our judicial system is so overloaded, said Fan, that plea bargains are seen as a quick way to avoid the time and cost associated with going to trial. And in recent decades, she said, tougher sentencing laws have given prosecutors more tools to leverage a plea.

"Guilty pleas have become a powerful way of doing triage," she said. "Defense attorney often say that this comes at the expense of people making fully informed and free judgments about their fate."

While a plea deal can be a welcome break for those guilty of a crime, some say it robs those who are innocent of their chance to prove it in court.

"It's very difficult to admit that you did something you didn't do," said Kurt Boehl, a Seattle criminal defense attorney. "We see this more and more with these type of plea bargains, these types of tools that the prosecution is now using to essentially coerce these pleas so that they don't have to spend money going to trial regardless of what the truth is."

Boehl said nearly 100 percent of his cases begin with some sort of bargaining or offer from the prosecution. If his client rejects their offer, he said, the state will typically make the charges against the defendant more severe by amending the charge to a higher degree or adding some sort of enhancement.

"All of these things, my client would be looking at doing substantially more jail time," Boehl said, which makes rejecting the offer more difficult. "It's frustrating for me to know that my client didn't commit an offense but he's entering a plea so that he won't have faced a more serious offense. I don't think that that's justice."

Brandi Kruse, 97.3 KIRO FM

share this story:
facebook
email


You might also be interested in:




Boy stranded in river after plunge over waterfall

A 13-year-old boy fell over a waterfall and was stranded for more than eight hours on a rock Saturday.


Ross&Burbank: Who can eat the most cheeseburgers?

Rachel Belle, Luke Burbank, Sean DeTore and Libby Denkmann go head to head with cheeseburgers... and whiskey.




One game still sticks in Doug Baldwin's craw

Seahawks wide receiver Doug Baldwin told "The Kevin Calabro Show" that Seattle's 6-3 loss to the Cleveland Browns sticks out among the more memorable games of his rookie season.


Trial of ex-P&G, Goldman board member starts in NY

The July 29, 2008, phone call between two titans of Wall Street began with the old friends exchanging mild pleasantries, but then quickly turned serious and _ by the government's account _ criminal.


Cocker spaniel rescued from 30-foot fall into well

Deputy sheriffs and rescue personnel in South Carolina have reunited a 4-year-old cocker spaniel with her family after she fell down a 30-foot well.

most popular

  1. 23 arrested in major King County gang crackdown
    Crime rates have gone down across the board in Washington, but a new gang sweep...
  2. Border bust: Drug mule ate 3 pounds of cocaine
    Some movies portray drug smuggling in a dramatic, glamorous way that makes drug...
  3. Boy stranded in river after plunge over waterfall
    A 13-year-old boy fell over a waterfall and was stranded for more than eight hours...
  4. Calabro: One game still sticks in Doug Baldwin's craw
    Seahawks wide receiver Doug Baldwin says Seattle's 6-3 loss to the Browns sticks...
  5. Seattle Kitchen recommends best pizza in town
    A trip to the newest pizza restaurant in Seattle got The Seattle Kitchen Show staff...




close

Is taking a plea bargain justice?

Tuesday, Sep 27, 2011

Our judicial system is so overloaded, said Fan, that plea bargains are seen as a quick way to avoid the time and cost associated with going to trial.
Share:
mynorthwest.com
Copyright © 2012 Bonneville International. All rights reserved.