JASON RANTZ

Rantz: Inslee’s orca task force could actually be hurting the whales

Nov 12, 2018, 7:28 AM

whale tracking, orcas, orca...

Southern resident orcas. (AP)

(AP)

Governor Jay Inslee, our absent leader busy trying to salvage his presidential campaign, is doing more harm than good when it comes to saving the Southern Resident orcas, at least when it comes to one idea recently instituted.

Inslee’s Southern Resident Killer Whale Task Force just recommended a ban on whale watching, which, according to KING 5, was just put into effect. Only, the ban actually hurts orcas according to one expert, and they didn’t even go through some basic review.

“I think going straight into a moratorium now, it’s going to be bad for the whales overall,” said Orca Conservancy Chief Scientist David Bain told KING 5. “On the water, the whale watch operators play a role in managing the behavior of other vessels. So, some people consider it a disadvantage that you can look out and see the whale watching boat and know where the whales are. But we are asking vessel operators to slow down when they are a half-mile away from the whales now. That means the sport fisherman who is running from port to his favorite fishing hole; he’s going to be going fast and not realize the whales are there. But if he sees the whale watch boats, he’ll know he needs to slow down.”

In their draft report, the Task Force took small vessels for whale watching to task for producing “relatively high-frequency underwater noise that can mask echolocation, making it more difficult for Southern Resident orcas to find and capture prey.“

But Bain says the task force pushed through their recommendation without doing any meaningful scientific research.

“The task force members got a packet that had details about all of the things that they were going to be voting on,” Bain told KING 5. “They had time to review it and understand the issue. This idea did not go through that process. It’s something somebody brought up in a discussion, and then 15 minutes later they are voting on it. Nobody took the time to ask what the science was and why the vessel working group did not support it in the first place.”

This is, of course, one expert’s take on an issue that surely has many sides. But it would appear that the unelected group went into the process already wanting to institutes plans without vetting them beyond their own preconceived notions. That’s obviously dangerous.

If the governor would stop pushing his presidential campaign, perhaps he could have stopped this from happening. But, with much of what Inslee tackles, this just gives the appearance of doing something that matters.

Listen to the Jason Rantz Show weekday mornings from 6-9 a.m. on KTTH 770 AM (or HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here.

RELATED: Task force released recommendations for Puget Sound whales
RELATED: Is the task force focused on the wrong solutions?

Jason Rantz on AM 770 KTTH
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to AM 770 KTTH weekdays at 3-7pm toThe Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

Burien lawsuit...

Jason Rantz

Exclusive: City of Burien sues King County for breaking contract in homeless camping ban

The City of Burien filed a lawsuit against King County for its refusal to enforce a homeless camping ban that was lawfully adopted.

1 hour ago

Image: The Stevens County Sheriff's Office says it recently received an odd call from a Sasquatch h...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Sheriff’s office asked legality of hunting Sasquatch in Stevens County

A Sasquatch hunter had an interesting question for the Stevens County sheriff. Is it legal to hunt Sasquatch?

18 hours ago

Image: Children bike past Wilson Elementary in Spokane....

Jason Rantz

Rantz: ‘Racist’ Spokane elementary school’s ‘slaves and hobos’ ignites controversy

After a teacher told students they could dress as "slaves and hobos" for an event, the Spokane NAACP cried foul.

2 days ago

Images: At left, Bellevue Police Department Officer Kevin Bereta is seen in his uniform. At right, ...

Julia Dallas

Bellevue officer injured in VP Harris motorcade recalls road to reclaiming benefits

Bellevue Police Officer Kevin Bereta's life changed while he was on VP Kamala Harris' service detail during her visit to Washington.

2 days ago

permanent supportive housing...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: You’re being lied to about permanent supportive housing in Redmond

Redmond residents rightly push back against permanent supportive housing as a solution for the homeless, as Seattle media get in the way.

3 days ago

WA State Attorney General Bob Ferguson campaigning.  (Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: On crime, Bob Ferguson campaign made its first massive blunder

The Bob Ferguson campaign wants you thinking his top priority is crime. His entire political history says otherwise.

4 days ago

Rantz: Inslee’s orca task force could actually be hurting the whales