MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Advocacy group says people with disabilities could get denied COVID-19 treatment

Mar 25, 2020, 9:16 AM

Coronavirus, covid side effects...

A nurse at a drive up COVID-19 coronavirus testing station set up by UW Medicine. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

(AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

If scarce resources force doctors to make life-and-death decisions in the coronavirus pandemic, what happens to those living with disabilities?

One advocacy group believes an adult with cystic fibrosis or Down syndrome could be effectively sentenced to death.

Disability Rights Washington filed a complaint with the federal government this week after plans for scarcity of resources were released by the Washington State Department of Health in conjunction with the Northwest Healthcare Regional Network, and by the University of Washington Medical Center. DRW finds these plans to be discriminatory and dangerous to individuals with disabilities.

If a person with a disability contracts coronavirus and hospitals do not have enough resources to treat everyone, then the person “may be de-prioritized in getting treatment,” said David Carlson, director of advocacy for DRW.

Ebola drug successful for another Washington coronavirus patient

“Someone who didn’t have one of those [disabilities] but still got sick may be seen as having a better upside,” he explained.

The plans state that patients’ health and age should be considered when deciding to whom to distribute resources, prioritizing those who have the greatest chance of surviving and living many more years.

The Department of Health plan directs medical professionals, when determining whether a patient should be admitted to intensive care or sent to palliative care, to “consider loss of reserves in energy, physical ability, cognition and general health.”

The UW Medical Center plan states the following:

The standard construct for medical resource allocation in time of scarcity is based upon a utilitarian framework, often stated as making decisions that provide the greatest good for the greatest number. It is worth noting that this stance differs from the standard approach of clinicians, who see their ethical obligation as advocating for and prioritizing the care of a particular patient.

Greatest good, in a protracted clinical situation such as the COVID-19 outbreak, is generally considered maximizing survival of patients with COVID-19 within the institution and the region. Overall survival may be further qualified as healthy, long-term survival, recognizing that this represents weighting the survival of young otherwise healthy patients more heavily than that of older, chronically debilitated patients. Such weighting has general support in medicine and society-at-large.

Carlson said that this creates “an opportunity to bring in lots of assumptions about quality of life” and length of life, when in reality, no one knows how long anyone will live.

“In these times, we need to be committed to our civil rights, and not adopt other methods of determining value in people, such as philosophical utilitarianism,” Carlson said.

For example, Carlson pointed to a 28-year-old Seattle woman with cystic fibrosis, a genetic disease affecting the lungs and causing a life expectancy of middle age. She is very healthy and has never been hospitalized for her condition, but fears that on paper, doctors may assume she has little time left to live and is not worth saving.

While neither plan explicitly states that a person with disabilities would be passed over for care, Carlson believes the wording was left vague intentionally.

“What worries me is, you leave it squishy, knowing how it could be used in a squishy manner, so you don’t have to own how it’s actually used,” Carlson said. Instead, “you could be clear, [say], ‘We’re not going to use this against people with disabilities.'”

DRW is calling on the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services’ Office of Civil Rights to direct the state to clearly declare that those with disabilities will be safe from discrimination. In place of a utilitarian system, DRW suggests people be treated on a first-come, first-served basis, or a lottery system.

Throughout history, people with disabilities have faced discrimination for how they were born — and in some cases, this has been fatal. The eugenics trend of the early 20th century held that people with disabilities were lesser human beings who detracted from society and did not deserve to live among the general populace. As a result, they were often put into institutions.

Luckily, society has come a long way in the past 50 years, but Carlson said that even now, people with disabilities are already routinely discriminated against in everyday health care. This can mean getting passed over for a transplant, for example. He worries what extremes this could be taken to if the COVID-19 situation becomes much more dire.

“Life is not math,” he said. “We need to figure out how to honor the policies we’ve laid out for decades around anti-discrimination.”

The Washington State Department of Health did not respond to a request for comment at press time. The story will be updated if a response is received.

MyNorthwest News

Image: Brightly colored eggs are set on a table on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington,...

Ted Buehner

Expect good Easter weekend weather for egg hunts, chilly evening Mariners games

Both Saturday and Sunday of Easter weekend will feature temperatures warming to around 60 degrees across much of Western Washington.

7 hours ago

Taylor Swift performs onstage during the Taylor Swift | The Eras Tour at Lumen Field on July 22, 20...

Micki Gamez, KIRO Newsradio and Bill Kaczaraba, MyNorthwest

Seattle tourism dollars break records following All-Star Week, Taylor Swift

It was a record-setting year for dollars flowing into Seattle from tourists.

8 hours ago

Image: A bridge in Carnation....

Julia Dallas

Carnation frustrated with Seattle again after 8th false emergency alarm induces widespread panic

Carnation citizens have faced a series of panic-inducing alarms after SPU's system for the Tolt Dam falsely sounded eight times.

9 hours ago

Grocery store shopper...

Bill Kaczaraba

Ways to deal with Seattle grocery store sticker shock

Seattle grocery store sticker shock continues to play havoc on locals, but there are ways to counter high prices.

10 hours ago

belltown hellcat social media...

Frank Sumrall

Infamous ‘Belltown Hellcat’ social media influencer charged with reckless driving

The social media influencer has been accused of driving 107 miles per hour through Belltown in a Dodge Hellcat.

11 hours ago

KIRO Newsradio gracie awards...

MyNorthwest Staff

KIRO Newsradio anchors receive Gracie Awards for outstanding work

Heather Bosch and Lisa Brooks, anchors at KIRO Newsradio, have been honored by the Alliance for Women in Media with prestigious Gracie Awards.

14 hours ago

Advocacy group says people with disabilities could get denied COVID-19 treatment