THE DAVID BOZE SHOW

They’re not the same

Apr 1, 2015, 9:31 AM | Updated: 11:49 am

If you must, David Boze suggests saying the GOP is wrong in priorities, should do more, or should d...

If you must, David Boze suggests saying the GOP is wrong in priorities, should do more, or should do less. But don't say there's no difference between Republicans and Democrats. (AP)

(AP)

I’ve been told that after the Republican-led state senate voted in favor of a highway package that included higher gas taxes, there is no difference between the parties and both are equally ignorant, obtuse and unconcerned about the plight of working Washingtonians or the problem of an ever bigger government.

Let’s look more closely at that.

Let’s grant that the transportation package is expensive. Does that make it not conservative? Conservatives agree we need to pay for new things when we buy them. New roads are needed, improvements have to be made, and gas tax dollars are guaranteed for highways.

Democrats try to divert highway/roads money elsewhere, Republicans preserve it. Democrats argue that amidst “functionally obsolete bridges and unsafe infrastructure” we should use hundreds of millions of gas tax dollars for bike trails and walking paths. Democrats want billions for inefficient light rail plans that, after more than a decade, have failed to reach promised goals, ridership or reach.

The state Department of Transportation refuses to make traffic congestion a factor of consideration when determining state projects. Democrats (including Governor Jay Inslee, who recently pretended otherwise when discussing I-405 tolls) have sided with WSDOT on this. Republicans have insisted WSDOT revise their decision making to include it.

Now for the State General Fund Budget:

Governor Jay Inslee released his plan for Washington state’s budget. It is a plan heavy on new taxes that includes a new carbon-tax that defined Washington employers as polluters and would have meant higher gas prices at the pump without the guarantee that those higher prices meant more investment in the state’s roads (whereas by law gas taxes must be spent on state roads/highways).

Democrats in the State House answered back showing the same appetite for new taxes, but not for the carbon-tax. Despite all the fundraising claims that Republican opposition to things like the carbon-tax meant the GOP was at war with the planet, House Democrats made the governor’s tax proposal disappear and instead inserted their own capital gains tax on Washington’s richest.

Of course the federal income tax started as a tax on “the richest” and is now a confusing, jumbled mess that impacts everyone. It is so complicated not even its enforcers can reliably interpret it, and it sucks up countless man-hours of otherwise productive time into citizen efforts to comply. Odds of a new capital gains tax staying only on the Super rich? Ask yourself if you’ve ever – in your life (or your grandmothers’) – heard political parties agree that there’s enough money for everybody – ever? No?

Me neither.

So I can look in my crystal ball – as can you – and see how this works. You start with the richest. After that, anything you do is not a new tax, but an extension of an existing tax and you keep extending until you get to the real money which is in the majority of people in the state of Washington. Get the camel’s nose under the tent, and you’re two-thirds there.

Which leaves us with the Republican-led Majority Coalition in the State Senate. They released their plan yesterday. No new taxes. They use the additional $3 billion the state is collecting from a better economy to satisfy state needs. They invest more than another billion in education.

In the plan, class size reduction is targeted to where studies show it would actually do the most good (for the most part). College tuition is reduced. State employee raises are changed to have a greater impact on the least paid. Mental health service funds are replenished.

No difference? You can disagree with certain decisions or priorities, but to claim no difference is to refuse to look at the arguments between officials in our state and what’s at stake should those arguments go another way. It’s to pretend that how you pay for roads and who gets to use them makes no difference. It’s to pretend that billions of new tax dollars would make no difference.

In short, it’s a liberal argument, because if you honestly think there is no real difference, why not give the left in this state all their funding priorities? Why not grant the governor and the House Democrats all their new taxes since supposedly no one will feel them any stronger than they would no tax at all.

Say the GOP is wrong in priorities, should do more, or should do less, but don’t say there’s no difference. Saying there’s no difference is arguing as a Democrat.

The David Boze Show

Seattle self-defense expert Lawrence Kane said the most common natural reaction for a person angry ...

Eric Mandel

Seattle self-defense expert: Would take a ‘miracle’ for Ben Carson’s story to be accurate

If the presidential race wasn't bizarre enough, we're now calling in experts to prove whether a potential American president lied about his ability to stab a friend.

8 years ago

After 13 years on the air, David Boze announces he’s leaving KTTH. (KTTH image)...

David Boze

David Boze announces he’s leaving KTTH

I leave the station I helped found in the hands of a great company and good people. I am incredibly grateful for the loyalty and kindness of my listeners.

8 years ago

Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson smiles during a campaign rally at West Memphis High Sc...

Jacob Rummel

Ben Carson tries to explain involvement with ‘propaganda’

It wasn't an intentional attempt to appeal to young voters, but Ben Carson did end up the victim of a situation youth fall prey to on a regular basis.

8 years ago

Bremerton football coach Joe Kennedy prays with players on the field. (AP)...

Jacob Rummel

Praying Bremerton coach garners support from legislators at state and federal level

As Bremerton football coach Joe Kennedy continues to defy the school district by praying at midfield after games, he's starting to garner support in legislatures at the state and federal level.

9 years ago

If voters pass the I-122 initiative, the average Seattle voter would be allotted four $25 vouchers,...

Eric Mandel

Former Seattle Ethics Commission Chair calls I-122 flawed

The aim of the I-122 campaign is to give power back to regular voters by creating a way to publicly finance city and mayoral elections. But will it?

9 years ago

Mayor Ed Murray’s Move Seattle levy promises maintenance and repair, including bridge moderni...

Kipp Robertson

Move Seattle levy raises more questions than it answers

The proposed $930 million Seattle transportation levy might look good on the surface, but it doesn't go very deep.

9 years ago

They’re not the same