MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Doctor searches for evidence that plastic surgery produces youth, beauty

Aug 2, 2013, 7:27 AM | Updated: 10:16 am

Dan Restione before and after his appearance on “Extreme Makeover” (left and center) an...

Dan Restione before and after his appearance on "Extreme Makeover" (left and center) and Dan Restione in 2012 (right.) (AP Photo/File)

(AP Photo/File)

It’s a huge industry in the U.S. and it’s all based on the idea that you’ll look younger and better than ever before.

The pitch is sometimes subtle and sometimes not, with ads and TV shows that boast, “Dreams really do come true! A dream transformed into a miracle!”

Ten years ago, I bought it hook, line, and scalpel. I was 40, plain and plump, and I’d fallen hard for a lovely lady. So I signed up for the TV show “Extreme Makeover.”

What I didn’t know then – couldn’t know – is just how much plastic surgery actually delivers on dreams of youth and beauty. Dr. Joshua Zimm of New York noticed the lack as well.

“There wasn’t a lot of data in the scientific literature that looked at any sort of objective measurement to determine whether [plastic surgeons] were effecting age and/or attractiveness,” says Zimm.

So Zimm did a small survey using before and after pictures. He released his results this week.

In terms of youth? “We did see an overall reduction in age of about 3.1 years,” says Zimm.

But what about beauty? “There wasn’t a statistically significant improvement in attractiveness,” he says.

So: You pay big money and the “miracle” is you look a few years younger, but not more attractive. Zimm admits this is a small survey and not the last word on the practical effects of plastic surgery, but it fits perfectly with my experience.

After surgeries, six weeks of bandages, and a dentist visit so excruciatingly painful I tore the armrest off the chair and had to be sedated, I didn’t get the girl. I didn’t get any other girls. My new teeth started to break, my cheekbones sank back out of sight, and the fat they liposuctioned out of me was quickly replaced. My chin implant is still in there, but it’s not a huge selling point on the romance market.

It’s a far cry from the promises of the TV show doctors.

Now, Dr. Zimm says prospective patients do have other motives. “They don’t want to look as tired, they don’t want to look angry, they don’t want to look as sad.”

Good luck with that because you know what makes me look tired, sad, and angry, doc? Going through surgery and reality TV hell to look 37 and-a-half instead of 40 and not getting the girl.

I’m just saying…

MyNorthwest News

Seattle arson vacant buildings...

Bill Kaczaraba

Seattle Mayor to address city’s arson problem in vacant buildings

Seattle Mayor Bruce Harrell has proposed emergency legislation to address the escalating issue of fires and arson in vacant buildings.

42 minutes ago

Madison Valley girl missing...

Frank Sumrall

13-year-old Madison Valley girl missing since Tuesday

The Seattle Police Department (SPD) is asking the public to keep an eye out for a missing 13-year-old girl from Madison Valley.

53 minutes ago

Doolittle Raider...

Feliks Banel

Remembering Enumclaw’s Doolittle Raider Edward Saylor

Edward Saylor volunteered to be a flight engineer on the dangerous "Doolittle Raid" mission 75 years ago.

4 hours ago

discolored water tacoma...

Frank Sumrall

Two months of discolored water at Tacoma school leads to frustrated faculty and parents

Birney Elementary School in Tacoma has been dealing with brown, discolored water since February, with teachers and parents demanding answers.

4 hours ago

UW rape...

Frank Sumrall

UW football player pleads not guilty to raping mulitple women

18-year-old UW running back Tylin "Tybo" Rogers has been charged with one count of second-degree rape and another count of third-degree rape.

5 hours ago

Photo: In this Dec. 27, 2012, file photo, a variety of military-style semi-automatic rifles obtaine...

James Lynch

State commissioner to decide on high-capacity magazine ban

The Washington State Commissioner held a hearing on whether the ban on high-capacity magazines should be lifted while the full court considers the matter.

16 hours ago

Doctor searches for evidence that plastic surgery produces youth, beauty