JASON RANTZ

Rantz: Transgender rights activists should side with Trump bathroom roll back

Feb 23, 2017, 12:28 PM

If you’re concerned over the recent President Donald Trump move to roll back President Barack Obama-era transgender bathroom guidance, respectfully, you shouldn’t be. In fact, you should welcome this move because it will actually provide closure on an important issue.

Listen: Transgender issues explained

I admit this will be immediately derided controversial and half the lunatic tweets I’ll get criticizing me will be informed by an ideological bigotry on their part (they won’t even read this blog before getting angry). But hear me out: if this is a civil or human right, then you want the courts to decide this, not any one president.

The problem with guidance coming from any administration – Left, Right or Center – is that it’s subject to the person in office, not an absolute determination of law. Wouldn’t you rather there be one firm answer? You can’t claim something is a civil right, but not want the court to decide. Would you prefer each administration decide you’ll have bathroom rights for only four or eight years at a time?

Related: Stop whining about ‘joke’ and prove your point on transgender bathroom bill

Absolutely nothing has changed as a result of the Trump move. His position, as president, is that transgender bathroom and locker room use is a state’s rights issue. He made that position crystal clear when he ran; personally, he’s stated multiple times he doesn’t care who uses the bathrooms and has strongly criticized states that aimed to curb these rights. But his ideological position is that the states should decide, barring a Supreme Court review (it’s the same position that many Progressive activists seemed content with when they passed marijuana legalization, despite it being against federal law).

States like Washington have decided in favor of transgender bathroom rights; a decision I agree with. States that support this as a right are already implementing it. Other states activists find problematic? The guidance was held up in courts before going into effect and the issue will be heard by SCOTUS. Let it be heard if you’re confident in the right.

Related: Very troubling response to transgender bathroom issue

If it’s not deemed a right, then you were wrong. It’s okay to be wrong and it’s okay to actually try to enact change in other ways. In fact, rather than impose your will on people who are against it, how about you have the audacity to have civil dialogues with people who disagree with your position and win them over? LGBTQ rights have come a very long way through dialogue and exposure on the issues. We’ve seen these dialogues lead to great success. But too often, we hurl insults at people who disagree with our position then try to impose our views on those opposed. We’d all be better served if we talked more openly and honestly about it.

Jason Rantz on AM 770 KTTH
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to AM 770 KTTH weekdays at 3-7pm toThe Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

Image: Seattle Police Department officers arrest a woman caught driving a stolen car full of stolen...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Activists to harass cops with Seattle Police complaint campaign

A Seattle Police complaint campaign by activists amounts to little more than harassment. But it could backfire, generating sympathy for cops.

4 hours ago

Image: A Boeing 737 Max 10 airliner taxis past a hanger on the flight line before its first flight ...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: It’s time for Washington to worry about Boeing surviving

Boeing controversy after controversy, plus bad press, threatens the company's future. Washington should be very worried right now.

1 day ago

Image: Republican presidential candidate and former President Donald Trump speaks to supporters dur...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Trump ‘bloodbath’ controversy is the latest media invention

When President Donald Trump used the term "bloodbath," the media became unhinged. He wasn't talking about violence, but the auto industry.

2 days ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: KTTH Roundtable: Will TikTok Be Banned?

A local mystery was solved in Los Angeles (with a surprising end result) and Jason Rantz and Bryan Suits tackle the arguments behind the TikTok ban. Listen to The Bryan Suits Show weekdays from 6 a.m. – 9 a.m. on AM 770 KTTH or on-demand wherever you listen to podcasts. Listen to The Jason Rantz […]

3 days ago

Inset: Headshot of Seattle Police Department (SPD) Captain Deanna Nollette; Primary photo: An SPD v...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Officer suing Seattle police for gender discrimination accused of gender bias

Seattle police officers said Captain Deanna Nollette, who sued the department for gender bias, is "notorious" for mistreating female officers.

5 days ago

Kim Wyman...

Bill Kaczaraba

Is ex-Secretary of State Kim Wyman running for that office again?

Rumors are spreading that former Washington Secretary of State Kim Wyman is running for that office again.

5 days ago

Rantz: Transgender rights activists should side with Trump bathroom roll back