MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Is it free speech to call someone a ‘racist’?

Aug 17, 2017, 6:07 AM

free speech...

White nationalist demonstrators clash with police at the entrance to Lee Park in Charlottesville, Va., Saturday, Aug. 12, 2017. Gov. Terry McAuliffe declared a state of emergency and police dressed in riot gear ordered people to disperse after chaotic violent clashes between white nationalists and counter protestors. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)

(AP Photo/Steve Helber)

After the tragedy in Charlottesville, the Twitter account “Yes, You’re a Racist” blew up with activity.
The account identifies people who took part in the white nationalist demonstration.

“This could be libelous,” KIRO Radio’s Dave Ross wondered. “Who knows what’s really in their hearts?”

RELATED: College student attacked for taking photo with VP Pence

After all, being labeled a racist is like social poison, as James Allsup found out. He resigned his position as president of the College Republicans at Washington State University after it was revealed he attended the Charlottesville demonstration. He initially claimed he was covering the event for his YouTube channel, but it turned out that he was there in a more official capacity than that — he was a speaker.

“Principles of defamation apply here,” said former state Attorney General Rob McKenna. “Let’s say he was just walking by the rally and happened to be photographed and they claimed he was attending it and hanging out with the neo-Nazis. If he can show that those claims are false and knowingly false, he might have a defamation claim.”

“But that doesn’t seem to be the case with (Allsup),” McKenna said. “He went to this rally to speak against the removal of Robert E. Lee’s statue. He ended up being caught up with all the far right people who were there. He did not exit the rally when he realized they were there. So he probably wouldn’t have a successful defamation claim. Absent libel or slander, people have a right to say bad things about you if they disagree with what you are doing, just as you have a right to show up at a rally for a cause you believe in.”

It comes down to free speech from all angles. But there is a concern, McKenna notes, about hampering free speech by throwing around labels.

“Where this becomes troubling, of course, is when any group tags someone with a negative label, like being a racist, because they choose to attend certain events or express certain views,” McKenna said. “So we worry about free speech being chilled by the fear that you will be labeled something very unpleasant.”

“And the right is doing that by referring to people with the counter demonstrators as the ‘radical left,'” he said. “So they are trying to engage in that same kind of labeling activity, that has risks for sure, but it is within their rights to do. The problem they face is a simple political matter – being labeled a racist is a far more toxic matter than being labeled part of the radical left.”

MyNorthwest News

lead cookware washington...

Frank Sumrall

Washington becomes first state to ban lead in cookware

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee signed the Lead in Cookware Act Thursday, banning lead from any products used to cook food.

47 seconds ago

delta sexual assault...

Frank Sumrall

Woman sues Delta Air Lines after sexually assaulted on flight by employee

Last year, a woman was sexually assaulted on a Delta Air Lines flight from Phoenix to Seattle by an airline employee.

60 minutes ago

Photo: Lewis and Clark High School students thought quickly to save their track coach's life....

Julia Dallas

Spokane high school students save track coach’s life after his heart stops

Two Spokane high school students used their quick thinking and past training to save their track coach's life last week.

3 hours ago

Image: Brightly colored eggs are set on a table on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington,...

Ted Buehner

Expect good Easter weekend weather for egg hunts, chilly evening Mariners games

Both Saturday and Sunday of Easter weekend will feature temperatures warming to around 60 degrees across much of Western Washington.

15 hours ago

Taylor Swift performs onstage during the Taylor Swift | The Eras Tour at Lumen Field on July 22, 20...

Micki Gamez, KIRO Newsradio and Bill Kaczaraba, MyNorthwest

Seattle tourism dollars break records following All-Star Week, Taylor Swift

It was a record-setting year for dollars flowing into Seattle from tourists.

16 hours ago

Image: A bridge in Carnation....

Julia Dallas

Carnation frustrated with Seattle again after 8th false emergency alarm induces widespread panic

Carnation citizens have faced a series of panic-inducing alarms after SPU's system for the Tolt Dam falsely sounded eight times.

17 hours ago

Is it free speech to call someone a ‘racist’?