Check your gain if your residence has been rentedApril 9, 2014 @ 8:26 am
The sale of a primary residence can be the largest cash day of a consumer's life.
Since tax day is looming, it's a good time to check and see how that residence was purchased and used before earmarking all of the proceeds. If your principal residence has been rented in the past, you may not get to exclude all of the gain.
In a recent example, we explained that a couple had sold their home and purchased two Arizona golf-course condominiums with the proceeds - one for their primary residence and another as a rental - and still put some money in their pocket. What made the deal interesting was that they had purchased the original home six years ago via a tax-deferred exchange.
While investors had turned rental properties into principal residences for years, the timing for claiming the $500,000 principal residence exemption ($250,000 for a single person) on a home acquired via an exchange wasn't clarified until late 2004 and then changed to its present status in 2008 with two additions to the rules.
Before 2004, taxpayers were left to guess how long they had to hold an investment property before converting it a primary residence -- or when it was safe to sell it and pocket any gain.
The American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 spelled out the steps necessary to create a "safe harbor" with the Internal Revenue Service for investors who ended up living in one of their rentals. The key stipulation was the exchange property must be held for five years in order to qualify for the primary residence exemption. The five-year period curtailed people from buying investments then immediately moving into them and quickly selling them simply to avoid a capital gains tax.
In order to qualify for the $500,000 exclusion ($250,000 for single persons), homeowners must own and use the property as a principal residence for two out of five years prior to the date of sale. Second, the owner must not have used this same exclusion in the two-year period prior to the sale. So, the only limit on the number of times a taxpayer can claim this exclusion is once in any two-year period.
Under the exchange rules, commonly known as 1031 exchanges or Starker exchanges, a taxpayer who exchanges property that was held for productive use or investment for "like-kind" property may acquire the replacement property on a tax-free basis. Because the replacement property generally has a low carryover tax basis, the taxpayer will have taxable gain upon the sale of the replacement property.
When the homeowner converts the replacement property into a principal residence, however, the taxpayer may shelter some or all of this gain from income taxation. The committee that drafted the five-year rule wrote that proposal "balances the concerns associated with these provisions to reduce this tax shelter concern without unduly limiting the exclusion on sales or exchanges of principal residences."
While the five-year requirement is a helpful guideline, it does significantly extend the timeline for people who might consider moving into their own rental. That's because an investment property needs to be rented (used as an investment) after an exchange to show the exchange was clearly an investment-for-investment transaction.
Accountants say the exchanged property should be held for at least two years as an investment property before an owner considers converting it to a primary residence.
According to Rob Keasal, real estate tax specialist in the Seattle accounting firm of Peterson Sullivan, the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008 amended Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code. Section 121 no longer permits homeowners to take the full tax-free exclusion on the sale of real property that was held and used as their primary residence if there was any non-qualified (rental) use of the real property prior to it being held and used as their primary residence. The gain will have to be prorated for the time period when was rented.
For example, if you rented out a home for two years and then occupied it for two years, then sold - you will end up paying capital gain tax on 50 percent of the gain from your proceeds.
Exchange facilitators and tax attorneys caution that all exchanges must meet the "facts and circumstances" test regardless of how much time has passed before converting an investment property to a personal residence. In a nutshell: It's all about intent. If it's clear at the time of the exchange that a taxpayer intended to use the exchange property as a primary residence, the exchange can be challenged.
While a tax-deferred exchange may appear just like a "sale" for you, your real estate agent and parties associated with the deal, Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Service code specifically requires that an exchange take place. That means that one property must be exchanged for another property, rather than sold for cash.
The exchange is what distinguishes a Section 1031 tax-deferred transaction from a sale and purchase. The exchange is created by using an intermediary (or exchange facilitator) and the required exchange documentation.
If you've traded for a lakefront getaway condo and now think you would like to live there, make sure you own it for five years before attempting to pocket any principal residence exemption.
Tom Kelly's new novel "Cold Crossover" is now available in print at bookstores everywhere and in both print and Ebook form from a variety of digital outlets. Follow real estate agent and former basketball coach Ernie Creekmore as investigates the disappearance of his star player on a late-night boat. Check out the national reviews and put "Cold Crossover" on your list.
Working Through It
State troopers stay on the job despite seeing their own homes burn down
Fans turning to the secondary market will pay a hefty premium to see the Seahawks
As crews battle multiple wildfires, we take a look back at the at fire prevention's spokesbear
Please login below with your Facebook, Twitter, Google+ or Disqus account. Existing MyNorthwest account holders will need to create a new Disqus account or use one of the social logins provided below. Thank you.