JASON RANTZ

Protesters think protesters who break laws shouldn’t be punished

Jul 29, 2015, 10:17 AM | Updated: Jul 30, 2015, 9:20 am

Jason Rantz says protesters from the Black Lives Matter movement are making the argument that prote...

Jason Rantz says protesters from the Black Lives Matter movement are making the argument that protesters in the movement who break the law not actually be punished because that's not progressive. (KIRO Radio file photo)

(KIRO Radio file photo)

A number of protesters from the Black Lives Matter movement are making the argument that protesters in the movement who break the law should not be punished because that’s not progressive, man!

In an editorial in The Stranger, Eliana Horn, Cat Cunningham, Beck Gross and Gillian Locascio (“four white Jews and queers,” as they say) complain that the City of Seattle is charging protesters who they believe broke the law during the many protests over the last several months. They argue that this action isn’t living up to Seattle values:

The City of Seattle brands itself as a progressive city emblematized by Chief Sealth on the city’s official corporate seal. Yet, like other American cities, Seattle’s police department and our local criminal justice system disproportionately target people of color. According to the Seattle Police Department (SPD) arrest figures, the total black drug arrest rate was over 13 times the white drug arrest rate in 2006. As of 2014, the King County Juvenile Detention Center was locking up more black youth than white youth, although there are six times as many white children in Seattle as black ones.

They don’t provide any context as to why people of color are being “target[ed]” because then they might have to point to a reason beyond racism. There’s also some humor in that these four white people are complaining about how the SPD targets people of color, when these four, in particular, were arrested and tried for pedestrian interference.

How about this novel concept: if you break the law as an adult who should know better, you should be arrested and tried.

Related: Try to decipher this Seattle nonsense

What I love about this particular movement is how they don’t quite understand the concept of civil disobedience, which many of the protesters tout as necessary. Well, it’s not entirely civil disobedience if you’re not breaking the law and getting arrested for it. The reason why civil disobedience is so powerful is that you actually sacrifice something meaningful for the sake of social change; acting cowardly, trying to avoid an arrest, is hardly noble and certainly doesn’t show any willingness to make scarifies on behalf of your beliefs.

They write: “We are fighting for a world where all people can live without fear of police brutality. Today, we ask [Seattle City Attorney] Pete Holmes: how are you using your position to challenge white supremacy?”

I guess I’ll answer: maybe he’s doing it by charging four white people who he viewed as breaking the law, who are now using their white privilege to stop future prosecutions against them.

Jason Rantz on AM 770 KTTH
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to AM 770 KTTH weekdays at 3-7pm toThe Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

Image: Seattle Police Department officers arrest a woman caught driving a stolen car full of stolen...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Activists to harass cops with Seattle Police complaint campaign

A Seattle Police complaint campaign by activists amounts to little more than harassment. But it could backfire, generating sympathy for cops.

7 hours ago

Image: A Boeing 737 Max 10 airliner taxis past a hanger on the flight line before its first flight ...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: It’s time for Washington to worry about Boeing surviving

Boeing controversy after controversy, plus bad press, threatens the company's future. Washington should be very worried right now.

1 day ago

Image: Republican presidential candidate and former President Donald Trump speaks to supporters dur...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Trump ‘bloodbath’ controversy is the latest media invention

When President Donald Trump used the term "bloodbath," the media became unhinged. He wasn't talking about violence, but the auto industry.

2 days ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: KTTH Roundtable: Will TikTok Be Banned?

A local mystery was solved in Los Angeles (with a surprising end result) and Jason Rantz and Bryan Suits tackle the arguments behind the TikTok ban. Listen to The Bryan Suits Show weekdays from 6 a.m. – 9 a.m. on AM 770 KTTH or on-demand wherever you listen to podcasts. Listen to The Jason Rantz […]

3 days ago

Inset: Headshot of Seattle Police Department (SPD) Captain Deanna Nollette; Primary photo: An SPD v...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Officer suing Seattle police for gender discrimination accused of gender bias

Seattle police officers said Captain Deanna Nollette, who sued the department for gender bias, is "notorious" for mistreating female officers.

5 days ago

Kim Wyman...

Bill Kaczaraba

Is ex-Secretary of State Kim Wyman running for that office again?

Rumors are spreading that former Washington Secretary of State Kim Wyman is running for that office again.

6 days ago

Protesters think protesters who break laws shouldn’t be punished