JASON RANTZ

Attacks against Amazon fueled by shoddy reporting

Aug 18, 2015, 5:31 PM | Updated: Aug 21, 2015, 2:19 pm

It turns out, everyone is miserable. Yet, we’re focused on Amazon because an anecdotal, contr...

It turns out, everyone is miserable. Yet, we're focused on Amazon because an anecdotal, contrived New Yorks Times article told us to, KIRO Radio's Jason Rantz says. (AP)

(AP)

The Amazon attacks are getting out of hand and the way it’s being spun to generate more clickable content for websites, more eyes on silly news reports, and radio reports is starting to bug me.

It’s bothering me, not just because I’m a fan of Amazon and love to support local companies, especially ones meaningful to the economy, but because most of the story is essentially being pushed via inconsistent anecdotes and really shoddy, meaningless data points.

The entire conversation was fueled by a co-authored article in the New York Times. A really, really, really long article that was light on sourced-materials and heavy on anecdotes, much of which was anonymous.

“One of the most fascinating beliefs at Amazon, is that being sort of socially cohesive and making people feel good does not always produce the best results,” co-author Jodi Kantor told CBS. “So there is a culture of tough criticism there.”

And because that is not what a lot of workers expect &#8212 this idea that you’ll be suffocated to death with vacuous praise &#8212 this story is being framed in a way that is judging Amazon more harshly than it should be.

For one, the article didn’t appear to really represent Amazon in a fair way. I’ll fight Kantor’s anecdotes with other anecdotes from people on the record, willing to put their name and face to the comments.

Aaron Kerson told KIRO TV, “It’s been super enjoyable” and been a “very supportive environment.”

“I was blown away by what I read,” he added.

And not just that, an independent editor with the New York Times is going after the story, arguing it’s hardly great journalism. Margaret Sullivan wrote: “The evidence against Amazon, while powerful, is largely anecdotal, not data-driven. And anecdotes can be used and interpreted in any number of ways … For such a damning result, presented with so much drama, that doesn’t seem like quite enough.”

And this whole thing started an equally spurious debate over whether or not tech workers, in general, are unhappy.

In a KING 5 report, we’re told they are. They quote a study by TINYpulse, a Seattle startup that surveys workers. They looked into more than 5,000 tech workers who were asked to rate how happy they were, but only 19 percent said they were happy.

“So they’re actually less happy as a group, despite all these positive things they have going for them,” the CEO of TINYPulse told KING 5.

I gotta say, even though 19 percent is obviously low, can we give you some context? All other workers rated their happiness at 22 percent, so it’s not like there’s a huge disparity between unhappy techies and super happy accountants.

It turns out, everyone is miserable. Yet, we’re focused on Amazon because an anecdotal, contrived New York Times article told us to.

Jason Rantz on AM 770 KTTH
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to AM 770 KTTH weekdays at 3-7pm toThe Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

Image: The Stevens County Sheriff's Office says it recently received an odd call from a Sasquatch h...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Sheriff’s office asked legality of hunting Sasquatch in Stevens County

A Sasquatch hunter had an interesting question for the Stevens County sheriff. Is it legal to hunt Sasquatch?

8 hours ago

Image: Children bike past Wilson Elementary in Spokane....

Jason Rantz

Rantz: ‘Racist’ Spokane elementary school’s ‘slaves and hobos’ ignites controversy

After a teacher told students they could dress as "slaves and hobos" for an event, the Spokane NAACP cried foul.

1 day ago

Images: At left, Bellevue Police Department Officer Kevin Bereta is seen in his uniform. At right, ...

Julia Dallas

Bellevue officer injured in VP Harris motorcade recalls road to reclaiming benefits

Bellevue Police Officer Kevin Bereta's life changed while he was on VP Kamala Harris' service detail during her visit to Washington.

1 day ago

permanent supportive housing...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: You’re being lied to about permanent supportive housing in Redmond

Redmond residents rightly push back against permanent supportive housing as a solution for the homeless, as Seattle media get in the way.

2 days ago

WA State Attorney General Bob Ferguson campaigning.  (Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: On crime, Bob Ferguson campaign made its first massive blunder

The Bob Ferguson campaign wants you thinking his top priority is crime. His entire political history says otherwise.

3 days ago

Image: Jason Rantz of AM 770 KTTH is defending his honor against a partisan smear by The Stranger w...

Jason Rantz

Jason Rantz defends his honor against partisan smear by The Stranger

Charles Mudede smeared Jason Rantz in a blog post for the Stranger. It prompted a response from Rantz, who had to defend his own honor.

5 days ago

Attacks against Amazon fueled by shoddy reporting