November 16, 2009 - 1:05 am

Government at its worst

Last week, I spent a considerable amount of time on the show talking one of the great scourges government has unleashed on the people: Red light and speeding cameras.

Lying politicians sell the cameras as a tool to increase public safety. But study after study has shown that red light cameras actually increase the number of accidents at intersections where they've been installed.

The latest report came courtesy of KCBS-TV in Los Angeles. They looked at 32 intersections that had installed red light cameras. At 20 of the 32, the accident racte increased. Three remained the same. At only nine intersections did the accident rate decrease.

Now we learn that Seattle City Councilman Nick Licata is proposing to add more red light and speeding cameras in the city.

At least Licata isn't lying about the motivation. Instead of the bogus public safety line most politicians try to peddle, Licata admits that his plan is simply to raise revenues.

But if the cameras actually make the streets more dangerous, and their only motivation is to transfer money from citizens to politicians, isn't that combo an example of government at its absolute worst?



  • Add A Comment

  • sprachfuzzi wrote...
    I totally agree
    that intersections with cameras can cause more accidents. I am so paranoid about accidentally being in the intersection at the wrong time that I unnecessarily slam on my brakes as soon as the light turns yellow. I've come really close to being rear-ended a number of times and have probably ticked off tons of people behind me. I have no problem driving through intersections without cameras.
  • holodeck wrote...
    Free right turn
    I got a ticket for very slowly taking a free right turn on the camera. Lots of time to see if it was safe and all that. $124. If anyone here has ever broken ANY kind of trafic law, no mater how minor, let us know. Never coming to a complete stop, crossing the double line ect. And if you have, do the right thing and send $124 the the government.
  • microP wrote...
    Tradeoff
    It's simple, as with everything, there is a tradeoff. If Licata looks to increase revenue, he will get less safety, more people killed and injured. If tickets are written with revenue in mind, they will increase revenue. If with safety, more safety.
  • Chuck Gould wrote...
    Experience in other cities demonstrates how to reduce accidents....
    increasing the length of the "yellow" cycle by about 1 second solves the rear-ending problem.

    I'm no big fan of the cameras, but if they are at a greater number of intersections people will adjust their driving style for all intersections. When there are only a few red light intersections, people tend to freak out and over-react to the yellow at those particular corners.

    There's no excuse, in computerized age, to put a more user-friendly yellow on stop lights. Five seconds before the end of the green cycle the yellow light should start to flash- once per second, while the green light remained on. Anybody looking at the signal would be aware that the light was about to turn yellow. All the Type A's could floor it and fly through the intersection in time to clear, and anybody following a car where nothing shows over the top of the driver's seat except two tiny little hands on the steering wheel and some blue hair will realize the car in front is probably going to stop.

  • Chuck Gould wrote...
    And don't blame government for a lack of personal responsibility....
    Driver A stops abruptly to avoid running a red light. Driver B, in the following car, plows into the back of Driver A.

    So who's to blame in a rear end collission? The traffic light? Nope. Driver A? Nope, Driver A was obeying a traffic signal. Driver B? Yep. Driver B failed to follow at a safe distance and was unable to respond and brake in time to avoid colliding with Driver A.

    Blaming in on the "government" because Driver A stopped for a traffic signal is inconsistent with a philosophy that prioritizes personal responsibility.

    Driver A could have slammed on the brakes because a small kid or a dog ran into the street from between two parked cars, or any other reason. Driver A has to be concerned with the operation of his or her own car, and if safe operation or avoiding an accident calls for a sudden stop, it's up to the following driver to stop safely as well.

    Nobody should be forced to make poor decisions behind the wheel because the impatient fool immediately behind is following too closely.

  • otmilkr wrote...
    Just obey the law, it's simple.
    I think those stats are twisted by someone who has a bad driving record. Cameras in school zones dramatically slow people down. Cameras caught the person who killed Officer Brenton. I would be in favor of a camera every 10 square feet, everywhere. In fact, if there was a Govt camera in every room of every person's house, there would be little to no domestic violence or child molestation. Like it or not, just like illegals from Mexico, there will be lots more cameras in the future, not less. Stop speeding, stop worrying about taking "free" right turns, and simply OBEY the law.
  • Bill Law wrote...
    otmilkr
    Uncle Adolph would have loved you.
  • Paul Kersey wrote...
    otmilkr has a sense of humor...
    something genuine Seattle liberals have a shortage of.

    otmilkr wants cameras everywhere, the constitution abolished ("it's a dinosaur document"), UN troops sweeping neighborhoods confiscating guns...and knife control (with a new federal agency set up)....

    Although these ideas are not too extreme for the typical Seattle liberal...I smell some bad fish.

  • GlassBoxShoes wrote...
    Ignore the cameras...
    Just drive safely and you won't get your picture snapped. It's so easy.
  • eric von zipper wrote...
    Chuck - ageist!
    Shocking, isn't it? A man of Chuck Gould's ethics taking a potshot at the senior driver - stereotyping...profiling. I'm surprised he didn't throw Asian drivers into his hateful little missive.








News
Local
National
World
Money
Lifestyle
Sci/Tech
Odd News
Politics

Multimedia
Photo Galleries
Videos
Sports
Mariners
Seahawks
Sounders
College
Storm
Blogs
NBA
Golf
NHL
Tennis
Olympics
Auto Racing
Entertainment
Dining
Movies
Movie Times
Calendar of Events
Entertainment News
Television
Travel
Tom Douglas
Chef Jeremy
Tom Tangney
Fit in the City
Seattle Fashionistas
the mixtape
Weather
Local Conditions
School Closings
Earthquake Tracker

Traffic
Current Conditions

Podcasts
Download past shows
Daily audio roll
Blogs
Dave Ross
Dori Monson
Ron and Don
TBTL
David Boze
Michael Medved
Frank Shiers
Phil the News Junkie
MyNorthwest Blog
Shannon Drayer
Kevin Calabro
Brock and Salk
97.3 KIRO FM
Shows/Hosts
Schedule
Events/Contests
Press Releases
Community Outreach

770 KTTH: The Truth
Shows/Hosts
Schedule

710 ESPN Seattle
Shows/Hosts
Schedule
Home   |   Contact Us   |   Terms of Use   |   Privacy Statement   |   Copyright Infringement   |   Employment   |   EEO Public File Report   |   Contest Rules   |   Set Us as Your Home Page   |   RSS
Copyright © 2010 Bonneville International. All rights reserved.