Updated Sep 21, 2010 - 7:25 am
Case more about racism than felon voting rights
Originally published: Sep 21, 2010 - 6:20 am
KIRO Radio.
In Washington, like in most states, convicted felons cannot vote until they've done their time. But a case challenging that law is coming to a head in federal court Monday.
On its face, Farakkhan v. Gregoire is about whether felons have the right to vote. But it's really about institutionalized racism: namely whether Washington's criminal justice system treats minorities unfairly.
"You have vast disproportionate rates of incarceration and sentencing for African-Americans, Latinos, and Native Americans," said Dale Ho, one of the NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund lawyers representing the plaintiffs in the 14-year-old case. They claim that due to racism built into the court system, the state's law banning felons from voting violates the 1965 Voter Rights Act. "Black defendants convicted of crimes lose their right to vote 50 percent longer than white defendants," Ho said.
In January, a 3-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of Ho and the plaintiffs. The state was set to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, until the 9th Circuit decided to hear the case again, this time before an 11-judge en banc panel. "To our surprise, the judges themselves decided to reconsider this case," said Secretary of State Sam Reed.
Tuesday, Attorney General Rob McKenna will argue before that 11-judge panel. Reed said the fact that the court decided to hear the case a second time is a good sign. "There is no evidence of there being discrimination per se," he said. "If there are problems in the justice system, they need to address those, not to say that everyone who is in prison today has a right to vote."
Three other appellate courts (in cases out of New York, Massachusetts, and Florida), have reached the opposite conclusion, deciding the Voting Rights Act does not deal with felons' right to vote.
"In a couple of these other cases there have been requests for the Supreme Court to hear them," Reed said. "But we understand they're waiting and seeing on this one because they may want to take the Washington case."
According to Reed, no matter what the 9th Circuit decides, Farrakhan will likely reach the highest court in the land, and that could mean changes in voting rights for felons across the country.
Follow Alex Silverman on twitter @alexsilverman
Photos: Seattle Police identify suspects in May Day melee
Five suspects have been identified for vandalism and violence during Seattle's May Day protests. - First 787 built in SC takes maiden flight
- Voluntary recall for Shitake-Ya mushroom slices
- Man charged with murder in S. Seattle shooting
- WA: wolves likely caused fatal calf injuries
- Car hits side of WA middle school; no kids hurt
- Suspect pleads guilty in beauty school killing
- Liddi's slam leads Seattle past Texas 5-3
- More Local News »
Thank you Facebook for reminding me nothing is safe
I missed Microsoft, I missed Apple, I missed Amazon, I missed
Google, and so I figured my last chance to win an IPO payday
was Facebook. -

The day in photos
May 23: Rare cheetahs, Cannes glamor, New York fleet... -
A day in the life: Dori Monson Show
What is it really like to create the Dori Monson Show?... -

Commercial spacecraft blasts off for space station
In its second attempt a commercial craft will blast... -

The day in photos
May 22: Trumpets for Guinness, Usher in court, non-vicious...
Seahawks QB competition is still Matt Flynn's to lose
Brock Huard says Matt Flynn is still the favorite in the Seahawks' quarterback competition despite much of the attention being focused lately on rookie Russell Wilson. - Crew defeat Sounders in Seattle 2-0
- Seahawks' Allen Barbre suspended 4 games
- Study: SoDo could handle traffic from arena
- Audio: Jack Z happy with Montero's defense
- CF Franklin Gutierrez progressing in rehab
- Huard: What Winslow brings to Seahawks
- Union: NFL colluded to cap 2010 salaries
- More Sports »
Missouri opts for untested drug for executions
The same anesthetic that caused the overdose death of pop star Michael Jackson is now the drug of choice for executions in Missouri, causing a stir among critics who question how the state can guarantee a drug untested for lethal injection wont cause pain and suffering for the condemned. - Battle over Beverly Hills subway goes Hollywood
- Idaho town seeks to lure gun and ammo makers
- Monsignor: Cardinal wanted accusers kept unaware
- Unabomber updates Harvard University alumni book
- Battle over Beverly Hills subway goes Hollywood
- Drug cartel player extradited to US from Mexico
- Idaho town seeks to lure gun and ammo makers
- More National News »
Wis. theft victim uploads video of suspected thief
A Wisconsin man whose camcorder was briefly stolen has found a way to get back at the suspected thief: He uploaded to YouTube a video that the suspect took with the camera, a clip in which the man reveals his name, shows his face and admits he stole the camera.- Iowa man with zebra, parrot in truck gets DUI
- Silicon Valley tech exec accused of Lego thefts
- Ohio family's stolen swine statue is returned
- Ore. workers awarded $332K in onsite toilet fight
- Mafia-style end for Australia's flawed Obama mugs
- Tons of pot found floating off Southern Calif.
- Ohio pair get engaged after running half-marathon
- More Odd News »



