Seattle Burger Review: Elliot Bay’s elk burger leaves longing for beef

Jul 19, 2019, 5:52 AM | Updated: 11:40 am


(Tom Amato, KTTH)

(Tom Amato, KTTH)

I’m on a mission to find the best burger in the city of Seattle. I travel to various burger joints within city limits and rate the establishment’s most popular burger on a scale of 1-10. Of all the measures I use, taste is most important. 

Maybe a normal beef burger isn’t your thing. Maybe a veggie burger doesn’t taste enough like beef and a pork burger tastes too much like chicken. You could always go with an elk burger.  

You’ll find one of the more extravagant elk burgers at Elliot Bay Public House and Brewery in Lake City (Note: The item is not listed on the menu of the West Seattle location). It’s called the “Cherry Stout BBQ Elk Burger.” This review is purely based on the taste of one particular menu item and is not reflective of the location or any of the many offerings it has.  

Maybe elk is an acquired taste because there’s many people out there who enjoy it. The health benefits can also be attractive. The meat is more protein-rich than beef and contains far less fat content. But when it comes to taste, I found it too challenging. Let’s face it: Although body builders may find elk desirable, you’re typically not anticipating a healthy meal when you go out for a burger.  

They recommend you order the elk burger medium rare. It’s good idea to do so because elk meat is naturally tough and may be difficult to chow down on should it be cooked further. If you’re like me and used to eating beef, you’ll be surprised that, despite the color, it’s not juicy at all. It was dry and had a tough outer-hide. Maybe ‘gamy’ isn’t the right word, but I could definitely taste the iron content.  

For those expecting a flavor-blasted meal, this dish delivers, but it’s not coming from the elk. The cherry flavor comes from the house BBQ sauce that’s called “No Doubt Stout cherry BBQ sauce.” The burger comes with caramelized onions, arugula, bacon, and Swiss cheese. All those ingredients were necessary for the burger since I found the elk to be difficult. I don’t think the burger as a stand-alone would be as successful, nor would it be without flavorful ingredients. It’s served on a bun baked with spent grain.  

Since it comes on the side, I cut the burger in half and applied more BBQ sauce on one side than the other. The sauce tastes how it sounds, so if you’re a fan of cherries, you’ll be a fan of the sauce. I liked the half with added sauce better, but do be aware, it’s very strong. The onions were great and I was glad they packed them on. I also appreciated Swiss cheese because, frankly, American and Cheddar are becoming tiresome. The bottom bun did soften over time. The fries were delicious. This is a very filling burger and I almost didn’t finish.  

The burger will cost you $15.50. That’s understandable because harvesting elk and getting it to the table obviously costs more than a cow. However, I think you might be better off grabbing a beef burger which costs around $12.00. The price includes the fries.  

I loved the atmosphere of the bar. It gives off more of a ‘lodge’ kind of feel but serves food and drink like a brewery. It looks like a place that would warm you up on a winter day and it has tons of food and drink variety.  

Biggest strength(s): Onions, size, Swiss cheese  

Biggest weakness(s): Elk isn’t for everyone (including me), bun  

A friend of mine raves about this location. I loved the atmosphere, struggled with the elk. I’ll give the “Cherry Stout BBQ Elk Burger” from Elliot Bay Public House and Brewery a 5.5/10.  


What do you think of elk burgers? What do you think about this particular elk burger? Where should I go next? Tweet me @TommAmato on Twitter.  

Past reviews: 8 OZ. Burger (7.5/10), Little Big Burger (8/10), Uneeda Burger (5/10),Li’l Woody’s (7/10), CaliBurger (6/10), ShakeShack (8/10), Red Robin (7/10), BurgerMaster (4/10), Sam’s Tavern (7.5/10), Great State Burger (6.5/10), Zippy’s Giant Burgers (8/10), Red Mill Burgers (7.5,10), Henry’s Tavern in Bellevue (9/10), Blue Moon Burger’s ‘Impossible Burger’ (1/10), Katsu Burger (7.5/10), Rain City Burgers (6/10), BRGR Bar (7/10), Kidd Valley (7/10), Loretta’s Northwesterner (5/10), Scooter’s Burgers (7/10)  


Jason Rantz on AM 770 KTTH
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to AM 770 KTTH weekdays at 3-7pm toThe Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

Bob Ferguson...

Jason Rantz

Rantz Exclusive: Secretary of State says AG Bob Ferguson demanded he break law in vulgar tirade

Secretary of State Steve Hobbs says Attorney General Bob Ferguson demanded he break the law in a vulgar and angry tirade.

3 days ago

Image: The crowd cheers at the 2013 Bumbershoot Arts & Music Festival in Seattle....

Jason Rantz

Rantz: It’s time to pull the plug on Bumbershoot Seattle after latest disaster lineup

The newest Bumbershoot lineup confirms what we've known for a while: this music festival is dead in Seattle.

4 days ago


Jason Rantz

Rantz: Asylum seeker says Seattle activists are taking advantage of migrants

Migrants seeking asylum are being taken advantage of by Seattle housing activists convincing them to illegally occupy parks.

5 days ago

Photo: The anti-Israel encampment at the University of Washington gave rise to a new hate group: UW...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: UW Seattle embraced the Nazi Youth as a new generation of hate group has formed

The anti-Israel encampment at the University of Washington gave rise to a new hate group: UW Nazi Youth. It's time we call them what they are.

6 days ago

The State Capitol in Olympia...

Jackson Meyer

Bob Ferguson from Graham on governor’s race: ‘My intent was to win’

After Washington AG Bob Ferguson threatened legal action, two candidates also named Bob Ferguson have withdrawn from the gubernatorial race.

10 days ago

Photo: Progressive candidate Shaun Scott....

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Progressive candidate upset he isn’t running unopposed, makes up candidate

It appears that progressive candidate Shaun Scott expected to run unopposed for a state representative seat.

10 days ago

Seattle Burger Review: Elliot Bay’s elk burger leaves longing for beef