MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Key court decision could pave way for Seattle safe injection sites

Oct 3, 2019, 12:20 PM

Safe injection sites...

Safe injection sites have long been controversial in the U.S. (AP)

(AP)

A federal judge in Pennsylvania ruled Wednesday that safe injection sites do not conflict with federal statutes.

Are injection sites a slippery slope or tool against opioid epidemic?

In the past, lawmakers have argued that so-called “crackhouse rules” strictly forbid the implementation of supervised drug injection sites. Safehouse, a Pennsylvania-based nonprofit, sought to get clarity on that before establishing a site in Philadelphia.

The law as it stands states that an you cannot establish a location where the explicit purpose is to facilitate the consumption of an illegal controlled substance.

In the case presented by Safehouse, U.S. District Judge Gerald McHugh came to the conclusion that a safe injection site doesn’t fall under that definition.

“I cannot conclude that Safehouse has, as a significant purpose, the objective of facilitating drug use,” Judge McHugh said in his decision. “Safehouse plans to make a place available for the purposes of reducing the harm of drug use, administering medical care, encouraging drug treatment, and connecting participants with social services. None of these purposes can be understood as a purpose to facilitate drug use.”

Proponents of supervised consumption sites argue that they serve an important function in not only preventing overdoses, but also ultimately in reducing drug use altogether.

“The answer comes down simply to data,” Crozer-Keystone Health System’s Dr. Rick Pescatore told KTTH’s Jason Rantz back in May. “The data is consistent; the data is overwhelming that supervised consumption sites represent a clearinghouse for patients. They decrease mortality, they decrease overdoses, decrease communicable disease, they decrease crime, and overall, they provide a public health good.”

Here in Seattle, it’s the legality of safe injection sites that’s been cause for a fierce debate between the Department of Justice and city officials.

In April, U.S. Attorney Brian Moran warned Seattle that it could expect legal repercussions if it hosted a safe injection site. Shortly after, City Attorney Pete Holmes spoke out.

“The [Trump] Administration’s position continues to be disappointing because these are sites where medical professionals can meaningfully engage with people facing addictions, offering supervision but also treatment,” Holmes said.

Seattle mayor responds to safe injection threat from U.S. Attorney

Both Holmes and Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan also stated that they still took Moran’s threat “very seriously.”

In the future, the recent ruling in Pennsylvania has the potential to set a precedent for Seattle.

“What an incredible ruling, which I expect will inform the conversation ahead,” Holmes told Q13.

That said, it could also be a short-lived victory as well.

“The fact that it took the judge fifteen pages to lay out his argument for disagreeing with four different appeals courts is a sign that, regardless of the strength of his argument, other judges could rule differently and it’s ripe for The Third Circuit Court of Appeals to overrule him when the government inevitably appeals,” noted SCC Insight’s Kevin Schofield.

If the Third Circuit upholds the decision, though, the case could soon end up in front of the U.S. Supreme Court. It would take a favorable ruling from the Supreme Court for Seattle to be able to legally establish its own safe injection site.

MyNorthwest News

Image: Brightly colored eggs are set on a table on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington,...

Ted Buehner

Expect good Easter weekend weather for egg hunts, chilly evening Mariners games

Both Saturday and Sunday of Easter weekend will feature temperatures warming to around 60 degrees across much of Western Washington.

1 hour ago

Taylor Swift performs onstage during the Taylor Swift | The Eras Tour at Lumen Field on July 22, 20...

Micki Gamez, KIRO Newsradio and Bill Kaczaraba, MyNorthwest

Seattle tourism dollars break records following All-Star Week, Taylor Swift

It was a record-setting year for dollars flowing into Seattle from tourists.

2 hours ago

Image: A bridge in Carnation....

Julia Dallas

Carnation frustrated with Seattle again after 8th false emergency alarm induces widespread panic

Carnation citizens have faced a series of panic-inducing alarms after SPU's system for the Tolt Dam falsely sounded eight times.

4 hours ago

Grocery store shopper...

Bill Kaczaraba

Ways to deal with Seattle grocery store sticker shock

Seattle grocery store sticker shock continues to play havoc on locals, but there are ways to counter high prices.

4 hours ago

belltown hellcat social media...

Frank Sumrall

Infamous ‘Belltown Hellcat’ social media influencer charged with reckless driving

The social media influencer has been accused of driving 107 miles per hour through Belltown in a Dodge Hellcat.

5 hours ago

KIRO Newsradio gracie awards...

MyNorthwest Staff

KIRO Newsradio anchors receive Gracie Awards for outstanding work

Heather Bosch and Lisa Brooks, anchors at KIRO Newsradio, have been honored by the Alliance for Women in Media with prestigious Gracie Awards.

8 hours ago

Key court decision could pave way for Seattle safe injection sites