Flip of Michigan Legislature highlights role of fair maps

Nov 21, 2022, 12:24 PM | Updated: Nov 23, 2022, 2:46 am
Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Publ...

Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Public Library, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in New Baltimore Mich. A Democratic swing in the Michigan Legislature highlights the role that redistricting can play in the outcome of elections. Although Hornberger's roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide, she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)

(AP Photo/Jose Juarez)

              Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Public Library, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in New Baltimore Mich. A Democratic swing in the Michigan Legislature highlights the role that redistricting can play in the outcome of elections. Although Hornberger's roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide, she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              Macomb County Commissioner Veronica Klinefelt poses for a photo inside an office, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in Mt. Clemens, Mich. Democratic candidates for the Michigan House and Senate won a majority of votes this year. As a result, they won control of both chambers. Were it not for the new districts, Klinefelt, a Democrat, said she probably would not have run for the Senate. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Public Library, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in New Baltimore Mich. A Democratic swing in the Michigan Legislature highlights the role that redistricting can play in the outcome of elections. Although Hornberger's roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide, she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              Macomb County Commissioner Veronica Klinefelt poses for a photo inside an office, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in Mt. Clemens, Mich. Democratic candidates for the Michigan House and Senate won a majority of votes this year. As a result, they won control of both chambers. Were it not for the new districts, Klinefelt, a Democrat, said she probably would not have run for the Senate. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Public Library, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in New Baltimore Mich. A Democratic swing in the Michigan Legislature highlights the role that redistricting can play in the outcome of elections. Although Hornberger's roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide, she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              FILE - Protesters attend a meeting of Michigan's new Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission on Oct. 21, 2021, in Lansing, Mich. An Associated Press analysis of election data indicates that Michigan's new state legislative districts reduced the built-in advantage Republicans had enjoyed over the previous decade. It shows that gerrymandering, or the lack of it, can affect the balance of power in legislatures and, ultimately, the policies they pursue. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio, File)
            
              Macomb County Commissioner Veronica Klinefelt poses for a photo inside an office, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in Mt. Clemens, Mich. Democratic candidates for the Michigan House and Senate won a majority of votes this year. As a result, they won control of both chambers. Were it not for the new districts, Klinefelt, a Democrat, said she probably would not have run for the Senate. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)
            
              Michigan Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger poses for a photo at the MacDonald Public Library, Monday, Nov. 21, 2022, in New Baltimore Mich. A Democratic swing in the Michigan Legislature highlights the role that redistricting can play in the outcome of elections. Although Hornberger's roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide, she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair. (AP Photo/Jose Juarez)

Democratic candidates for the Michigan House and Senate won a majority of votes this year, translating into their party winning control of both legislative chambers. That may seem like a natural result, but it hasn’t been in previous elections.

While Democrats also won a majority of votes in 2018 and 2020, Republicans won majorities in the Legislature. The difference this time: Candidates ran in new districts drawn by a citizens commission instead of ones crafted by Republican lawmakers that were designed to help keep their party in power.

“Michigan went from some of the most extremely gerrymandered maps to some of the country’s fairest maps, and now we have a perfect alignment between the votes that voters cast and the officials that were elected into office,” said Nancy Wang, executive director of Voters Not Politicians. Her group spearheaded a successful 2018 ballot initiative that changed the way Michigan’s legislative districts are drawn.

An Associated Press analysis of election data indicates that Michigan’s new state legislative districts reduced the built-in advantage Republicans had enjoyed over the previous decade. It shows that gerrymandering — or the lack of it — can affect the balance of power in legislatures and, ultimately, the policies they pursue.

The launch of Michigan’s new legislative districts this year coincided with a ballot measure seeking to enshrine abortion rights in the state constitution. The abortion measure passed with nearly 57% of the vote, elevating an issue that gave Democrats an edge in some competitive districts.

Abortion “was definitely a factor in my race, and most likely in every race across the state,” said Republican House Speaker Pro Tem Pamela Hornberger, whose roughly 300-vote loss in a state Senate race was the closest statewide.

Recently reelected Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer already is talking about working with Michigan’s new Democratic legislative majority to fully rescind a 1931 law that bans abortion and to codify same-sex marriage rights — two issues that gained little traction in the Republican-led Legislature.

The legislative flip in Michigan was part of a strong showing for Democrats at the state level in this year’s midterm elections. Wins in legislative or governor’s races also gave them full control of the government in Maryland, Massachusetts and Minnesota.

Michigan is not the only state with a history of partisan gerrymandering, in which the party in charge draws districts to its advantage — packing voters of the other party into select districts and spreading others among multiple districts to diminish their clout. Gerrymandering surged among both Republicans and Democrats this past redistricting cycle.

Unlike in Michigan, voters in about half the states do not have the ability to put issues on the ballot through citizen initiatives. So similar redistricting initiatives can’t be pursued in Democratic-dominated Maryland or be used to check the power of Republican-led legislatures in North Carolina, Texas and Wisconsin, where partisan maps all have faced lawsuits.

For the past decade, Michigan’s legislative elections were held under maps enacted in 2011 by a Republican-led Legislature and governor. Those districts gave Republican candidates one of the largest advantages in the nation, according to a prior AP analysis that used a mathematical formula to illustrate potential instances of gerrymandering. That formula shows the maps used in the 2022 elections were nearly politically neutral.

In 2018 and 2020, Democratic candidates received a slight majority of the total state House votes, yet Republicans won a 58-52 House majority each year. Democrats also received more votes for the Michigan Senate in the last election in 2018, yet Republicans won a 22-16 majority under the maps they had drawn.

A constitutional amendment approved by voters in 2018 established the Michigan Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission and stripped lawmakers of their redistricting responsibilities. The measure required a 13-member panel, randomly selected from a pool of applicants, to consider “partisan fairness” as one of several criteria for drawing maps. The process kicked in with the 2020 census.

Were it not for the new districts, Macomb County Commissioner Veronica Klinefelt, a Democrat, said she probably would not have run for the Senate. But she seized the chance when a new map combined parts of two previous districts to create a new district in the northern Detroit metro area. Klinefelt defeated a Republican incumbent who was trying to represent the new district.

“The opportunity to flip the Senate for the first time in 38 years was something that I couldn’t just walk away from,” Klinefelt said.

Hornberger’s quest for a newly created Senate district pitted her against Democratic state Rep. Kevin Hertel. Like other Michigan races this election, their contest drew unprecedented spending from Democrats seeking to take control of the chamber. Democrats attacked what Hornberger described as a mistaken vote against a bill about reporting child abuse that she later reversed, while Republicans attacked Hertel over an unpaid tax bill from years ago.

Hornberger said she was disgusted by the tone of the campaign.

“It just goes to show you how absolutely crucial it is to have that power in Lansing, Democrat or Republican,” she said, later adding: “and the amount of money we will spend and the horrible things we will do to each other to get it.”

Yet Hornberger said she considers the maps drawn by the citizens commission to be fair.

An analysis conducted for the commission when the maps were adopted projected that if Democrats received 52.3% of the vote, they would win a 20-18 Senate majority and a 57-53 House majority.

The actual results tracked almost exactly with that ratio. Democratic legislative candidates received just under 51% of the total statewide votes. Democrats won a 20-18 Senate majority and a 56-54 House majority.

“Honestly I think we did a pretty decent job,” said Dustin Witjes, a Democratic commissioner.

Republican commissioner Douglas Clark and nonpartisan commissioner Rebecca Szetela also said they were pleased that the percentage of seats won by each party aligned so closely with the percentage of votes they received.

“To me, a fair map is a map that reflects the will of the voters,” Szetela said.

Partisan balance can be achieved through a mixture of lopsided districts favoring Democrats and Republicans or with districts containing a more bipartisan split among voters. Commissioners said it wasn’t their goal to create more competitive districts, but it was a byproduct in some cases.

While the number of Senate races decided by less than 10 percentage points remained the same from 2018 to 2022, the number of close House races rose from 14 in each of the previous two elections to 20 this year.

“Depending on the issues of the election and depending on the candidates, some of these districts can go either way — they can go Republican or they can go Democrat,” Clark said. “In this instance in this election, more of them went Democrat. So I think we have to accept those results — that’s what the people wanted.”

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

AP

FILE - Workers set up the Montreal Convention Centre in preparation for the COP15 U.N. conference o...
Associated Press

Governments gather in Canada in bid to boost biodiversity

BOSTON (AP) — Amid warnings that biodiversity is in freefall, environmental leaders will gather in Montreal to hammer out measures aimed at shoring up the world’s land and marine ecosystems and coming up with tens of billions of dollars to fund these conservation efforts. Delegates from about 190 countries will assemble for nearly two weeks, […]
1 day ago
Associated Press

Taliban allow high school graduation exams for Afghan girls

ISLAMABAD (AP) — Afghan girls will be allowed to take their high school graduation exams this week, an official and documents from the Taliban government indicated Tuesday — even though they have been banned from classrooms since the former insurgents took over the country last year. According to two documents from the Taliban ministry of […]
1 day ago
South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, center, leaves an African National Congress (ANC) national...
Associated Press

South Africa’s lawmakers delay debate on president’s future

JOHANNESBURG (AP) — South Africa’s lawmakers have postponed until next week a debate on the damning report that has resulted in calls for President Cyril Ramaphosa to step down. The session was scheduled to take place in Cape Town on Tuesday to discuss a parliamentary panel’s report that found Ramaphosa may have broken anti-corruption laws […]
1 day ago
FILE - Palm oil trees at Pangkalan Kerinci in Riau, Central Sumatra, Indonesia, on May 1, 2008. Eur...
Associated Press

EU agrees deal to ban products which fuel deforestation

BRUSSELS (AP) — European Union lawmakers and governments reached a deal Tuesday that would ban the import of products which contribute to deforestation around the world. The preliminary agreement, which still needs to be formally adopted by the EU parliament, requires companies to verify that the goods they sell in the EU have not led […]
1 day ago
FILE - A student visits a sensory room at Williams Elementary School, on Nov. 3, 2021, in Topeka, K...
Associated Press

Many kids are struggling. Is special education the answer?

The COVID-19 pandemic sent Heidi Whitney’s daughter into a tailspin. Suddenly the San Diego middle schooler was sleeping all day and awake all night. When in-person classes resumed, she was so anxious at times that she begged to come home early, telling the nurse her stomach hurt. Whitney tried to keep her daughter in class. […]
1 day ago
Associated Press

Millennial Money: How credit can beat buy now, pay later

At first glance, a “buy now, pay later” plan’s promise of no interest or upfront fees can seem more appealing than a credit card’s terms. Dividing a transaction into, say, a pay-in-four installment plan sounds straightforward and manageable. Unlike credit cards, though, these plans lack certain consumer protections and are sometimes unpredictable. In this way, […]
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

Comcast Ready for Business Fund...
Ilona Lohrey | President and CEO, GSBA

GSBA is closing the disparity gap with Ready for Business Fund

GSBA, Comcast, and other partners are working to address disparities in access to financial resources with the Ready for Business fund.
SHIBA WA...

Medicare open enrollment is here and SHIBA can help!

The SHIBA program – part of the Office of the Insurance Commissioner – is ready to help with your Medicare open enrollment decisions.
Lake Washington Windows...

Choosing Best Windows for Your Home

Lake Washington Windows and Doors is a local window dealer offering the exclusive Leak Armor installation.
Anacortes Christmas Tree...

Come one, come all! Food, Drink, and Coastal Christmas – Anacortes has it all!

Come celebrate Anacortes’ 11th annual Bier on the Pier! Bier on the Pier takes place on October 7th and 8th and features local ciders, food trucks and live music - not to mention the beautiful views of the Guemes Channel and backdrop of downtown Anacortes.
Swedish Cyberknife Treatment...

The revolutionary treatment of Swedish CyberKnife provides better quality of life for majority of patients

There are a wide variety of treatments options available for men with prostate cancer. One of the most technologically advanced treatment options in the Pacific Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform at Swedish Medical Center.
Work at Zum Services...

Seattle Public Schools announces three-year contract with Zum

Seattle Public Schools just announced a three-year contract with a brand-new company to the Pacific Northwest to assist with their student transportation: Zum.
Flip of Michigan Legislature highlights role of fair maps