Similar state abortion challenges meet different outcomes

Jan 5, 2023, 10:25 PM | Updated: Jan 6, 2023, 12:44 pm
FILE - South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster holds up a bill banning almost all abortions in the state...

FILE - South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster holds up a bill banning almost all abortions in the state after he signed it into law on Feb. 18, 2021, in Columbia, S.C. The South Carolina ban on abortions after cardiac activity is no more after the latest legal challenge to the state's 2021 law proved successful. The state Supreme Court ruled Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023, that the restrictions violate the state constitution's right to privacy. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins, File)

(AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins, File)

              FILE - An attendee at Planned Parenthood's Bans Off Our Bodies rally for abortion rights holds a sign reading "Idaho the women as property state" outside of the Idaho Statehouse in downtown Boise, Idaho, on May 14, 2022. Idaho's Constitution does not implicitly enshrine abortion as a fundamental right, the state Supreme Court ruled on Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023 as it dismissed a lawsuit brought by Planned Parenthood. (Sarah A. Miller/Idaho Statesman via AP, File)
              FILE - Planned Parenthood South Atlantic Director of Public Affairs Vicki Ringer addresses reporters on Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023, in Columbia, S.C. The South Carolina Supreme Court ruled 3-2 that a ban on abortions after cardiac activity violates the state constitution's right to privacy. (AP Photo/James Pollard, FIle)
              FILE - A large crowd marches to downtown during a University of Minnesota student led protest in Minneapolis, Minn., after the Supreme Court overruled Roe v Wade on June 24, 2022. A bill to strengthen abortion rights in Minnesota is on the fast track to becoming law as it passed a legislative committee in its first test Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023. (Renée Jones Schneider/Star Tribune via AP, File)
              FILE - South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster holds up a bill banning almost all abortions in the state after he signed it into law on Feb. 18, 2021, in Columbia, S.C. The South Carolina ban on abortions after cardiac activity is no more after the latest legal challenge to the state's 2021 law proved successful. The state Supreme Court ruled Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023, that the restrictions violate the state constitution's right to privacy. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins, File)

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The top courts in two conservative states ruled the same day on similar challenges to abortion bans — and went in opposite directions.

The 3-2 decisions Thursday in Idaho, which keeps a ban on abortion at all stages of pregnancy, and South Carolina, which blocks enforcement of a ban after cardiac activity can be detected, are the latest examples of the patchwork of policies imposed since the U.S. Supreme Court last year struck down Roe v. Wade, which had guaranteed the right to abortion nationwide for nearly five decades.

The conclusions from the state justices rest on differences in state constitutions, said Robert F. Williams, director of the Center for State Constitutional Studies at Rutgers University-Camden.

“There are also differences in the judges,” Williams said. “Everybody knows by now that judges don’t just call balls and strikes.”

In both cases, abortion rights advocates argued that the states protect privacy, and therefore abortion.

The majority opinion in the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling was also rooted in the idea of a right to privacy. The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the idea last year in Dobbs v. Jackson, ruling instead that the legality of abortion should be decided by the states.

The landscape then shifted quickly. Several states had so-called trigger bans ready to enforce in case Roe was overturned, and two more adopted new bans after the ruling.

Bans on abortion at all stages of pregnancy, with various exceptions, are now considered to be in effect in 13 states. Several of those bans, plus others that are less restrictive, are being challenged in court. At least seven other bans are not being enforced because of injunctions imposed amid legal challenges.

Now, instead of arguing that the U.S. Constitution protects abortion access, lawyers challenging the bans are basing their cases on the language of state constitutions. Several of the challenges are rooted in the right to privacy.

One key difference between those documents in the states with rulings this week: Idaho’s does not have a clause that explicitly declares a right to privacy. South Carolina’s does.

South Carolina’s right to privacy was adopted from a suggestion by a late 1960s committee reviewing the state’s constitution which was significantly rewritten in 1895 to strengthen and enforce segregation. It said the people should be secure from “unreasonable invasions of privacy.”

The justices who ruled the strict abortion law didn’t violate privacy rights cited notes from the committee that the intention of the privacy clause was to protect against government surveillance in a modernizing world.

But in the majority opinion, Associate Justice Kaye Hearn, the Supreme Court’s only female member, pointed out the commission had no women. At the time they met, women couldn’t serve on juries and the state had not ratified the 19th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution that gave women the right to vote decades before.

“We cannot relegate our role of declaring whether a legislative act is constitutional by blinding ourselves to everything that has transpired since the amendment was adopted,” she wrote.

Hearn wrote that while lawmakers have the authority to protect life, the privacy clause means women should have enough time to determine they are pregnant and decide whether to have an abortion.

“Six weeks is, quite simply, not a reasonable period of time for these two things to occur,” Hearn wrote in a ruling that means abortion remains legal in South Carolina up to 20 weeks gestational age.

The three votes to reject the strict abortion law are fragile. Hearn is 72, the mandatory retirement age for judges in South Carolina and has to leave the court this year. If the state legislature passes a new law on abortion, Hearn will not be on the court that reviews it. Thursday’s decision also led some conservatives to suggest South Carolina change how it chooses judges from the current system where they are picked by legislators after being screened and vetted by a committee.

In Idaho’s ruling that kept the abortion ban in place, Justice Robyn Brody noted that the constitution there does not specifically say there’s a right to abortion.

“We cannot read a fundamental right to abortion into the text of the Idaho Constitution,” she wrote in an opinion signed by two other justices. “If we were to jettison that disciplined approach, even in the face of a uniquely emotional and politically divisive policy issue, the Idaho Constitution would no longer be the voice of the people of Idaho — it would be effectively replaced by the voice of a select few sitting on this Court.”

Two other Idaho justices dissented.

Courts have also been known to change their position on whether abortion rights are protected. Iowa’s top court ruled in 2018 that the state constitution contained a fundamental right to abortion — and last year that it doesn’t.

But justices aren’t the only ones with a say.

Last year, voters in all the states that put it to a ballot measure sided with abortion rights. In Kansas and Kentucky, they rejected amendments that would have found the state constitutions should not be interpreted to protect abortion rights. Voters in California, Michigan and Vermont approved amendments that enshrine the right to abortion.


Mulvihill reported from Cherry Hill, New Jersey.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Presidential candidate Andreas Mavrogiannis, left, who is backed by the left-wing AKEL party, is se...
Associated Press

Voting starts for Cyprus’ presidency, with 3 front-runners

NICOSIA, Cyprus (AP) — Cypriots on Sunday began voting for their eighth president in the ethnically divided island’s 63-year history as an independent republic, with three front-runners each portraying themselves as the safest bet to guide the country through turbulent economic times and to seek peace with breakaway Turkish Cypriots. Opinion polls indicate that none […]
1 day ago
Pope Francis arrives to celebrate mass at the John Garang Mausoleum in Juba, South Sudan, Sunday, F...
Associated Press

Pope makes final bid for peace, forgiveness in South Sudan

JUBA, South Sudan (AP) — Pope Francis made a final appeal for peace in South Sudan on Sunday as he celebrated Mass before tens of thousands of people to close out an unusual mission by Christian religious leaders to nudge forward the country’s recovery from civil war. On the last day of his African pilgrimage, […]
1 day ago
Associated Press

Turkey detains 15 for IS links but finds no concrete threats

ISTANBUL (AP) — Turkish police have arrested 15 people for alleged links to the extremist Islamic State group, the country’s official news agency said late Saturday, following days of security warnings by Western consulates. Anadolu news agency, sourcing an Istanbul police statement, said the group was detained for purportedly planning attacks on the Swedish and […]
1 day ago
In this photo provided by the U.S. Coast Guard Pacific Northwest, a Coast Guard rescue swimmer reac...
Associated Press

Man rescued by Coast Guard wanted in ‘Goonies’ fish incident

A man who was saved by a Coast Guard rescue swimmer at the mouth of the Columbia River as a massive wave rolled the yacht he was piloting Friday was wanted for a bizarre incident in which police said he left a dead fish at the Astoria, Oregon, home featured in the classic 1985 film, "The Goonies."
1 day ago
FILE - An Amazon company logo on the company's building in Schoenefeld near Berlin, Germany, March ...
Associated Press

Amazon violated labor law with delivery app

A Spanish court has ruled that Amazon broke labor laws by forcing more than 2,000 delivery drivers to use an app that the company controlled for scheduling work and payments and requiring them to use their own cars and cellphones on the job.
1 day ago
Harry Styles attends the premiere of "My Policeman" at the Princess of Wales Theatre during the Tor...
Associated Press

Grammys could make history with Beyoncé, Bad Bunny wins

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Will Beyoncé emerge from the Grammy Awards as its most decorated artist ever? That’s one of the main storylines heading into Sunday’s ceremony, where the superstar is the leading nominee and needs four wins to make history. Several of music’s biggest names, including Beyoncé, are in the running for the night’s […]
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

safety from crime...

As crime increases, our safety measures must too

It's easy to be accused of fearmongering regarding crime, but Seattle residents might have good reason to be concerned for their safety.
Comcast Ready for Business Fund...
Ilona Lohrey | President and CEO, GSBA

GSBA is closing the disparity gap with Ready for Business Fund

GSBA, Comcast, and other partners are working to address disparities in access to financial resources with the Ready for Business fund.

Medicare open enrollment is here and SHIBA can help!

The SHIBA program – part of the Office of the Insurance Commissioner – is ready to help with your Medicare open enrollment decisions.
Lake Washington Windows...

Choosing Best Windows for Your Home

Lake Washington Windows and Doors is a local window dealer offering the exclusive Leak Armor installation.
Anacortes Christmas Tree...

Come one, come all! Food, Drink, and Coastal Christmas – Anacortes has it all!

Come celebrate Anacortes’ 11th annual Bier on the Pier! Bier on the Pier takes place on October 7th and 8th and features local ciders, food trucks and live music - not to mention the beautiful views of the Guemes Channel and backdrop of downtown Anacortes.
Swedish Cyberknife Treatment...

The revolutionary treatment of Swedish CyberKnife provides better quality of life for majority of patients

There are a wide variety of treatments options available for men with prostate cancer. One of the most technologically advanced treatment options in the Pacific Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform at Swedish Medical Center.
Similar state abortion challenges meet different outcomes