NATIONAL NEWS

Police in California aren’t immune from certain misconduct lawsuits, high court rules

Jun 23, 2023, 3:21 PM

FILE - A Los Angeles Police Department vehicle is parked outside the LAPD headquarters in downtown ...

FILE - A Los Angeles Police Department vehicle is parked outside the LAPD headquarters in downtown Los Angeles on July 8, 2022. On Thursday, June 22, 2023, the Supreme Court of California ruled that police are not immune from civil lawsuits for misconduct that happens during investigations. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes, File)

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Police in California are not immune from civil lawsuits for misconduct that happens while they investigate crimes, the state Supreme Court ruled this week, overruling a precedent made by lower courts that had helped protect law enforcement from litigation for decades.

The justices unanimously rejected on Thursday an argument by Riverside County that its sheriff’s deputies couldn’t be sued for leaving a man’s naked body lying in plain sight for eight hours while officers investigated his killing.

California law protects police from being sued for any harm that happens during a prosecution process — even if the officer acted “maliciously and without probable cause.” Now, the Supreme Court says police can be sued for misconduct during investigations.

“The potential for factual overlap between investigations and prosecutions does not justify treating them as one and the same,” Justice Leondra Kruger wrote in the ruling.

Kruger noted the court issued a similar ruling in 1974. But in 1994, a state appeals court adopted a broader interpretation to shield police from lawsuits stemming from conduct during investigations. Lower courts have been relying on that ruling to dismiss misconduct lawsuits against law enforcement that did not involve prosecutions.

A lawyer representing Riverside County in the case did not immediately respond to a request for comment Friday.

This particular case centered on Jose Leon, who was shot and killed in 2017 southeast of Los Angeles in Riverside County. His wife Dora Leon sued the county for negligence and emotional distress after she said deputies left her husband’s naked body lying with his genitals exposed. Dora Leon’s case was dismissed by lower courts that ruled state law provides immunity to law enforcement officers and agencies for police conduct during investigations.

The Supreme Court reinstated Dora Leon’s lawsuit. Kruger wrote that the lower courts’ decision was wrong, saying police investigations cannot be interpreted as part of the prosecution process.

Many local police departments have routinely argued that they are immune from damage claims “the moment a police officer arrives on the scene of a crime,” said Richard Antognini, a lawyer representing Leon.

If the Supreme Court had ruled in favor of the county, “it would have essentially immunized them for almost anything,” he said.

The recent ruling helps remove an obstacle for victims seeking damages from police misconduct, Antognini said. California laws still provide immunity to certain aspects of police investigations.

The ruling was praised by John Burris, a California civil rights attorney who has represented more than 1,000 victims of police misconduct across the country.

“This should have a positive impact on police reform, because now the law has spoken,” Burris said. “Police should be trained and be better informed as to what their obligations are.”

National News

Voters wait in line to cast their ballots at Scranton High School in Scranton, Pa., on Election Day...

Associated Press

PHOTO COLLECTION: US Election 2024 America Votes

This is a collection of photos chosen by AP photo editors.

8 minutes ago

Associated Press

North Dakota’s lone congressman seeks to continue GOP’s decades-old grip on the governor’s post

BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — North Dakota’s lone congressman is seeking to become the conservative state’s next governor and continue a three-decade Republican grip on the job. U.S. Rep. Kelly Armstrong is facing Democratic state Sen. Merrill Piepkorn and independent candidate Michael Coachman in Tuesday’s general election. Armstrong defeated Lt. Gov. Tammy Miller in a Republican […]

1 hour ago

Hundreds block a portion of Phillips Avenue downtown to protest the Supreme Court decision overturn...

Associated Press

South Dakota is deciding whether to protect abortion rights and legalize recreational marijuana

South Dakota will decide Tuesday whether to add protections for abortion rights to the state constitution and potentially overturn the state’s abortion ban. The abortion rights measure was in a crowded field of initiatives on the state’s general election ballot that also included the proposed legalization of marijuana for recreational use, a measure to remove […]

2 hours ago

Associated Press

Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar is a heavy favorite to win 4th term against ex-NBA player Royce White

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Democratic U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar was a heavy favorite to win a fourth term Tuesday against a challenge by anti-establishment Republican and former NBA player Royce White in Minnesota’s top election matchup. Klobuchar went into the campaign with a history of big wins and a huge financial advantage. She drew 58% of […]

2 hours ago

This combination of file photos shows Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris,...

Associated Press

America reaches Election Day and a stark choice between Trump and Harris

WASHINGTON (AP) — A presidential campaign marked by upheaval and rancor approached its finale on Election Day as Americans decided whether to send Donald Trump back to the White House or elevate Kamala Harris to the Oval Office. Voters on Tuesday faced a stark choice between two candidates who have offered drastically different temperaments and […]

2 hours ago

Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump waves as he departs a campaign rally ...

Associated Press

The Latest: Trump and Harris cede stage to voters who’ll also decide control of House and Senate

Election Day is here. Voters are gearing up to head to the polls to cast their ballots for either Donald Trump or Kamala Harris in one of the nation’s most historic presidential races. They’ll also be determining which party will control the House and Senate. Follow the AP’s Election 2024 coverage at: https://apnews.com/hub/election-2024. Here’s the […]

3 hours ago

Police in California aren’t immune from certain misconduct lawsuits, high court rules