NATIONAL NEWS

New York judge resigns after saying he can’t be on a jury since he thinks all defendants are guilty

Feb 4, 2025, 11:58 AM | Updated: 1:40 pm

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — An upstate New York judge has resigned after he got out of jury duty by claiming that he couldn’t be impartial — because he thought everyone brought before a court is guilty.

Richard T. Snyder, who had been a justice of the Petersburgh Town Court for about a decade, left his post after being charged with misconduct by a state judicial commission, officials said Tuesday.

According to court transcripts, Snyder tried to avoid serving on a jury in 2023 by first identifying himself as a judge and then saying, “I know everybody come in front of me. I know they are guilty. They would not be in front of me.”

He was eventually dismissed from serving on the jury after he continued to argue that he could not be impartial, saying “No. It would not be fair,” court transcripts from a special grand jury empanelment in Rensselaer County show.

The judge who was overseeing the jury selection reported Snyder to state officials.

At a judicial commission hearing the following year, Snyder said he understood that defendants are supposed to be considered innocent until proven guilty but that he still felt that people wouldn’t be in court if they didn’t commit crimes.

“I meant, that they were guilty because they did something wrong. But they’re not guilty ‘til they come to court. They’re innocent ’til proven guilty,” he told the commission.

“They did something wrong. That’s why they got a ticket. But they’re not guilty,” he added.

Snyder, who was elected as a justice, is not an attorney and has agreed to never serve as a judge again.

Public records did not list a phone number for Snyder. Voicemails left with the Petersburgh Town Court were not immediately returned.

Petersburgh is a small town outside Albany near New York’s border with Vermont and Massachusetts. It has a population of about 1,400 people, according to census data.

In a statement, Robert H. Tembeckjian, administrator of the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, said “there is no place on the bench for someone who so deeply misunderstands the role of a judge and the administration of justice.”

“It is bad enough that a judge would seek to avoid such a fundamental civic responsibility as jury service. It is astounding that the judge would claim an inability to be impartial, and to declare under oath that the accused must be guilty or they would not be in court,” he said.

Courts in New York do not offer automatic jury duty exemptions to anyone, including judges.

National News

FILE - President Joe Biden talks with Connecticut Gov. Ned Lamont, left, and Rep. John Larson, D-Co...

Associated Press

Connecticut Rep. John Larson says a complex partial seizure caused him to stop speech on House floor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Connecticut U.S. Rep. John Larson, who inexplicably stopped speaking during a speech Monday on the House of Representatives floor, said Tuesday night he had suffered a complex partial seizure. The 76-year-old Democrat, who is serving his 13th term, said the House attending physician referred him for further evaluation following the incident. The […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Death Row building is seen at the Louisiana State Penitentiary Friday, Sept. 18, 2009, in An...

Associated Press

Louisiana seeks to resume executions imminently after a 15-year pause

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Louisiana will seek to resume carrying out death sentences in the coming months after a 15-year pause, this time using nitrogen gas as the execution method, the state’s attorney general said Tuesday. Attorney General Liz Murrill told The Associated Press that she expects at least four people on death row to […]

1 hour ago

In this courtroom sketch, Salman Rushdie testifies on the witness stand gesturing how the attacker ...

Associated Press

Excerpts from Salman Rushdie’s court testimony about a harrowing attack

MAYVILLE, N.Y. (AP) — Author Salman Rushdie testified Tuesday in the trial of a man accused of attacking him with a knife just after he took his seat for a panel discussion at the Chautauqua Institution in western New York. The noted author was on the witness stand for just about an hour, during which […]

3 hours ago

President Donald Trump, from right, speaks to reporters accompanied by Interior Secretary Doug Burg...

Associated Press

Apple changes Gulf of Mexico to Gulf of America based on Trump’s order

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Apple renamed the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America on its maps Tuesday after an order by President Donald Trump was made official by the U.S. Geographic Names Information System. The move follows Google, which announced last month that it would make the change once the official listing was […]

3 hours ago

FILE - PBS President and CEO Paula Kerger speaks during the PBS Executive Session at the Television...

Associated Press

With public broadcasters pressured by the Trump administration, PBS shuts down its diversity office

NEW YORK (AP) — PBS says it is shutting down its office of diversity, equity and inclusion to comply with President Donald Trump’s executive order, firing the two executives brought on when the effort was begun in 2021. The move, eliminating the jobs held by Cecilia Loving and her associate Gina Leow, comes as public […]

4 hours ago

Associated Press

Court sets March 19 date for first execution in Arizona in over 2 years

PHOENIX (AP) — The Arizona Supreme Court set a March 19 execution date Tuesday for a man who pleaded guilty to murder more than 17 years ago and recently said his death sentence was “long overdue.” It would be the state’s first application of the death penalty in more than two years. The court issued […]

4 hours ago

New York judge resigns after saying he can’t be on a jury since he thinks all defendants are guilty