SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: Kirkland employees shouldn’t undergo bias training

Nov 27, 2018, 5:48 AM

kirkland, menchie's, yogurt, protest...

A protest was held at the Kirkland Menchie's in the week following a incident when a black man was asked to leave the store for being suspicious. (Hanna Scott, KIRO 7)

(Hanna Scott, KIRO 7)

We talked ad nauseam last week about that yogurt shop in Kirkland.

In case you were out of town for Thanksgiving or just under a rock and don’t know the story, here’s a recap: A 31-year-old African-American man who works as a court-appointed supervisor was watching a visit between a mother and son at a Menchie’s frozen yogurt shop in Totem Lake, Kirkland. He was sitting at a table by himself without buying anything.

The two teenage girls who worked at the Menchie’s didn’t know that he was a supervisor, and felt apprehensive because of recent robberies that had occurred at the business. They called the owner, who then called 911, and Kirkland police asked the man to leave.

The victim of the incident, 31-year-old Byron Ragland, suggested at a press conference last week that proper reparations would be for the yogurt shop to fire the two girls, for the shop owner to lose his business license, and for Byron himself to get hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy all the restaurants currently operated by the yogurt shop owner. Oh, and he called the business owner, who is by the way a Filipino-American, a white supremacist.

Now we find out that all City of Kirkland employees will all undergo racial bias training.

My question is: should the media have to undergo bias training instead? Some of the local TV stations — which I won’t name — played the 911 call from the yogurt shop owner, Ramon Cruz. After playing the part where Cruz says that Ragland “looks suspicious,” they cut to a line later in the call where Cruz describes Ragland as African-American, as if he had made those two statements back-to-back.

The story line of this whole incident has been that the 911 call was racist. But if you listen to the raw call, the shop owner says nothing about race in his initial description of Ragland. It is not until the dispatcher asks for the man’s race 30 seconds later in the call that Cruz says Ragland appears to be African-American from the security camera footage.

If you just listen to the edited version of the call, the incident comes across as racist, as if the shop owner were equating Ragland being suspicious with his being African-American. But in reality, this is not how it was phrased at all. Cruz described only Ragland’s suspicious behavior, and the prior incidents at the shop that had the young female employees feeling nervous. He only brought up race after he was specifically asked by the dispatcher.

So — is that call really worthy of every member of the City of Kirkland having to undergo bias training? I would argue that this audio was manipulated by several different media outlets to make it sound like the owner was tying the suspicious look to the man’s race.

RELATED: Civil rights attorney says Kirkland incident is likely racist, but question is proportionality
RELATED: We can’t compare Menchie’s incident with Charleena Lyles

Associated Press

9 dead after shooting in northern Pennsylvania

Nine people were killed Friday in a shooting in Erie, Pennsylvania, Gov. Josh Shapiro said Saturday. Police said the suspected shooter was also dead. “I have not seen anything like this in my 28-plus years,” Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah told a local news station. “I’m not sure that the city of Erie has ever […]

38 minutes ago

Luke Ihnen, attorney for Christa Pike, speaks during a news conference after a judge ruled the Tenn...

Associated Press

Christa Pike, who survived an execution attempt, is discharged from hospital, attorney says

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Christa Pike, who survived Tennessee’s attempt to execute her by lethal injection, has been moved back to prison, according to a statement released by her attorneys. Pike, 50, was discharged from the hospital and is back at the Deborah K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, the women’s prison where she was housed for […]

55 minutes ago

This image from video obtained and verified by AP shows thick black smoke and flames rising from a ...

Associated Press

The airport in the Saudi capital has been attacked again, officials say

CAIRO (AP) — The airport in the Saudi capital was attacked again Saturday and was evacuated, two regional officials said, two days after three Saudi citizens including a pilot were killed there as the kingdom faces an extraordinary series of assaults in the new front in the Iran war. One official said air traffic to […]

2 hours ago

Pope Leo XIV arrives to celebrate a mass in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican, Thursday, Oct.8, 2...

Associated Press

Pope Leo declares death penalty ‘inadmissible’ as his native US plans to livestream execution

ROME (AP) — Pope Leo XIV on Saturday declared capital punishment ”inadmissible” as he marked the World Day Against the Death Penalty and his native United States announced plans to livestream an execution by firing squad. In a post on X, the American pope quoted the revised Catholic teaching on capital punishment ushered in by […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Pediatrician Irving Phillips examines a 16-month-old boy at a CommuniCARE+OLE clinic, June 2...

Associated Press

Trump’s Medicaid cuts strip refugees and other legal immigrants of their health coverage

New restrictions have stripped Medicaid coverage from certain legal immigrants, including refugees and victims of human trafficking, as part of broader federal changes to the health insurance program that are expected to force millions off their coverage. The change effective Oct. 1 cut from Medicaid what is estimated to be hundreds of thousands of people […]

3 hours ago

This photo made with a smartphone shows Independent Alaska U.S. House candidate Bill Hill, who is c...

Associated Press

A small-town Alaska fisherman has Republicans on the defensive as they try to keep US House majority

JUNEAU, Alaska (AP) — In the thick of Alaska’s primary election season this summer, independent Bill Hill took a break from his U.S. House campaign to return home to Bristol Bay. The world’s biggest sockeye salmon run was beginning, and that meant he needed to get back to work. “I told my team that I […]

4 hours ago

Dori: Kirkland employees shouldn’t undergo bias training