Seattle council member suggests eyesore deterrent to tree cutting

Apr 7, 2016, 4:18 PM | Updated: Apr 28, 2016, 12:07 pm

Seattle City Council member Lisa Herbold suggested adding billboards in the place of illegally chop...

Seattle City Council member Lisa Herbold suggested adding billboards in the place of illegally chopped trees. (AP)


Seattle City Council member Lisa Herbold suggested a sly deterrent Thursday morning for stopping homeowners from illegally chopping down trees: replacing them with a billboard.

“Sydney, (Australia) I think actually puts view-blocking signs,” she said. “It’s a very creative way to make sure that there’s a deterrent and people can’t just pay the fine and get the view in exchange.”

Related: ‘Cosmic connection’ made at King County’s community resources exchange

This discussion stems from the now-infamous West Seattle tree-cutting case, where homeowners hired a tree-cutter who removed 150 trees. Although the homeowners claim it was an accident, some legal experts disagree and the City Attorney’s office says they may face felony charges.

Some have speculated that the homeowners figured the fine from the city would be less than the gain in value of their homes, which now feature a pristine view.

The City Council committee didn’t adopt Herbold’s suggestion as a new city ordinance, but certainly discussed it.

The Seattle Department of Transportation owns part of the land where the trees were cut. SDOT director Scott Kubly told the council that the department is taking the situation “very seriously.” Kubly admitted the department could have done better. It took more than a month before the city responded to the removal of the trees.

“We got an email from a constituent, a resident, we didn’t follow up to ask a clarifying question and we should have done that, so that’s pretty clear and that way we can truly get an understanding of the severity &#8212 versus make assumptions.”

The tree-cutting issue is similar to an incident that sparked a lawsuit decided this week, with important implications. Neighbors dug a ditch and cut tree roots on Jennifer Mustoe’s Rainier, WA property. Mustoe claimed the neighbors cut the roots so severely that she worried the tree would die and fall onto her house.

Ultimately, she lost the lawsuit. On Monday, Judge Gary R Tabor ruled against her claim.

Attorney Mike Spence, who works on real estate cases that include tree-cutting disputes. He says the ruling, which happened earlier this week, sets a new precedent.

“The old law says that you have a duty of due care to prevent damage to your neighbor’s trees, but the court rejected that,” Spence said.

Mustoe valued the tree at $16,000 and said she spent $4,000 to remove it. But the court disagreed, saying this was a “reasonable” reason to remove the tree.

Kubly says SDOT is working on other plans to address the issue, such as setting up a deadline response time for calls about tree-cutting incidents.

He noted that there is a maximum 72-hour response time for potholes, but there isn’t that sort of mandate when it comes to trees.

The full City Council is expected to continue the discussion when it meets next year.

MyNorthwest News

I-5 pedestrian killed...

Bill Kaczaraba

Man killed in hit-and-run on Interstate 5 in Seattle

The Washington State Patrol is in the process of gathering further details about a traffic incident on Interstate-5that left one man dead.

23 hours ago

Tegu Tazz...


Granite Falls alligator turns out to be escaped pet tegu named ‘Tazz’

Reports of a 10-foot alligator have turned out to be an “incredibly docile and friendly” pet tegu by the name of Tazz.

24 hours ago

Apartment fire in Sotuh Lake Union. (via KIRO 7)...

Bill Kaczaraba

South Lake Union apartment fire contained, 2 may be injured

An apartment fire in South Lake Union has been contained, but two people may have been injured.. The fire was in the 320 block of 7th Ave N but units remain in the area. Authorities are asking you to avoid the area. Firefighters are on scene at a reported fire in an apartment building in […]

1 day ago



How a faulty CrowdStrike update crashed computers around the world

All it took was one faulty CrowdStrike software update to cause global disruptions that grounded flights, and other services.

1 day ago

Image: A dog was found around 2 a.m. on Wednesday, June 12, 2024 at Colman Dock in Seattle without ...

Steve Coogan

Lost dog found alone on Seattle ferry dock heads to a new home

A lost dog found without its owner on a ferry dock in Seattle last month, later identified as Tripp, has found a new home.

1 day ago

Image: The Tacoma Police Department released images of a shooting in the parking lot of at the Taco...

Steve Coogan

Gunman nearly hits Tacoma schools security officer during daytime shooting

Police in Tacoma are probing a shooting where a bullet nearly hit hitting a security officer working at the Tacoma Public Schools building.

1 day ago

Seattle council member suggests eyesore deterrent to tree cutting