MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Man found guilty in 1991 cold case murder in Federal Way

May 25, 2023, 12:05 PM | Updated: 1:00 pm

yarborough...

From left, an image of Patrick Leon Nicholas; victim Sarah Yarborough, who was found dead Dec. 14, 1991 near Federal Way High School. (KIRO 7)

(KIRO 7)

Update 12:05 p.m.: 

Patrick Leon Nicholas was sentenced Thursday to 548 months (slightly more than 45.5 years) for the 1991 cold case murder of Federal Way teen Sarah Yarborough.

On May 10, Patrick Leon Nicholas was found guilty of murder by a jury.

Original Story:

Patrick Leon Nicholas was found guilty of murder by a jury for the 1991 cold case murder of Federal Way teen Sarah Yarborough.

His trial began April 17 at the Norm Maleng Regional Justice Center in Kent, where he was eventually found guilty of first-degree felony murder with sexual motivation and second-degree murder with sexual motivation. Nichols was found not guilty of premeditated murder in the first degree.

Arrest made in 27-year-old murder of Federal Way teen Sarah Yarborough

“Had we had the opportunity and the ability years ago to run familial testing, we would have identified, conceivably, that brother, and it would have helped us to narrow down and figure out who ultimately was responsible for this particular crime,” retired King County homicide detective Kathy Decker told KIRO 7.

On Dec. 14, 1991, 16-year-old Sarah Yarborough was found raped and murdered on the campus of Federal Way High School after she was last seen leaving her home to go to a high school dance competition. Both her car and her body were discovered on campus later that day.

Nicholas was arrested in 2019 after police used DNA testing at the crime scene.

Court documents revealed Nicholas had a record of sex crimes and lived in the area when Yarborough was killed.

KIRO 7 News contributed to this report.

MyNorthwest News

Boeing Max 737 families...

Associated Press

Victims of Boeing 737 Max crashes asking for the company to be fined billions

Families of some of the people who died in two Boeing 737 Max crashes are asking federal officials to fine Boeing $24.8 billion

1 hour ago

Photo: A Juneteenth celebration took place in Tacoma....

James Lynch

Tacoma hosts largest Juneteenth celebration in the state

For the second straight year, what's billed as the largest Juneteenth celebration in Washington was held at Tacoma's Stewart Heights Park.

15 hours ago

Photo: A Milton officer was severely injured while he was trying to take down a suspect on Wednesda...

Julia Dallas

‘A very emotional situation:’ Milton officer run over, dragged through parking lot

A Milton officer was severely injured while he was trying to take down a suspect on Wednesday in a Taco Bell parking lot.

16 hours ago

Image: Former financial TV analyst James Arthur McDonald, Jr. was arrested at a residence in Port O...

Steve Coogan

Ex-financial TV analyst who became a fugitive arrested for fraud in Washington

A former CEO of two investment firms who was a frequent paid guest on a cable network's programs has been arrested for fraud.

18 hours ago

Image: The service center for Marysville School District...

Julia Dallas

State sends reinforcements to review Marysville’s struggling school budget

The Washington State Superintendent of Public Instruction has put together a committee to review Marysville School District's budget.

20 hours ago

Image: A person holds several small Pride flags during a recent event in Washington....

The KIRO 7 staff with MyNorthwest editors

Pride flag raised at Newcastle City Hall after City Council reverses decision

The Newcastle City Council reversed their previous decision Tuesday and elected to raise the Pride flag at City Hall. The council voted 4-3.

21 hours ago

Man found guilty in 1991 cold case murder in Federal Way