SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?

Sep 11, 2017, 5:15 PM

Irma...

This photo shows a home destroyed by Hurricane Irma in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla., Monday, Sept. 11, 2017. (Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

(Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

Rush Limbaugh took a lot of heat this week for calling out the media on how much they hype extreme weather like Hurricane Irma. He called it part of the Liberal agenda on climate change.

Then he looked at the radar from the National Weather Service and promptly evacuated his Florida compound.

So who was right? At least at the eye of the hurricane?

RELATED: In defense of meteorologist – don’t get mad at forecasts

As many of you know, my parents live in Naples, Florida. This is their 20th hurricane season down there, and they rarely evacuate. For Irma, it initially looked like it was going to hit Miami, so their plan was to stay put. By the time its path shifted west, all the shelters were packed, and it was too late for a couple in their 70s to risk the drive north.

I obsessed in front of the Weather Channel all weekend doing the mental calculations of what a 12-15 foot storm surge would look like in their neighborhood. I had lived through a 22-foot surge during Katrina, and it wiped the town of Bay St. Louis off the map.

But the surge from Irma never came. It wasn’t even close to 15 feet.

Was Rush Limbaugh right? Is there a weather conspiracy that caused hundreds of thousands of Floridians to buy gas and food and water and hotel rooms? Did the shadowy left wing elites win again?

Would it have been better if the media was like, “We usually get these wrong, so Florida, don’t worry about it. You’ll probably be OK.”

Weather professionals are really in a tough spot. They are speaking in probabilities and computer models. Do they hype up the possible catastrophic outcomes? Of course. That’s human nature looking at a computer telling you the worst thing possible. Would it be better if they painted a rosier picture? For me, there are several occupations that I want to have a dash of pessimism. Airplane pilots, surgeons, and weathermen. I don’t want to hear any of them say, “Seems like it’ll be OK.”

All you have to do is go 90 miles to the south of Florida to see the full wrath of Irma in Cuba and then continue to follow her wake through the Caribbean to see that this storm was a monster. Yes, the hurricane wasn’t as bad as predicted — in the US. But it killed and destroyed on the way here.

Does this mean there’s a bunch of climate change radicals sitting in a conference room somewhere eating bagels and high-fiving right now. I think not. This is one instance where they are glad to be wrong.

As my 70-something mother would say, “Better to be safe than sorry.”

 

Associated Press

Hurricane Nolo gains speed as it moves away from Hawaii, but high winds, flash floods are still risk

HILO, Hawaii (AP) — Hurricane Nolo was moving away from the Hawaiian Islands on Sunday, but the threat of heavy rains, flash flooding and strong winds persisted in areas recovering from previous storms. By early Sunday, Nolo was about 260 miles (418 kilometers) southwest of Hawaii’s southernmost point and was moving away from the Big […]

51 minutes ago

A Coast Guardsman tosses a rope to a kayaker in distress after the kayaker's boat overturned north ...

Tom Brock

San Juan Islands Rescue: Coast Guard crews save man after his kayak overturns

A Coast Guard helicopter and rescue boat saved a man from the chilly waters of the Salish Sea Friday, after his kayak capsized near Orcas Island.

1 hour ago

Associated Press

Three people were killed and four were injured in shooting at Detroit strip club, police say

DETROIT (AP) — Three people were killed and four more were injured when an argument led to gunfire at an after-hours strip club Sunday morning in Detroit, officials said. Police responding to the 7:21 a.m. shooting on a largely residential street found three men who had been fatally shot, Detroit Police Chief Todd Bettison told […]

2 hours ago

Boeing (2)...

Tom Brock

Software glitch raises safety concerns for Boeing 737 MAX planes

Boeing has notified its customers of a computer glitch on its 737 MAX planes that could force pilots to land manually, instead of using autopilot.

3 hours ago

Iraq's Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations General Ass...

Associated Press

UN speakers’ go-to quotes: Ancient texts, modern greats and a little Talking Heads

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Presidents, premiers, monarchs and cabinet ministers have plenty to say at their annual gathering at the U.N. General Assembly. Still, sometimes they borrow a few words, quoting from a range of sources. Speakers this week touched on homeland sayings, ancient texts, figures of moral authority and more — even a bit […]

4 hours ago

Police stand at a road block on the road to RAF Fairford after an incident, in Whelford, England, S...

Associated Press

Air base at the center of a UK terror probe has been used by the US Air Force during the Iran war

LONDON (AP) — British police arrested five men on Sunday on suspicion of preparing an act of terrorism and explosives offenses outside RAF Fairford, a military base in western England that’s operated by the U.S. Air Force. Three suspicious vehicles are being searched, and counterterror officers are leading the investigation. Here’s what to know about […]

4 hours ago

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?