City of Seattle counters income tax lawsuits

Sep 29, 2017, 5:07 PM | Updated: 5:57 pm

seattle Income tax, state income tax...

Taxes. (Chris Potter, Flickr)

(Chris Potter, Flickr)

The City of Seattle wants the lawsuits against its recently passed income tax shut down before they get to trial.

The City of Seattle has filed a motion for a summary judgement, meaning it wishes the court to determine that the cases fighting its income tax are too weak to go any further. In a statement Friday, the city argues its council was fully authorized by the state Legislature to pass a personal income tax on high-income residents. Attorneys representing the city also argue that Seattle should not be held to court rulings from the 1930s, which some state tax law is based upon.

RELATED: What people outside Seattle should know about its income tax lawsuit

“Those nearly century-old Washington Supreme Court decisions relied on case law that is no longer valid, incorrect statements of the law, and unfounded conclusions,” the city’s statement reads.

“Seattle’s personal income tax is best characterized as an excise tax rather than a property tax …” it argues.

A King County Superior Court judge is expected to hear arguments for the case on Nov. 17. The city is being represented by Pacifica Law Group.

Seattle income tax lawsuits

Seattle’s tax has resulted in three lawsuits. Washington law, which was partially decided in court in the 1930s, states that income is property, and that all property taxes must be uniformly imposed. Therefore, it is argued, Seattle cannot pick and choose how much and whose income it wants to tax. Washington law also states that local governments cannot impose income taxes.

The city has fully expected to defend the tax in court, in fact, legal challenges were part of its plan when it passed it. The argument for summary judgment provides insight into the city’s reasoning:

Plaintiffs challenge the legality of the city’s personal income tax. But the tax is within the taxing authority delegated by the state and should be upheld. First, the law taxes residents’ total personal income, not net income. Thus, the state law prohibiting city net income taxes does not apply. Second, the city’s personal income tax is not a tax on property so constitutional restriction on property taxes do not apply. The 1930s cases that held income is property for tax purposes should be overturned because those cases relied on case law that is no longer valid, incorrect statements of the law, and unfounded conclusions. Indeed, the weight of judicial authority at the time, and today, holds that an income tax is not a property tax. Third, the city’s personal income tax is best characterized as an excise tax, or perhaps sui generis (as the Washington Supreme Court recently indicated). The city has been granted broad authority to enact non-property taxes, both in the form of excise taxes and otherwise for all local purposes. Pursuant to these statutes, the city has full authority to enact a local income tax.

The city respectfully requests this court grant it summary judgement and declare the city’s personal income tax both statutorily authorized and constitutional.

“Sui generis” is a legal term that means “unique.”

City’s Motion for SJ PDF

MyNorthwest News

Photo: A deputy's body camera captured a runaway wallaby in Parkland....

Julia Dallas

Runaway wallaby hops out of arms reach of deputies in Parkland

 A wallaby was caught on camera running around Parkland Sunday morning. Pierce County deputies and WSP responded.

32 minutes ago

seattle sex trafficking...

Frank Sumrall

Seattle resident arrested for sex trafficking in San José

A San José special operations unit arrested a Seattle resident last week on suspicion of alleged commercial sex trafficking.

4 hours ago

5-car crash sr 900...

Frank Sumrall

Mustang causes 5-car crash on SR 900 after veering onto oncoming traffic

A 5-car crash on State Route 900 (SR 900) in Renton Sunday led to four injured individuals, a five-hour highway backup and a brush fire.

7 hours ago

Photo: Neighbors in Mount Vernon are being praised for saving young kids from a burning home....

Samantha Lomibao, KIRO 7

Neighbors in Mount Vernon save young kids home alone from burning house

Neighbors in Mount Vernon are being praised for saving young kids from a burning home. The fire sparked on June 3.

19 hours ago

Photo: Republican presidential candidate former President Donald Trump is surrounded by U.S. Secret...

Julie Carr Smyth, Jill Colvin, Colleen Long, Michael Balsamo, Eric Tucker and Michelle L. Price, The Associated Press

Trump heads to convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

Trump called for unity and resilience after an attempt on his life added fresh uncertainty to an already tumultuous presidential campaign.

20 hours ago

Photo: More than 70 Seattle firefighters responded to a Columbia City fire after a construction sit...

Julia Dallas

Columbia City construction site goes up in flames; downs power lines, damages cars and home

More than 70 Seattle firefighters responded to a construction site in Columbia City after it went up in flames early Saturday morning.

21 hours ago

City of Seattle counters income tax lawsuits