Bullied boyfriend or calculated killer? Jury to decide Joseph McEnroe’s fate
Mar 23, 2015, 6:42 PM | Updated: Mar 24, 2015, 6:10 am
Joseph McEnroe is accused of killing six members of his girlfriend's family on Christmas Eve 2007. A jury will begin deliberations Tuesday. (KIRO Radio/Ibby Denkmann)
(KIRO Radio/Ibby Denkmann)
“He did it for his girlfriend,” said Prosecutor Scott O’Toole in an emphatic closing rebuttal at the King County Superior Courthouse Monday.
A jury will now decide whether Joseph McEnroe is guilty of murdering six members of girlfriend Michele Anderson’s family in a grisly attack on Christmas Eve, 2007.
McEnroe scribbled notes for his defense team, his eyes lowered during the final statements that could decide whether he ultimately faces the death penalty.
O’Toole claims McEnroe and Anderson were motivated by “greed and anger” when they shot and killed Wayne Anderson and his wife Judy.
Michele perceived a pattern of disrespect from her family members and argued with them about money.
After the first murders, McEnroe helped hide Michele’s parents’ bodies in a shed behind the main home, cleaning up evidence while they waited for the rest of the Anderson family to arrive for a Christmas celebration.
In taped interviews with King County investigators, both Anderson and McEnroe confessed to shooting Scott Anderson, Michele’s brother, his wife Erica and their two young children, Nathan and Olivia.
Michele Anderson’s trial will begin after McEnroe’s concludes.
When deliberations begin Tuesday morning, jury members must consider whether to convict McEnroe of first degree murder, which indicates premeditation and intention in the killings. They can also choose to return a lesser charge of second degree murder, indicating no premeditation.
Prosecutor Scott O’Toole argued shooting the Anderson family a total of 14 times was absolutely premeditated, citing forensic evidence, the couple’s scramble to clean up Wayne and Judy’s blood before the extended Anderson family arrived, and statements on their taped confessions.
Defense attorney Leo Hamaji said during his closing statement that Joseph McEnroe was unable to premeditate the crimes because he was mentally ill and completely dominated by Michele. Hamaji detailed McEnroe’s abusive childhood and said he was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder, showing similar characteristics to domestic violence victims.
An expert witness for the defense, Dr. Donald Dutton, previously testified Anderson and McEnroe suffered from a shared psychosis known as “Folie-a-deux,” and said McEnroe was unable to defy his domineering girlfriend.
Hamaji said this mental state compelled McEnroe to jump in and participate in the murders.
“When he got into that situation where he felt Michele was being attacked, he reacted,” Hamaji said.
The defense emphasized that any reasonable doubt about McEnroe’s premeditation should push the jury to choose second degree murder.
“The fact of the matter is that he decided to throw in his lot with his girlfriend,” prosecutor O’Toole countered. “If he was dominated by his girlfriend, I would suggest to you that’s not the reason why he didn’t premeditate, that’s exactly the reason why he did premeditate.”
If McEnroe is convicted of first degree murder, a second penalty phase trial will kick in to decide if he should be given the death penalty.
