MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Seattle income tax case inches toward Washington Supreme Court

Nov 18, 2019, 9:55 AM | Updated: 11:58 am

Income tax, Washington state...

A controversial decision from an appeals court could blaze a trail for an income tax in Washington. (Photo by Chris Hondros/Getty Images)

(Photo by Chris Hondros/Getty Images)

Seattle’s income tax case continues to inch its way forward, with the city officially putting in its request to have it heard before the Washington State Supreme Court.

Diving into Seattle’s case for an income tax

In 2017, the Seattle City Council passed a 2.25 percent tax on personal income over $250,000 dollars. The money was supposed to go to a variety of public services. It was overturned in court, and the city has been fighting the battle ever since.

“We already know that the state of Washington has the most regressive tax structure in the entire country,” said Seattle City Attorney Pete Holmes.

Back in July, the Washington State Court of Appeals handed down a shocking decision, ruling that the City of Seattle has the legal authority to impose an income tax, provided it’s uniform across all tax brackets.

In early November, an appeals court rejected a request to take a second look at its ruling.

That left the door open for a showdown in Washington’s Supreme Court, where a few different things will need to be decided:

  • Whether a tax on high-earners Seattle approved in 2018 can be implemented at all
  • Whether the appeal’s court decision allowing a uniform tax across all earners is Constitutional
  • Whether income qualifies as property

The City of Seattle is hoping to see a 90-year-old legal precedent that labels income as property overturned, something that’s been a major roadblock toward levying an income tax anywhere in Washington state.

Opinion: History of Washington’s income tax shows why we need it

Opposing the city’s case is the Pacific Legal Foundation, which cites past defeats of an income tax in Washington state.

“(Seattle’s) precise argument has gone to the state Supreme Court seven times already, and has been found to be unconstitutional all seven times,” said the PLF’s Brian Hodges.

While the city sees an income tax as a way to provide a more equitable system for everyone, Hodges and the PLF view the issue as one of constitutionality.

“This case represents a purposeful violation of the constitution,” he said.

In the days ahead, the city and the PLF will wait in a holding pattern — there’s no deadline for the state Supreme Court to decide on whether to hear the case.

MyNorthwest News

New gym...

Paola Tristan Arruda, KIRO 7 News

New gym opens its doors amid ongoing Eastlake construction

Seattle Strength and Performance, or SSP, celebrated the grand opening of its newest location in Eastlake.

3 hours ago

Costco recall (1)...

MyNorthwest Staff

Costco recalls popular holiday item in 12 states

Costco is recalling a widely used topping ahead of the holiday rush.

3 hours ago

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson...

KIRO Newsradio staff

Mayor Wilson criticizes council for adding $31 million in one-time spending to budget

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson is pushing back on changes the Seattle City Council’s Select Budget Committee made to her proposed 2027 budget.

4 hours ago

Silverdale airbnb bear-spray...

MyNorthwest Staff

Silverdale Airbnb owner accused of bear-spraying guests, threatening them with apparent firearm

A Silverdale Airbnb owner faces two assault charges after he allegedly bear-sprayed two guests and threatened them with what appeared to be a handgun.

4 hours ago

meteors...

Chief Meteorologist Morgan Palmer, KIRO 7 News

Want to see the Leonids meteors? Here’s the best time to look up

It’ll be a quiet evening in western Washington, but if you’re willing to stay up, you might get a chance to see a few meteors.

5 hours ago

fall city teen...

James Lynch

Fall City teen accused of killing 5 family members pleads not guilty in adult court

Andrew Humiston, the 17-year-old accused of killing his parents and three siblings at their Fall City home in October 2024, appeared in adult court.

5 hours ago

Seattle income tax case inches toward Washington Supreme Court