MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Washington Court of Appeals affirms dismissal of Seattle’s ‘Jump Start’ payroll tax lawsuit

Jun 21, 2022, 1:57 PM | Updated: 1:57 pm

...

A Washington Court of Appeals upheld the King County Superior Court’s dismissal of a lawsuit brought by the Greater Seattle of Chamber of Commerce that contested the constitutionality of a payroll expense tax.

In June, King County Superior Court judge Mary Roberts ruled that a payroll tax that applies to businesses that spend $7 million or more on payroll in Seattle is “constitutionally permissible.”

The judgement came after the Greater Seattle Chamber of Commerce contested the constitutionality of the tax which was passed by the City Council with a vote of 7-2 last summer on July 6.

According to court documents, the chamber contended that the tax is a tax on “employers’ payment of compensation to employees,” making it “constitutionally impermissible tax on an employee’s act of earning a living.”

However, the judgment stated, “…the tax is levied on the business entity, not the employee; taxpayers ‘may not make any deductions from the employees’ compensation to pay’ for the tax.”

“The city has authority to tax all business activities in the city. The payroll expense tax is an excise tax measured by payroll expenses and paid by businesses that engage in business with employees in the city,” court documents stated in part.

The payroll tax plan called JumpStart Seattle was introduced by Councilmember Teresa Mosqueda.

“I am glad to have this frivolous challenge behind us, since the reality is the opponents say they want the same investments JumpStart will fund: more affordable housing, pathways out of homelessness, and economic resilience for our local economy,” Mosqueda said in a release. “We now have the assurance that this progressive revenue stream is coming as we seek to respond to the crises worsened by COVID-19.”

Amazon and other businesses with annual payrolls of at least $7 million would pay a tax for each employee with a salary of $150,000.

The tax rate would go up when companies pay workers more than $500,000, or for companies with Seattle payrolls greater than $1 billion.

“We can jump start our economy and do it in an equitable and inclusive way,” Mosqueda previously said.

Mosqueda insisted that she was not targeting Amazon.

“This is not about one company,” she said. “This is not about one targeted effort, this is about a universal approach to really invest in our local economy.”

About two weeks after the tax passed, then-Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan refused to sign the tax bill but she did not veto it either.

In a letter to the city clerk, Durkan wrote the bill will likely have an opposite result in terms of increasing revenue for the city, as it will average $2,700 per job.

Durkan also stated that the city will need additional “progressive revenues” to overcome these unusual times and that the city needs to move away from a “regressive tax system to one that is more progressive.”



MyNorthwest News

Earthquake Auburn...

Frank Lenzi

Auburn earthquake: More than 1,600 report feeling shaking

It wasn't your imagination. The earth was moving late Friday night near Lea Hill in Auburn.

2 hours ago

GTA...

Katrina Guischard

GTA 6 is here. What parents need to know before handing over the controller

If you've got children or teenagers at home, chances are you've already heard about Grand Theft Auto (GTA) 6.

3 hours ago

_El Niño...

Ted Buehner

Strengthening El Niño points to warmer winter, weaker snowpack for Washington

El Niño continues to strengthen according to the National Weather Service’s Climate Prediction Center (CPC).

14 hours ago

911...

James Lynch

Man accused of calling King County 911 nearly 1,400 times in 3 days

A 35-year-old man is accused of calling King County’s 911 center nearly 1,400 times in three days over a civil court matter.

14 hours ago

Art Marble...

Heather Bosch, KIRO 7 News

Seattle bar owner defends ‘ladies night is for women’ email

The owner of a Seattle bar and restaurant said he’s getting death threats after a Sep. 19 email to his employees was shared on social media.

14 hours ago

bigfoot track...

Luke Duecy

1982 Bigfoot investigation: Forest Service releases records of suspected Sasquatch hoax in WA

The legend of Bigfoot has another chapter in Washington history, thanks to newly released government records.

15 hours ago

Washington Court of Appeals affirms dismissal of Seattle’s ‘Jump Start’ payroll tax lawsuit