MYNORTHWEST NEWS

How critics will reverse new state marriage equality law

Feb 16, 2012, 6:43 AM | Updated: 7:59 am

Washington is the seventh state to legalize same sex marriage but approval came from the legislatur...

Washington is the seventh state to legalize same sex marriage but approval came from the legislature. When the issue goes to voters, historically, it always fails. (AP Photo/file)

(AP Photo/file)

Washington is the seventh state to legalize same sex marriage but approval came from the legislature. When the issue goes to voters, historically, it always fails.

Critics of Washington’s new marriage equality law are gathering signatures on a referendum to overturn the law, signed Monday by Governor Chris Gregoire. At the bill signing ceremony in Olympia, gay state representative Jamie Pedersen of Seattle told supporters “we will all need to work together to tell our stories and defend this victory.”

Joseph Backholm, director of the Family Policy Institute of Washington, admits those stories might sway some voters.

“It’s a logic-less but totally emotional and occasionally effective argument but the reality is the fact that your love and commitment might be the same is not relevant,” said Backholm. “The state has never been interested in the private reasons people marry, there has never been a love and commitment threshold that was the determiner for who got marriage recognition.”

Backholm’s group is part of a larger effort called Preserve Marriage Washington, a national coalition with the goal of preserving the traditional definition of marriage. He argues that the issue is no longer about equality, since Washington voters approved the “Everything But Marriage Act.”

“That’s actually a factor that plays in our favor because you can appeal to people’s sense of fairness only so far and they have done that with Everything But Marriage, where same-sex couples have all the rights and benefits. But now you’re saying ‘we want to redefine a term that’s had a common and uncontroversial understanding for the entire time the state has existed,'” said Backholm.

Across the country, 31 states have held ballot measures on the issue of same sex marriage, in one form or another, and it always fails. Twenty-nine states have amended their constitutions to ban gay marriage or have passed laws defining marriage as a heterosexual union.

About the campaign in Washington to overturn the new marriage equality law, University of Washington law professor Peter Nicolas expects opponents of same sex marriage will make an effort to confuse people.

“Voters are fleetingly involved in legislative processes so they can be easily swayed, potentially, by advertising that’s designed to have an emotional reaction in a way that sometimes legislators are insulated from,” said Nicolas.

He expects critics will campaign on stereotypical fears of gays and children and the impact of same-sex marriage on schools and curriculum. Backholm acknowledges as much, claiming parents don’t want children taught that homosexual and heterosexual relationships are the same.

Nicolas also predicts critics will highlight how same sex marriage threatens freedom of religion, something he considers a specious argument.

“People are protective of the rights of religious organizations and nobody is telling any church, synagogue, mosque that they have to perform same sex marriages after this bill is moved into law,” said Nicolas.

Backholm, with Preserve Marriage Washington, thinks Washington voters favor equal treatment but they’ll slam on the brakes when it comes to redefining marriage. He expects the referendum to overturn the new law will draw a strong voter turnout. And both sides expect to spend many millions of dollars in the campaign, much of the money coming from out of state.

MyNorthwest News

Department of Justice (1)...

MyNorthwest Staff

Seattle man charged in decade-long immigration fraud scheme involving friends, family

A Seattle man was arrested Tuesday on an indictment in which he was charged in a scheme to submit false information to obtain immigration status for others.

17 hours ago

dad kids responsibilities...

Katrina Guischard

Viral video of moms’ weekend getaway sparks debate over whether dads need child care backup

Moms share insights on childcare during weekends away, igniting debate on dads' responsibilities in parenting.

17 hours ago

Poe Russell ground stop...

Frank Lenzi

KIRO Newsradio host Angela Poe Russell stuck in Cabo until Tuesday after ground stop

KIRO Newsradio host Angela Poe Russell and her family are stuck in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, until Tuesday after a ground stop left them waiting aboard their plane for 6½ hours Friday.

2 days ago

everett meth trafficking...

MyNorthwest Staff

Everett drug trafficker sentenced after delivering meth to law enforcement officer

A 36-year-old Mexican national was sentenced to five years in prison after he was found tending to a drug stash house in Everett and making drug deliveries.

2 days ago

seattle holiday carousel westlake...

MyNorthwest Staff

Seattle’s Westlake Park holiday carousel returns after years-long hiatus

For the first time in more than five years, the Westlake Park Holiday Carousel is returning for the 2026 holiday season.

2 days ago

shooting...

MyNorthwest Staff

Shooting leaves 1 dead in Redmond, 2 suspects believed to be on the loose

A shooting in Redmond left one person dead, and two suspects are believed to be on the loose.

2 days ago

How critics will reverse new state marriage equality law