NATIONAL NEWS

State can’t use medication evidence to counter insanity defense in fatal crash, Georgia court says

May 28, 2025, 10:33 AM | Updated: 1:48 pm

ATLANTA (AP) — In the prosecution of a Georgia woman who caused a fatal car crash while suffering a psychotic break, the state cannot use evidence that she had stopped taking some of her psychiatric medications to counter her insanity defense, the state’s highest court ruled Wednesday.

Michelle Wierson was driving her Volkswagen Tiguan at high speed through the streets of DeKalb County, in Atlanta’s suburbs, when she hit a Toyota Corolla stopped at a traffic light. The impact pushed the car into the intersection where it collided with another car. Miles Jenness, a 5-year-old passenger in the Toyota, suffered a traumatic brain injury and a severed spine and died days later.

Everyone agrees that Wierson caused the September 2018 wreck. Her defense attorneys filed notice that she intended to plead not guilty by reason of insanity, saying that at the time of the wreck she was suffering from a “delusional compulsion” caused by mental illness that absolves her of criminal liability. The DeKalb County district attorney’s office wanted to present evidence that Wierson had stopped taking some medication prescribed to treat bipolar disorder, arguing that the jury should be allowed to consider that she voluntarily contributed to her mental state.

The trial court said the state could use that evidence, but the state Court of Appeals reversed that ruling in a pretrial appeal. The state then appealed to the state Supreme Court, which upheld the intermediate appeals court’s ruling.

An Atlanta-area psychologist with a years-long history of bipolar disorder, Wierson believed at the time of the crash that she was on a mission from God to save her daughter from being killed, her lawyers have said.

Georgia law outlines two tests for someone seeking to use an insanity defense at trial. Both have to do with the person’s mental state “at the time of” the alleged crime. The first says a person shall not be found guilty of a crime if they “did not have mental capacity to distinguish between right and wrong” related to the act. The second says a person shall not be found guilty of a crime if the person acted because of “a delusional compulsion” that “overmastered” their will.

An expert hired by the defense and another engaged by the court found that Wierson met both of those criteria. Justice Andrew Pinson wrote in Wednesday’s majority opinion that the law says nothing about the cause of the person’s mental state at the time of the crime.

“Put simply, the plain language of the insanity-defense statutes gives not even a hint that these defenses would not be available to a person who has ‘brought about’ the relevant mental state voluntarily, whether by not taking medication or otherwise,” he wrote.

Robert Rubin, a lawyer for Wierson, has said that his client is “haunted by the tragic consequences” of her actions. But he said in an email Wednesday that he hopes the Supreme Court ruling will allow the case to be resolved without a trial.

“The Georgia Supreme Court reaffirmed the basic principle that the focus of an insanity case is the defendant’s state of mind at the time of the act,” he wrote. “The State never disputed that our client was insane at the time of the accident. Its attempt to make this case about alleged medication compliance was misplaced and dragged this case out unnecessarily.”

The DeKalb County district attorney’s office did not immediately have a comment Wednesday. Bruce Hagen, a lawyer for the Jenness family said in an email that he was “very disappointed, although not surprised” by the high court’s ruling.

In its ruling on this case, the Supreme Court also overturned its own ruling in a 1982 case that had created an exception to the insanity defenses. That case involved a man diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia who, against his doctor’s orders, put himself in a highly stressful situation and ended up killing two people.

National News

Rep. Nick Begich III, R-Alaska, sign-waves with supporters at the edge of Midtown Mall, Monday, Nov...

Associated Press

Republican Nick Begich wins reelection to Alaska’s US House seat, a rare bright spot for the GOP

JUNEAU, Alaska (AP) — Republican U.S. Rep. Nick Begich has won reelection to Alaska’s lone U.S. House seat, hanging on during a year that saw Democrats regain control in both houses of Congress. His win Wednesday through the state’s ranked vote tabulations process was a rare bright spot for Republicans, whose ranks in the House […]

2 hours ago

Associated Press

Republican Nick Begich wins reelection to U.S. House in Alaska’s at-large Congressional District

Republican Nick Begich won election Wednesday to the U.S. House of Representatives representing Alaska’s at-large Congressional District, defeating independent candidate Bill Hill. Begich’s victory over Hill means he’ll serve a second straight term, helped in part by President Donald Trump’s endorsement. Hill ran as an independent but had back from the state’s Democratic Party as […]

2 hours ago

Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, D-Mich., and his wife Sarah Jukaku, left, walk to a gathering at the Cap...

Associated Press

Vance and El-Sayed are looking to meet after a bitter, personal campaign season

WASHINGTON (AP) — Vice President JD Vance and Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed are preparing to meet, the incoming Democratic lawmaker and the White House said, after a bitter campaign season that featured sharp and at-times personal attacks between the two men. The circumstances of the would-be meeting were not immediately clear, nor was it certain […]

3 hours ago

FILE - Floyd Mayweather, Jr., arrives with President Donald Trump at Laughlin Bullhead Internationa...

Associated Press

Charges dismissed against boxer Floyd Mayweather Jr. over bad check in Las Vegas

LAS VEGAS (AP) — A Las Vegas court dismissed felony charges against Floyd Mayweather Jr. on Wednesday at the request of prosecutors, following allegations the boxer wrote a bad check to purchase a watch, according to court records. A hearing in the case that had been scheduled for Thursday was canceled. Mayweather, 49, was charged […]

4 hours ago

_cyber outages...

ERIC TUCKER and MIKE CATALINI, The Associated Press

Takeaways from Mullin’s House testimony on cyber outages, the Texas-LSU flight and immigration

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, in testimony to Congress, tried to tamp down speculation about a series of recent cyber outages.

4 hours ago

In this image from video, authorities respond to the scene of a helicopter crash in Biscayne Bay, F...

Associated Press

Helicopter that crashed in Florida, killing 1 and injuring 2, was flying ‘extremely’ low, NTSB says

MIAMI (AP) — A helicopter that crashed earlier this month in Biscayne Bay, killing one person and critically injuring two others, had been flying so low that it hit the water on a turn, the National Transportation Safety Board said Wednesday. The Robinson R44 II helicopter went down Nov. 4 near Bill Baggs State Park […]

5 hours ago

State can’t use medication evidence to counter insanity defense in fatal crash, Georgia court says