SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date

Oct 7, 2016, 9:16 AM | Updated: 11:45 am

Costco blind date...

Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met, in front of mustard in Costco. (Contributed)

(Contributed)

It was a match made in Costco. Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met — with mustard.

“We met in Costco in the mustard aisle,” Susan told KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson. “It was the Kirkland Costco, aisle 38.”

Why Seattle women are such big drinkers — men

That was in March 2014. It was a Costco blind date. The mustard-themed meeting was a good blend. The pair were married six months later.

So this month, the couple decided to celebrate their wedding anniversary by touring Costcos in the area dressed up as Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. Their tour made the news. Susan said that there has been so much depressing news lately, she wanted to do something fun.

A Costco blind date

David got Susan’s phone number from a friend and the two started chatting on the phone. They hit it off. So David decided to take it to the next level.

“I wanted to ask her out on a date, but I wanted it to be very normal … so I invited her out to Costco,” he said. “I think she thought I was a bit crazy.”

She didn’t think he was crazy.

“I thought he was either really cheap,” Susan said. “Or, because I’m a single mom, maybe he was going to fill a basket and bless me with a whole bunch of food.”

“I got neither of them,” she noted. “I got free samples, though.”

Susan headed into the blind date with an open mind. She didn’t know what the guy on the phone looked like, though David had her business card with her photo on it.

“I’m waiting there by the mustard and anytime someone came down, I was like, ‘Is this him, is this him?’” Susan said. “There was this lovely lady named Doris having a difficult time deciding if she wanted to buy mayonnaise or not. And she was distracting me, and I was like, ‘Listen, lady, I don’t have time to talk with you right now because this could be the date of my life.’ He turned the corner then, with a smile, and I figured that was him.”

“In person, she was much prettier than her business card,” David added. “I asked Doris to take a picture of us. That was the beginning of us becoming Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. The mustard was in the background. We walked around getting free samples and talking.”

As it turns out, Costco was a good date idea, but David did make one misstep that day — forgot to buy Susan the hot dog he promised her. On their anniversary, he fixed that. The two ate a hot dog together, starting at each end and meeting in the middle.

Soundview tacoma little league wa...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘They make me proud as hell’: Tacoma dad chokes up as team faces Little League World Series elimination

Tacoma's Soundview Little League aims for victory against Phenix City in a crucial win-or-go-home game.

7 minutes ago

People look out across Lake Ontario from the harbor in Toronto, Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2026. (Keito Newm...

Associated Press

Trump mulls renaming Lake Ontario as ‘Lake America.’ Canadians balk at the idea

WINDSOR, Ontario (AP) — With his trade war with Canada intensifying, U.S. President Donald Trump floated the idea of renaming Lake Ontario to become “Lake America.” America’s northern neighbors quickly panned the idea. “He can blow out his hole as much as he wants to, but it’s never going to happen, because Canadians are strong,” […]

32 minutes ago

boeing whistleblower plane safety...

John Curley Show

‘Two Boeing models I would not fly’: Boeing whistleblower reveals planes subject to years of safety failures

Discover which Boeing models face safety failures, as whistleblower Merle Meyers shares insights on air travel risks highlighted in latest Netflix documentary.

48 minutes ago

Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry speaks during an event with SpaceX announcing a deal to build a new spac...

Associated Press

Elon Musk’s space company to build new rocket launching site in Louisiana

ABBEVILLE, La. (AP) — Elon Musk’s space company plans to spend $100 billion to build a new spaceport in Louisiana to launch rockets, state officials and the company announced Tuesday. Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry said the deal was a big win for the state and country, likening the impact of the new launch site to […]

53 minutes ago

Starbucks' fall menu...

Julia Dallas

Starbucks’ fall menu is back with new cider-chai drink, food, and classic Pumpkin Spice Latte

Summer isn't over yet, but Starbucks is already rolling out its fall menu, complete with a brand new drink, food item, and cake pop flavor.

56 minutes ago

dolly parton...

KRISTIN M. HALL, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Dolly Parton, music star, actor, and beloved figure who spanned generations has died at 80

Dolly Parton, the country music icon whose soaring vibrato vocals, poignant songwriting, and sparkling costumes, has died. She was 80 years old.

1 hour ago

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date