NATIONAL NEWS

Appeals court gives Trump gets another shot at erasing his hush money conviction

Nov 6, 2025, 7:49 AM

President Donald Trump speaks to the America Business Forum Miami, at the Kaseya Center, Wednesday,...

President Donald Trump speaks to the America Business Forum Miami, at the Kaseya Center, Wednesday, Nov. 5, 2025, in Miami. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)

NEW YORK (AP) — A federal appeals court on Thursday gave new life to President Donald Trump’s bid to erase his hush money conviction, ordering a lower court state court instead of moving it to federal court.

A three-judge panel in the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Trump’s request to move the New York case to federal court, where he can seek to have it thrown out on presidential immunity grounds.

But, the appeals court judges said, they “express no view” on how Hellerstein should rule.

Hellerstein, who was nominated by Democratic President Bill Clinton, twice denied Trump’s requests to move the case. The first time was after Trump’s March 2023 indictment; the second followed Trump’s May 2024 conviction and a subsequent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that presidents and former presidents cannot be prosecuted for official acts.

In the later ruling, at issue in Thursday’s decision, Hellerstein said Trump’s lawyers had failed to meet the high burden of proof for changing jurisdiction and that Trump’s conviction for falsifying business records involved his personal life, not official actions that the Supreme Court ruled are immune from prosecution.

Hellerstein’s ruling, which echoed his previous denial, “did not consider whether certain evidence admitted during the state court trial relates to immunized official acts or, if so, whether evidentiary immunity transformed” the hush money case into one that relates to official acts, the appeals court panel said.

The three judges said Hellerstein should closely review evidence that Trump claims relate to official acts.

If Hellerstein finds the prosecution relied on evidence of official acts, the judges said, he should weigh whether Trump can argue those actions were taken as part of his White House duties, whether Trump “diligently sought” to have the case moved to federal court and whether the case can even be moved to federal court now that Trump has been convicted and sentenced in state court.

Judges Susan L. Carney, Raymond J. Lohier Jr. and Myrna Pérez made their ruling after hearing arguments in June, when they spent more than an hour grilling Trump’s lawyer and the appellate chief for Manhattan district attorney’s office, which prosecuted the case and wants it to remain in state court.

Carney and Lohier were nominated to the court by Democratic President Barack Obama. Pérez was nominated by Democratic President Joe Biden.

Trump was convicted in May 2024 of 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to conceal a hush money payment to adult film actor Stormy Daniels, whose allegations of an affair with Trump threatened to upend his 2016 presidential campaign. Trump denies her claim, said he did nothing wrong and has asked a state appellate court to overturn the conviction.

It was the only one of the Republican’s four criminal cases to go to trial.

In trying to move the hush money case to federal court, Trump’s lawyers argued that federal officers, including former presidents, have the right to be tried in federal court for charges arising from “conduct performed while in office.” Part of the criminal case involved checks that Trump wrote while he was president.

Trump’s lawyer, Jeffrey Wall, argued that prosecutors rushed to trial instead of waiting for the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision. He also said they erred by showing jurors evidence that should not have been allowed under that ruling, such as former White House staffers describing how Trump reacted to news coverage of the hush money deal and tweets he sent while president in 2018.

“The district attorney holds the keys in his hand,” Wall told the three-judge panel in June. “He doesn’t have to introduce this evidence.”

In addition to reining in prosecutions of ex-presidents for official acts, the Supreme Court’s July 2024 ruling restricted prosecutors from pointing to official acts as evidence that a president’s unofficial actions were illegal.

Wall, a former acting U.S. solicitor general, called the president “a class of one,” telling the judges that “everything about this cries out for federal court.”

Steven Wu, the appellate chief for the district attorney’s office, countered that Trump was too late in seeking to move the case to federal court. Normally, such a request must be made within 30 days of an arraignment. Exceptions can be made if “good cause” is shown.

Hellerstein concluded that Trump hadn’t shown “good cause” to request a move to federal court as such a late stage. But the three-judge panel on Thursday said it “cannot be confident” that the judge “adequately considered issues” relevant to making that decision.

Wall, addressing the delay at oral arguments, said Trump’s team did not immediately seek to move the case to federal court because the defense was trying to resolve the matter by raising the immunity argument with the trial judge, Juan Merchan.

Merchan rejected Trump’s request to throw out the conviction on immunity grounds and sentenced him Jan. 10 to an unconditional discharge, leaving his conviction intact but sparing him any punishment.

National News

Dr. Alfiee Breland-Noble, who works to support the mental health of people of color, poses for a po...

Associated Press

How three leaders donated the $20 million Melinda French Gates gave them with no strings attached

Dr. Alfiee Breland-Noble says she was shocked when philanthropist Melinda French Gates picked her to receive $20 million to donate however she wanted. The psychologist, author and founder of The AAKOMA Project, a nonprofit supporting the mental health of young people of color, has long admired French Gates’ work, especially in the diversity of her […]

1 hour ago

Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin, speaks at a forum to address the evolving challeng...

Associated Press

Mullin heads to Congress as questions swirl over flight disruptions, football trip and immigration

WASHINGTON (AP) — Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin is set to appear Wednesday at a congressional hearing about threats facing the country at a time of looming questions over cyber infrastructure, the future of immigration enforcement and his decision to fly to the LSU-Texas college football game as travelers across the U.S. were still stuck […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Rep. Robert Garcia, D-Calif., the ranking member of the House Oversight Committee, speaks to...

Associated Press

House Democrat targets Trump family and top officials in early steps toward investigations

WASHINGTON (AP) — The top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee is laying the groundwork for long-promised investigations into the Trump administration that will launch with the new Congress in January. Rep. Robert Garcia of California, who is expected to lead the House Oversight Committee when Democrats take control, sent letters directing members of President […]

4 hours ago

FILE - Attendees gather at the OpenAI DevDay 2026 conference, Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026, in San Franc...

Associated Press

Senator vows AI hearings after watchdog gets platforms to plan terrorist attacks

WASHINGTON (AP) — The incoming chair of the Senate Homeland Security Committee is preparing hearings on AI after government watchdogs found the four most-used platforms — ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Grok — all created proposals for a terrorist attack in the U.S. when prompted by investigators. Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., who will helm the panel […]

4 hours ago

An aerial view shows vegetation growing on the Wallis Annenberg Wildlife Crossing over U.S. Highway...

Associated Press

Over a freeway near Los Angeles, animals can roam safely thanks to world’s largest wildlife crossing

AGOURA HILLS, Calif. (AP) — Touring the world’s largest wildlife crossing, Beth Pratt stepped carefully through freshly planted native vegetation and held up her hand for silence. “Hear that? We’re listening to birdsong right now, on top of one of the busiest freeways in the U.S.!” a beaming Pratt, one of the project’s leaders, said […]

5 hours ago

The Kaseya Center, home of the Miami Heat basketball team, features signage for the "Grand Theft Au...

Associated Press

Pro athletes clamor for ‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ release, but they insist their day jobs come first

LOS ANGELES (AP) — When “Grand Theft Auto VI” finally drops this week, professional athletes across the globe will immediately begin stealing cars, running from the cops and causing every manner of virtual mayhem under the Vice City sun. The love affair between pro athletes and video games has been strong for decades now, and […]

9 hours ago

Appeals court gives Trump gets another shot at erasing his hush money conviction