NATIONAL NEWS

NJ high court rules shaken baby syndrome testimony unreliable and inadmissible in child abuse cases

Nov 20, 2025, 2:57 PM

New Jersey’s highest court ruled Thursday that expert testimony about shaken baby syndrome is scientifically unreliable and inadmissible in two upcoming trials, a decision that comes as the long-held medical diagnoses have come under increased scrutiny.

The New Jersey Supreme Court determined that a diagnosis of shaken baby syndrome, which is also known as abusive head trauma, is not generally accepted within the “biomechanical community” and is therefore not “sufficiently reliable” for admission at the trials.

The 6-1 ruling deals with the trials of two men facing charges in separate cases, where the young victims showed symptoms that have come to be associated with shaken baby syndrome.

The justices, using an abbreviation for the syndrome, concluded in their lengthy decision that “there was no test supporting a finding that humans can produce the physical force necessary to cause the symptoms associated with SBS/AHT in a child.”

But Justice Rachel Wainer Apter, in a strongly worded dissent, said the other justices put more weight on the views of individual biomechanical engineers over the “consensus perspective of every major medical society in the world.”

That, she said, includes all the medical discipline involved in the diagnosis and treatment of shaken baby syndrome — pediatrics, child abuse pediatrics, neurology, neuroradiology, neurosurgery, radiology, ophthalmology and emergency medicine.

Wainer Apter also noted that every other U.S. state allows testimony in court on the syndrome and “every other court that has considered the question” has held such evidence as admissible.

“No case has ever concluded that evidence of SBS/AHT is unreliable,” she wrote. “And no case has ever found its reliability sufficiently questioned to preclude its admission at a civil or criminal trial.”

According to the Mayo Clinic, the syndrome is a result of forcefully shaking an infant or a toddler, which can damage or destroy a child’s brain cells and cause permanent brain damage or even death. Symptoms include bleeding around the brain, brain swelling and bleeding in the eyes.

Prosecutors and medical societies say the syndrome is the leading cause of fatal head injuries in children younger than 2 years of age, with more than 1,000 cases reported in the U.S. each year, according to the National Center on Shaken Baby Syndrome.

But defense lawyers and some in the medical and scientific communities argue that shaken baby diagnosis is flawed and has led to wrongful convictions, pointing to overturned convictions or dropped charges in California, Ohio, Massachusetts and Michigan.

The state attorney general’s office declined to comment Thursday, but the public defender’s office hailed the decision as a “landmark” moment, saying it reflected the importance of relying on “reliable, well-supported scientific evidence” in criminal cases.

“Where the science is uncertain, the stakes are simply too high to permit unsupported expert opinions to decide a person’s guilt or to justify separating children from their parents,” Cody Mason, a managing attorney in the public defender’s office, said in a statement.

National News

Associated Press

Northeastern Florida now under flood threats from storms that have devastated coastal communities

Heavy rains that left large swaths of Florida’s Atlantic coast under water and led to dozens of rescues moved further north on Friday as forecasters warned flooding threats could stretch into next week when a major river is expected to crest well above record levels. The National Weather Service posted flood warnings and watches stretching […]

2 hours ago

Melania Trump arrives at the world premiere of Amazon Prime Video's "Melania: The Series," Thursday...

Associated Press

Melania Trump gives a peek inside her marriage, motherhood and more in new series

NEW YORK (AP) — Melania Trump is back on screens on Friday with another behind-the-scenes look at her life before and after she became first lady, discussing her marriage to President Donald Trump, her relationship with son Barron and the healing power of a day at the spa. “Melania: The Series” is a two-part follow-up […]

4 hours ago

President Donald Trump arrives on Air Force One, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, at Joint Base Andrews, Md...

Associated Press

The Latest: Justice Department moves to have lawsuit dismissed in challenge to Alaska’s Senate race

The Trump administration has moved to effectively drop its lawsuit that sought to block the certification of Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race, ending a much-criticized gambit by the president to prevent one of his political rivals from taking office. Also, the White House named a new national cyber director Thursday after […]

4 hours ago

FILE - Stacey Abrams, Democratic candidate for Georgia governor, gives a concession speech in Atlan...

Associated Press

Stacey Abrams plans to refocus her Fair Fight voting rights group on threats to democracy

ATLANTA (AP) — After she lost the Georgia governor’s race in 2018, Stacey Abrams used her national profile and fundraising prowess to start an organization to confront problems with ballot access and voter disenfranchisement around the country. Eight years later, the Atlanta Democrat says the organization, Fair Fight, is winding down its voting-focused operations. Abrams […]

5 hours ago

Bart Collart poses for a photograph by the grave of his son, Marine Cpl. Spencer R. Collart, who di...

Associated Press

For families of the fallen, Trump’s proposed arch casts a shadow over Arlington National Cemetery

WASHINGTON (AP) — Cpl. Spencer Collart’s headstone faces the rising sun and the Lincoln Memorial to the east. The Marine Corps War Memorial is nearby. Soon, President Donald Trump’s gilded, towering arch could be, too. Collart’s silent stone speaks volumes in its simplicity of courage, sacrifice and loss. It stands among thousands of uniform headstones […]

5 hours ago

FILE - An FBI seal is displayed on a podium before a news conference at the field office in Portlan...

Associated Press

House Democrat investigates government agencies’ use of messaging apps to discuss official business

WASHINGTON (AP) — A top House Democrat is demanding that multiple government agencies preserve communications created on nongovernment messaging apps and investigate whether any records related to official business have been deleted. Rep. Jamie Raskin, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee and the panel’s incoming chairman, said in a series of nearly identical […]

6 hours ago

NJ high court rules shaken baby syndrome testimony unreliable and inadmissible in child abuse cases