NATIONAL NEWS

In Black pastor’s arrest, Alabama Supreme Court rules police can demand to see identification

Mar 17, 2026, 2:07 PM

FILE - This image made from bodycamera video released by the Childersburg (Ala.) Police Department ...

FILE - This image made from bodycamera video released by the Childersburg (Ala.) Police Department and provided by attorney Harry Daniels shows Michael Jennings, left, watering flowers in Childersburg, Ala., May 22, 2022. (Childersburg Police Department via AP, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(Childersburg Police Department via AP, File)

MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — Ruling in the case of a Black pastor who was arrested while watering his neighbor’s flowers, the Alabama Supreme Court said police can demand to see identification during a stop if they are dissatisfied with a person’s verbal answers.

Justices issued the 6-3 decision last week after a federal judge presiding over a lawsuit about Michael Jennings’ 2022 arrest asked the court to clarify whether officers can demand to see a person’s identification under the state’s “stop-and-identify” law. The minister was arrested when he declined to show Childersburg police identification.

Justice Will Sellers wrote that state law, “does not exclude from its purview a request for physical identification when a suspect provides an incomplete or unsatisfactory response to an officer’s demand to provide his or her name and address and an explanation of his or her action.”

In May 2022, officers questioned Jennings in his neighbor’s yard. Another neighbor had called 911 because she saw an unfamiliar car and a “young Black male” around the house. Officers who responded found Jennings watering flowers and asked what he was doing.

Jennings identified himself as “Pastor Jennings” and told officers that he lived across the street and was caring for his neighbor’s yard while they were vacationing. Officers asked to see his identification and Jennings refused, saying he hadn’t done anything wrong. The woman who called 911 also later identified Jennings as another neighbor.

Jennings was charged obstructing a government operation. The charge was later dismissed.

Jennings sued the city and the officers for false arrest. A federal judge dismissed the lawsuit, but the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the decision. U.S. District Judge R. David Proctor then asked the state Supreme Court to determine whether the state law prohibits an officer from demanding identification if the person gives an incomplete or unsatisfactory response to questions.

Matthew Cavedon, director of the Cato Institute’s Project on Criminal Justice, said the decision is a “significant expansion of government power over people.”

The Cato Institute and the American Civil Liberties Union had written an amicus brief in the case arguing the statute does not authorize any demands for physical identification. Cavedon said the case centers on what happens if a person gives an answer that the officer doesn’t find satisfactory.

“The significance now for Alabamians is if an officer’s not satisfied with whatever answer you give, I sure hope you’ve got your driver’s license or passport on you,” he said.

National News

A photo of the late Dolores Huerta is on display as part of a "Dia de los Muertos" altar display at...

Associated Press

Dolores Huerta, the late labor leader and civil rights icon, honored at memorial in California

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California officials paid tribute to Dolores Huerta, one of the nation’s most influential labor leaders, civil rights icons and feminist activists, at a memorial ceremony Monday at the state Capitol. They remembered her as a relentless advocate for a more just and fair world. Huerta co-founded a union that became the […]

14 minutes ago

FILE - Fiona, a Nile Hippopotamus, eats her specialty birthday cake to celebrate turning three-year...

Associated Press

Cincinnati Zoo says Fiona the hippo is undergoing care after swallowing object tossed into enclosure

CINCINNATI (AP) — The Cincinnati Zoo says its beloved hippo Fiona, who became a global celebrity after her premature birth nearly a decade ago, is undergoing veterinary care after swallowing an object tossed into her enclosure. Zoo veterinarians and staff are monitoring Fiona and working to help her pass the object, which was accidentally thrown […]

26 minutes ago

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at Semafor's Silicon Valley and The World conference in Menlo Park, Ca...

Associated Press

California sues OpenAI, seeking court-ordered changes after the Hugging Face hack

California’s attorney general filed a lawsuit against OpenAI on Monday in an effort to force the ChatGPT-maker to change its business practices over a July cybersecurity incident in which its artificial intelligence system hacked into another company on its own. In the lawsuit filed in San Francisco Superior Court, Attorney General Rob Bonta alleges that […]

28 minutes ago

Virginia state Sen. Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth, center, is led to a waiting vehicle as she leaves f...

Associated Press

Virginia state Sen. Louise Lucas pleads not guilty in marijuana-related case

State Sen. L. Louise Lucas, a powerful Virginia Democrat, pleaded not guilty Monday to federal racketeering, drug, money laundering and other charges. Federal prosecutors have accused Lucas of leading a criminal enterprise that they say acquired and sold large quantities of marijuana and laundered the proceeds. At a news conference and in charging documents, authorities […]

47 minutes ago

The American Heritage river cruise paddleboat is seen on its side after being struck by the Atlanti...

Associated Press

What we do and don’t know about a tanker with steering failure that hit a cruise boat in New Orleans

U.S. authorities are investigating what caused a tanker on the Mississippi River to crash into a smaller river cruise ship docked in New Orleans, sending dozens of people into the water. All 190 passengers and crew members on the cruise ship survived the collision Friday, and officials said no one suffered critical injuries. New Orleans […]

57 minutes ago

Aircraft are seen at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Arlington, Va., Saturday, Nov. 14...

Associated Press

Scrutiny of FAA intensifies after communications meltdown leads to nationwide grounding

The nationwide grounding of flights last week will only intensify scrutiny of the Federal Aviation Administration, which has been under a spotlight since a midair collision last year that killed dozens. The agency has been plagued for decades by underfunding, outdated technology and staffing shortages. Yet isolated technical problems went largely unnoticed by the flying […]

2 hours ago

In Black pastor’s arrest, Alabama Supreme Court rules police can demand to see identification