CRIME BLOTTER

Mercer Island teen vandals reportedly behind racist graffiti avoid conviction with diversion program

Mar 4, 2025, 9:43 AM | Updated: 1:51 pm

Two teenage boys who police say are responsible for vandalizing a Mercer Island middle school with ...

Two teenage boys who police say are responsible for vandalizing a Mercer Island middle school with anti-Semitic and offensive graffiti will now participate in a court-ordered "diversion program."(Photo: Mercer Island Police Dept.)

(Photo: Mercer Island Police Dept.)

Two teenage boys who police say are responsible for vandalizing a Mercer Island middle school with antisemitic and offensive graffiti will now participate in a court-ordered “diversion program.”

On New Year’s Day, the 16-year-old suspects allegedly trespassed on Islander Middle School’s property and defaced numerous windows and exterior walls with antiSemitic symbols and phrases, according to the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office (KCPAO).

More from MyNorthwest: Supreme Court will hear from US gun makers sued by Mexico for $10 billion

Mercer Island community outraged

Mercer Island community leaders were understandable outrage. They issued a joint public release on Jan. 2.

“This abhorrent act of hate is not only a violation of our community’s shared values, but an attack on the principles of inclusion, respect, and safety that we work every day to uphold in our community. As school superintendent, school principals, city manager and chief of police of Mercer Island, we condemn this hateful anti-Semitic and racist act,” the statement read.

Mercer Island Police say they identified the boys on Jan. 10.

One 16-year-old was arrested but later released to his parents, while the other lived out of state. The case was then referred to the KCPAO to determine whether or not charges would be filed. 

Instead of jail time, KCPAO said the juveniles were sentenced to a diversion program to promote healing in the community and potentially avoid a conviction.

“Under Washington state law, if charged through traditional prosecution these teens would be statutorily eligible for deferred dispositions—a sentencing alternative that allows juvenile offenders to avoid a conviction if they comply with court-ordered conditions. Given the nature of the offense, their lack of criminal history, and other factors, a traditional prosecution would not likely result in a lasting criminal record, nor would it provide an opportunity for meaningful dialogue between the offenders and the affected community,” KCPAO said in a recent press release.

Why a diversion program?

Prosecutors noted that after speaking with the local Jewish community, police and the school district, they helped find a mutually beneficial solution.

As part of the diversion program, the teens will meet with members of the affected community, including those from the Jewish community, to better understand the impact of their actions in a meaningful and educational way.

If the teens fail to meet requirements set by their juvenile probation counselor, the case will be reconsidered for potential new charges.

More from MyNorthwest: Sen. Patty Murray to skip Trump’s address to Congress Tuesday night

Crime Blotter

Pierce fentanyl death child...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Pierce Co. woman pleads guilty to lesser charge in fentanyl death of her child

A Puyallup woman accused in the fentanyl death of her 5-year-old in 2025 has pleaded guilty to a lesser charge.

6 hours ago

Silverdale airbnb bear-spray...

MyNorthwest Staff

Silverdale Airbnb owner accused of bear-spraying guests, threatening them with apparent firearm

A Silverdale Airbnb owner faces two assault charges after he allegedly bear-sprayed two guests and threatened them with what appeared to be a handgun.

18 hours ago

fall city teen...

James Lynch

Fall City teen accused of killing 5 family members pleads not guilty in adult court

Andrew Humiston, the 17-year-old accused of killing his parents and three siblings at their Fall City home in October 2024, appeared in adult court.

19 hours ago

seattle police (4)...

Luke Duecy

SPD caught renting cars to ICE division? Department says it was all part of a major drug bust and human trafficking

A social media post accusing Seattle police of renting cars for ICE agents has sparked a public response from the department and Wilson's office.

21 hours ago

seattle capitol hill hate crime hijab...

Jason Sutich

Seattle police seek hate crime suspect accused of pulling hijab off woman in Capitol Hill

Seattle Police Department detectives are seeking the public's help in identifying a hate-crime suspect who assaulted a woman wearing a hijab in Capitol Hill.

1 day ago

Kent collision multi-car fatal deadly Spanaway crash...

Luke Duecy

1 dead in 4-car crash in Kent; deputies arrest suspect in separate fatal Spanaway collision

One person is dead following a four-car crash in Kent on Monday afternoon. Kent police say the collision happened near the State Route 167 off-ramp.

1 day ago

Mercer Island teen vandals reportedly behind racist graffiti avoid conviction with diversion program