JOHN CURLEY

Seattle car tab rebate needs fine-tuning or it’s ‘not worth it’

May 13, 2015, 12:10 PM | Updated: 1:51 pm

The City of Seattle has the best intentions for providing low-income people with rebates on car-tab...

The City of Seattle has the best intentions for providing low-income people with rebates on car-tab fees, but the plan needs to be a little more thought out, KIRO Radio's Tom Tangney explains. (AP)

(AP)

The City of Seattle wants to lessen the pain of $60 car tab fees on low-income families by offering $20 rebates. Those rebates, however, could cost the city up to $17 in overhead, The Seattle Times reports.

The city has the best intentions, but the plan needs to be a little more thought out, KIRO Radio’s Tom Tangney said.

“If it really does cost $17 to save $20, even a good Liberal like myself, who believes in government, won’t feel that it is enough bang for your buck,” Tom said.

Related: Dave Ross – Best way to help the poor

The cost of providing a rebate should be between 10 to 15 percent of the total, Tom continued. A total of $2 for the $20 rebate is more reasonable.

“I like 10 percent,” KIRO Radio’s John Curley said. “It’s very similar to charity.”

If someone gives $1 to charity, most people would be OK with 90 cents going to that organization or cause, with the remainder going to costs.

But “if you find out only 15 cents go to charity, you probably wouldn’t want to give the money unless you want some sort of payback from Hillary Clinton,” Curley added.

The costs could be less than $17, or reduce over time.

“I’m willing to take the worst-case scenario and say yes, here’s a program the government needs to figure out, or it’s not worth it,” Tom said.

John Curley on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to tom and curleyTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 3pm for The John Curley Show.

John Curley

John Curley

income tax I-645...

John Curley Show

‘We have a very strong argument’: Citizen Action Defense Fund makes case against WA’s income tax ahead of hearing

Jackson Maynard argues against Washington's income tax ahead of the Feb. 5 lawsuit hearing, emphasizing key legal and economic implications.

9 hours ago

tacoma housing rent measure...

John Curley Show

‘Last place you want to go is government housing’: Curley warns about Tacoma’s direction after tenant measure vote

Tacoma voters backed a sweeping tenant rights measure on Election Night. John Curley said renters should be wary of government-owned housing.

9 hours ago

seattle RV parking rules...

John Curley Show

‘You’ll subsidize it. You’ll have more of it’: Curley questions Mayor Wilson’s RV safe lots after permit veto

Seattle's mayor and City Council are fighting over how to get RVs off city streets. John Curley thinks both sides are missing the bigger question.

11 hours ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘Even local government in WA is being polarized’: Former Burien mayor links Tacoma housing debate to party pressure

Former Burien Mayor Kevin Schilling explained how Tacoma's housing initiative reveals deepening polarization in Washington's local government discussions.

2 days ago

flock cameras everett renton...

John Curley Show

‘The police are basically renting access to data’: Cybersecurity expert warns about Flock cameras

John Curley likes Flock cameras. Producer Joe Wallace brought in someone he said could explain the risks better than he could.

5 days ago

Doctors Office gender...

John Curley Show

‘We’re supposed to be healers, not harmers’: Doctor says politics has taken over medical groups’ stance on gender care for minors

With Initiative 638 on the November ballot, Curley said he went looking for a better understanding of the medical side of the transgender debate.

5 days ago

Seattle car tab rebate needs fine-tuning or it’s ‘not worth it’