LIFESTYLE

Fan-favorite peanut butter dropped by Costco, angering shoppers

Nov 11, 2025, 12:09 PM

Costco peanut butter...

People walk to enter a Costco Wholesale store shortly after it opened. (Photo: Mario Tama, Getty Images)

(Photo: Mario Tama, Getty Images)

Some Costco shoppers are very disappointed after a consumer-favorite product has disappeared from store shelves and online inventory.

According to The Street, Kirkland’s Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter has gone missing in recent weeks. Online searches show a “no match found.”

The specific peanut butter has become a fan favorite over the last couple of years, with multiple posts dedicated to it on Costco’s Reddit page.

“This is what REAL peanut butter is like, not the processed garbage with added sugars and hydrogenated oils you are used to buying,” one user wrote.

“The best peanut butter on the planet,” another Costco shopper wrote on the thread. “I bought one of these no-stir mixers just for it. Straight into the fridge after mixing, and it’s perfection.”

On the recipe website All Recipes, Annie Campbell wrote that Costco removed “the only item [she] keeps [her] membership for.”

“I’m a full-fledged peanut butter fiend — I’ve tried nearly every brand out there — and while I could give a TED Talk on why this one tops them all, I’ll try to keep it brief. To start, the texture is silky-smooth. I store mine in the fridge (upside down), and it stays thick yet perfectly creamy and spreadable,” Campbell wrote for the outlet. “As it warms to room temperature, it softens into a luscious drizzle — ideal for topping pancakes or sliced apples — without ever separating into oil and solids.”

Costco has frequently discontinued and cycled through products on a temporary basis. The Street brought up another popular item, the Sweet Heat snack mix, which Costco had temporarily removed before bringing it back.

KIRO Newsradio has reached out to Costco for comment.

Lifestyle

A message board displays flights at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International airport as all flights...

Associated Press

(Not) up in the air: Travelers’ trepidations spike as Thanksgiving nears and tech hiccups abound

NEW YORK (AP) — At this point, it’s practically as much of a Thanksgiving tradition as turkey and stuffing — crowded airports, long lines, jam-packed flights, the ever-present worry about delays and cancellations and extra expenses. And for 2026’s busy holiday travel week, which effectively begins Friday, there’s another ingredient now: new concerns about the […]

6 hours ago

Noble Bear Coffee...

Frank Lenzi

Noble Bear Coffee opens in Purdy at former bikini barista location

Noble Bear Coffee, a family-friendly drive-thru coffee stand in Purdy, celebrated its grand opening Thursday at 13716 Purdy Dr. NW.

11 hours ago

Kirkland ethan stowell lime social...

Jason Sutich

Ethan Stowell opens Lime Social in Kirkland after launching Seattle steakhouse

Longtime Seattle restaurateur Ethan Stowell opened his second new Seattle-area restaurant on Tuesday since leaving Ethan Stowell Restaurants (ESR) last year.

13 hours ago

Seattle Space Needle Chihuly garden glass new CEO Drew Sheriff...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Space Needle and Chihuly Garden and Glass announce new CEO, Drew Sheriff

Seattle's Space Needle and Chihuly Garden and Glass, two popular tourism destinations have a new Chief Executive Officer, Drew Sheriff.

15 hours ago

Seattle christmas market...

Manda Factor

Mulled wine and mistletoe: Seattle Christmas Market brings holiday magic to Seattle Center

A European-style holiday village returns to Seattle Center, bringing outdoor shopping, warm drinks, and a new opportunity to keep celebrating after Christmas.

16 hours ago

ballard wine bar le pichet...

MyNorthwest Staff

Le Pichet owners plan new Ballard wine bar for early next year

The owners of Le Pichet, an intimate French bistro near Seattle's Pike Place Market, have announced plans to open a wine bar in Ballard early next year.

17 hours ago

Fan-favorite peanut butter dropped by Costco, angering shoppers