‘He’s not a human being,’ family says of shooter in Carnation murders
Mar 25, 2015, 1:19 PM | Updated: Mar 26, 2015, 10:39 am
Pam Mantle (center) has a hard time believing what happened to three generations of her family. (KIRO Radio/Libby Denkmann)
(KIRO Radio/Libby Denkmann)
Judy and Wayne Anderson were celebrating Christmas Eve in 2007 at their home in Carnation when their daughter, Michele Anderson, and her boyfriend, Joseph McEnroe, arrived and started a confrontation that ended in the shooting deaths of six family members.
The youngest victims were 5 and 3 years old. It took a jury only a day and a half to return a verdict convicting McEnroe on all six counts of first degree murder. He will now spend his life in prison and possibly face the death penalty, depending on the outcome of the next phase of the trial.
Pam Mantle is the mother of Erica Anderson and the grandmother of Olivia and Nathan, all killed by McEnroe and his girlfriend.
She still has a hard time believing what happened to three generations of her family.
“Could somebody really shoot my daughter six times?” asked Mantle. “Who could shoot a baby in diapers?”
Mantle it wasn’t easy to be in the court room almost every day of the two month trial.
“Really nauseating. He’s not a human being,” she said.
McEnroe’s defense team argued he was suffering from a personality disorder and could not resist his domineering girlfriend, Michele Anderson, when she decided to kill her family.
Erica Anderson’s father, Tony Mantle, denied this was a case of mental illness.
“I don’t buy it,” he said. “We had Joseph McEnroe in our home on numerous occasions. He was fully functioning.”
The jury will decide whether McEnroe deserves to be put to death for his crimes when the penalty phase of the trial begins Tuesday.
Pam Mantle is sure she knows how her daughter would feel. The last book they read together was by Ann Rule.
“Erica was very pro-death penalty,” she said. “I just think that the jury will make the best decision.”
Pam often thinks about what the six victims would be doing today, if McEnroe had not cut their lives far too short.
Wayne and Judy would be “traveling hopefully, in the RV they hoped to buy,” Mantle said. Her granddaughter, Olivia, would have turned 13 years old this month.
“She would have been a teenager. There would have been a lot of exciting stuff with that,” Mantle smiled.
Nathan would be 10 by now. His grandmother said he might have played baseball with his cousin, Jack.
“There’s too much gone,” Mantle said, shaking her head. “There’s too much missing.”
Prosecutors felt “tremendous relief,” when the verdict was read. But Prosecutor Scott O’Toole said there is still a lot of work to be done moving into the next phase. He and his team will call half a dozen witnesses to speak to the court for victim impact testimony. The defense will then present mitigation testimony.
If the death penalty is handed down, it could clash with the stand of Governor Jay Inslee, who has said he will not allow anyone to be put to death in Washington while he is in office.
“The law right now on the books is there is a death penalty in this state,” said O’Toole.
“The governor’s actions right now simply have an effect on his ability to influence the death penalty in this state. But it does not otherwise effect our decision whether to seek the death penalty. Or the jury’s decision whether to impose it.”
Prosecutor O’Toole expects Michele Anderson’s trial to begin in January 2016, almost a year from the date Joseph McEnroe’s trial started.
