MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Investigation finds Pierce County Sheriff Troyer violated department standards

Oct 26, 2021, 3:32 PM | Updated: 3:51 pm

troyer...

Sheriff Ed Troyer (File photo credit should read Andrew WINNER/AFP via Getty Images)

(File photo credit should read Andrew WINNER/AFP via Getty Images)

Pierce County Sheriff Ed Troyer has been found to have violated the department’s policies and standards in a confrontation with newspaper carrier Sedrick Altheimer, according to an independent investigation.

In said confrontation, Troyer claimed that Altheimer threatened to kill or harm him. A significant police presence was summoned in response.

The independent investigation was conducted by Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, commissioned by the Pierce County Council in April 2021.

It is separate from the criminal investigation conducted by the attorney general’s office, which charged Troyer with two misdemeanors: one count of false reporting, and one count of making a false or misleading statement to a public servant.

Pierce County Sheriff Ed Troyer says he’ll fight AG’s misdemeanor charges

The independent investigation was unable to substantiate that Troyer was threatened. It also found that “a reasonable person could conclude that Sheriff Troyer exhibited an improper bias in his confrontation with Mr. Altheimer.”

The specific policies of which Sheriff Troyer was found in violation largely relate to off duty conduct and police reporting without bias.

That policy forbids biased reporting in the interest of avoiding racial discrimination. While the report finds no explicit mention of race in what transpired between the two individuals, Troyer repeatedly referred to Altheimer as “homeless.”

“We find by a preponderance of the available evidence that Sheriff Troyer engaged in conduct that his Department expressly forbids — employing an economic bias to support his mistaken belief that Mr. Altheimer must be engaged in criminal activity,” the report reads.

The report deferred the issue of criminal law violation to the attorney general.

In terms of potential disciplinary recommendation, the report stated the following:

There are three significant parts to the disciplinary analysis we have been asked to address.

One … is that Sheriff Troyer gave two versions of important events extremely close in time — on the 911 call and to Officer Lawless — that are diametrically opposed and cannot both be true. Thus, we concluded he was either untruthful on the 911 call or he was untruthful to Officer Lawless who was investigating a potential crime.

Two, Sheriff Troyer exhibited bias in his decision-making. This not only violates PCSD policy, but it strikes at the very heart of fair and just policing. Finally, Sheriff Troyer’s 911 call created an all hands, highly emergent, and fluid series of events. The potential for harm to Mr. Altheimer, responding officers, and the general public was significant.

Being mindful that the range of discipline available to an elected sheriff when disciplining a deputy lies somewhere on a continuum between no discipline and termination from employment, we conclude Sheriff Troyer’s conduct, and the results of that conduct, lie at very far end of the “seriousness” scale of that continuum. Ironically, the appropriate level of discipline would reside with Sheriff Troyer, the very person whose judgment in these matters has been called into question.

In conclusion, the report deferred discipline to the court of law as well as future voters as “Sheriff Troyer was elected by the public and answers to them,” the report reads.

MyNorthwest News

Sheraton Grand Seattle Gingerbread Village November 19 open...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Gingerbread Village opens for holiday season at Seattle’s Sheraton Grand

The holiday spirit kicks off today in the lobby of Seattle's Sheraton Grand Hotel, featuring the Gingerbread Village.

50 minutes ago

City Lynnwood Traffic speed cameras school zones budget...

Jason Sloss, KIRO 7 News

City of Lynnwood considering running school speed cameras 24/7

The City of Lynnwood is considering running school zone speed cameras around the clock to ticket speeders and help close a budget deficit.

1 hour ago

Seattle Chinatown-International District Shooting Two wounded Seattle Police Department...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Police search for suspect after 2 shot in Chinatown-International District

Seattle police are reportedly searching for a suspect after two people were shot in the Chinatown-International District on Wednesday evening.

2 hours ago

Skagit County...

Chris Sullivan

‘Welcome to Skagit County’ sign sits miles inside Skagit County. Here’s why

Why is there a “Welcome to Skagit County” sign on a road already inside Skagit County? The answer has to do with where Mount Vernon ends.

3 hours ago

King County deputy stabbing shoreline...

Frank Lenzi

Man accused of stabbing King County deputy in Shoreline arrested in Texas

A man accused of stabbing a King County Sheriff's deputy in Shoreline last month has been arrested in El Paso, Texas.

13 hours ago

Follow @http://twitter.com/Mynorthwest...

MyNorthwest Staff

Dozens of people protest Turning Point USA event at UW

Dozens of people protested a Turning Point USA event at the University of Washington Wednesday night.

13 hours ago

Investigation finds Pierce County Sheriff Troyer violated department standards