MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Judge orders refund for ‘fundamentally flawed’ waterfront park LID tax

Mar 14, 2023, 1:59 PM | Updated: 5:33 pm

waterfront tax...

A new pedestrian walkway from Pike Place Market to the Waterfront. (Photo from waterfrontseattle.com)

(Photo from waterfrontseattle.com)

A King County Superior Court judge ordered the city of Seattle to refund a tax paid by some property owners in downtown Seattle after challenging the Local Improvement District (LID) used to fund the construction of a waterfront park.

The LID, a tax on nearby property owners for waterfront improvement and pays for what the city calls “special benefits” of having increased access and value now that the Alaska Way viaduct has been torn down. The tax was intended to raise $160 million for the park’s construction.

Homeowners worried about pricey Seattle waterfront LID

The ruling said only the plaintiff’s payments should be reimbursed, which would be approximately $16 million of the total $160 million the special assessment is expected to collect. Should the ruling stand, it’s expected other property owners will sue to get their assessments reimbursed.

In a ruling issued March 8, the judge found that the assessment method used by the city was “fundamentally flawed” and “arbitrary and capricious” and ordered a full refund of the tax.

The judge argued that the appraisers included in their evaluation of local property values the effects of the unfinished waterfront revitalization project, which violates the standard that the speculative value is “beyond the knowledge of reasonable certainty.” The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted these assessments, and the city did not properly adjust its valuations, the documents also stated.

The judge also found that the appraiser’s study itself contained several issues, including not meeting standards set by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) and did not properly measure the increase in property values.

“The Court finds that the LID assessment process as conducted by the city was fundamentally flawed. The process was infected from its inception by a rush to judgment by city staff who were apparently anxious to begin collecting revenue based on assessments of a LID improvements far in advance of the completion dates,” the documents read.

Much of the money already paid to the tax has been ordered by the judge to be refunded, and the property value assessments have been annulled.

The city said in a statement to KIRO Newsradio that they would be “reviewing the court’s written decision and evaluating the city’s options for appeal.”

MyNorthwest News

ballard wine bar le pichet...

MyNorthwest Staff

Le Pichet owners plan new Ballard wine bar for early next year

The owners of Le Pichet, an intimate French bistro near Seattle's Pike Place Market, have announced plans to open a wine bar in Ballard early next year.

40 minutes ago

Seattle downtown businesses vandalism...

Jake Chapman, KIRO 7 News

Seattle businesses grapple with repeated break-ins as city weighs more repair funding

The Seattle City Council is seeking an additional $1 million for a city grant program that helps small businesses recover from vandalism and break-ins.

1 hour ago

Kitsap County sheriff Kingston Poulsbo drive by shooting firearms...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Two Kingston men accused in alleged drive-by shooting, weapons case near Poulsbo

Two Kingston area men, ages 20 and 22, face charges for an alleged drive-by shooting and for illegally carrying two loaded firearms in a vehicle.

2 hours ago

Sheraton Grand Seattle Gingerbread Village November 19 open...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Gingerbread Village opens for holiday season at Seattle’s Sheraton Grand

The holiday spirit kicks off today in the lobby of Seattle's Sheraton Grand Hotel, featuring the Gingerbread Village.

4 hours ago

City Lynnwood Traffic speed cameras school zones budget...

Jason Sloss, KIRO 7 News

City of Lynnwood considering running school speed cameras 24/7

The City of Lynnwood is considering running school zone speed cameras around the clock to ticket speeders and help close a budget deficit.

5 hours ago

Seattle Chinatown-International District Shooting Two wounded Seattle Police Department...

Regan Gallo-Fenz

Police search for suspect after 2 shot in Chinatown-International District

Seattle police are reportedly searching for a suspect after two people were shot in the Chinatown-International District on Wednesday evening.

5 hours ago

Judge orders refund for ‘fundamentally flawed’ waterfront park LID tax