Marysville cop charged in shooting death of daughter
May 22, 2012, 10:28 AM | Updated: 3:35 pm
Snohomish County Prosecutors have charged a Marysville
police officer in the accidental shooting death of his
daughter.
Derek Carlile is charged with second-degree manslaughter.
Carlile and his wife stepped outside their van parked in
Stanwood to run an errand when they heard a pop. The off-
duty officer ran back to the van and saw his 7-year-old
daughter slumped over in her seat. He knew she had been
shot.
Carlile’s 3-year-old son had apparently climbed out of his
seat, grabbed his dad’s .38 revolver from the front of the
van, and shot his sister in the abdomen.
When deputies arrived to the scene, they found Carlile
performing CPR on his daughter. The rest of the family,
Carlile’s wife and three other children, was outside the
van.
Snohomish County Prosecutor Mark Roe tells 97.3 KIRO FM’s
Dori Monson Carlile created a “substantial risk of
death by leaving his loaded, unsecured handgun in clear
view and reach of four children.”
The prosecutor also said Carlile and his wife knew the 3-
year-old boy loved guns and was drawn to them.
“The conduct of the defendant was so far below a
reasonable standard of care in leaving an unloaded gun
without the safety on in a place where it could be easily
accessed by a kid who was very fascinated by guns,” said
Roe.
Carlile’s attorney David Allen told Monson he is
disappointed and while the officer accepts full
responsibility, he shouldn’t face criminal charges.
“Derek is a trained law enforcement professional with an
excellent record and while this was a tragic accident, it
was just that, an accident,” Allen said.
Listen to
David Allen-Attorney for Marysville cop charged in
daughter’s accidental shooting death
Allen accused the prosecutor of succumbing to public
pressure, citing a similar case in Pierce County where
prosecutors charged a mom and her boyfriend
with second-degree manslaughter after the death of a 3-
year-old who accidentally shot himself in a parked
car in Tacoma in March.
But Roe insisted he didn’t consider any other case and
treated the officer exactly as he would if he were “a
plumber.”
“I didn’t pay any attention to those other cases. We had
seasoned investigators from the homicide unit of the
sheriff’s office. We had a couple of hundred years of
experience of senior deputy prosecutors talking about this
case. I don’t even know or am familiar with the facts of
those other cases other than what I’ve read in the
newspaper, and they had no role in this decision,” Roe
said.
Carlile’s wife was not charged because prosecutors believe
she did not own the gun, nor did she put it in the van.
In fact, she asked Carlile what he was doing when he put
the gun in an open container because he normally wears it
or puts it in the locking side compartment.
Carlile failed to heed her warning.
“He’s very fascinated with guns and that’s why I’m beatin’
myself up because I left my damn gun, for forty seconds in
the center…it’s like what the hell,” Carlile said in a
police interview.
Arraignment will be June 5 at 3:00 p.m.
