MYNORTHWEST POLITICS

‘Trade means jobs:’ Trump tariffs on Canada and Mexico could hit close to home

Jan 31, 2025, 11:06 AM | Updated: 5:10 pm

tariffs...

A customer pumps gas at a gas station. (Photo: Nam Y. Huh, The Associated Press)

(Photo: Nam Y. Huh, The Associated Press)

The 25% tax that President Donald Trump plans to slap on imports from Canada and Mexico as soon as Saturday could drive up the price of everything from gasoline and pickup trucks, to Super Bowl party guacamole dip.

The tariffs would also invite retaliation. Doug Ford, the premier of Ontario, has already vowed to counterpunch by pulling American alcohol off store shelves in the Canadian province – no idle threat; Canada is the world’s No. 2 market for America’s distilled spirits (behind the 27-nation European Union).

Trump’s tariffs threaten to blow up the trade agreement he himself negotiated with America’s neighbors in his first term. His U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement – “the fairest, most balanced, and beneficial trade agreement we have ever signed into law,” Trump once declared — was supposed to bring predictability to North American trade, giving businesses the confidence to make investments.

But when it comes to the self-proclaimed “Tariff Man,” Trump and his passion for plastering taxes on foreign goods, nothing is predictable and nothing is ever really settled.

“Tariffs at those levels and at that scope would effectively destroy the agreement that Trump himself negotiated and always brags about,” Scott Lincicome, a trade analyst at the libertarian Cato Institute, said.

The president said the 25% levies are designed to pressure America’s two neighbors to do more to stop the flow of undocumented immigrants and fentanyl into the U.S.

More political news: New bill allows volunteer opportunities at schools for parents with criminal records

President of Washington Council on International Trade weighs in

However, President of the Washington Council on International Trade Lori Otto Punke told KIRO Newsradio Friday that for Washington “trade means jobs” and the tariffs are “potentially very consequential” as 40% of Washington jobs are tied to international trade.

“Mexico, Canada and China are some of our top trading partners, so there is a lot of concern about how these three countries might react to U.S. tariff policy and what we saw and what we’ve seen over the years, since the U.S. has had more aggressive tariffs in place than you know, in previous decades, is that really negatively impacts our ability to sell our goods and services abroad,” Otto Punke said.

She added that 95% of consumers are outside of the U.S. market.

“We’re really reliant on being able to sell Washington state’s goods and services outside of the U.S. and so that really helps benefit jobs here and what we know is that other countries will retaliate,” Otto Punke shared.

However, she is hopeful for a negotiated solution in the coming weeks but if not the consequences could be detrimental.

“I do have a lot of concerns that we’ll see a decrease in our ability to sell our goods and services abroad, which, again, will negatively impact our ability to sustain these jobs, which are really good, solid jobs here locally,” Otto Punke said.

Caught on the net: Washington lawmakers push to reduce penalties for online sting operations

Analysts believe tariffs are threat to USMCA

Michael Robinet of S&P Global Mobility and many other analysts suspect the tariff threat is also designed to get Canada and Mexico to go along with America’s demands for changes to the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) when it comes up for renewal next year.

Robinet, executive director of automotive consulting at S&P Global, said he doubts that Trump will go ahead with 25% across-the-board tariffs on Canadian and Mexican imports – what he calls a “shock-to-the-system” approach that would freeze the North American economy in a “Tariff Winter.” Instead, Robinet said, Trump might postpone or phase in the tariffs or initially exempt some industries to show Canada and Mexico how much worse things could get if he doesn’t get his way.

Trump pressured Mexico and Canada into agreeing to the USMCA five years ago, partly to narrow the United States’ big trade deficit – the gap between what the U.S. sells and what it buys.

It hasn’t worked out that way.

The U.S. deficit in the trade of goods of Mexico has widened from $106 billion in 2019 to $161 billion in 2023 (the last full year for which numbers are available). That is partly because Mexico has replaced China, locked in an ongoing trade war with the United States, as the source of many U.S. imports – furniture, textiles, shoes, laptops, computer servers.

The trade gap in goods with Canada has ballooned, too: From $31 billion in 2019 to $72 billion in 2023. The deficit largely reflects America’s imports of Canadian energy.

“The USMCA has not met the goals that Trump set forth for it. Our trade deficit with Canada and Mexico is bigger than it was, considerably,” said Lori Wallach, director of the Rethink Trade program at the American Economic Liberties Project and a longtime critic of America’s free trade pacts. “A lot of jobs have been offshored to Mexico since USMCA.”

When the USMCA comes up for renewal next year, the U.S. is expected to press for rules that would do more to encourage factories to produce in the U.S. And it could seek a crackdown on Chinese goods being sent through Mexico to the United States to evade tariffs that Trump and President Joe Biden imposed on Beijing.

The U.S. now does far more business – exports and imports alike – with both Canada and Mexico than it does with China. In 2023, U.S. trade of both goods and services with Canada and Mexico came to more than $1.8 trillion, compared with $643 billion with China. Because of USMCA – and the regional trade deal it replaced in 2020 – most products cross the region’s borders tariff-free.

The threatened 25% tariffs are causing heartburn in corporate boardrooms. If Trump goes ahead with his threat, tariffs would surge from $1.3 billion to $132 billion a year on Mexico’s imports to the United States and from $440 million to $107 billion on Canada’s, according to the tax and consulting firm PwC.

And no one knows if Trump will really pull the trigger or how long the tariffs would stay in place if he does.

“It’s really thrown industry into this turmoil of anxiety,” trade lawyer Chandri Navarro, senior counsel at Baker & McKenzie, said. “What industry likes is certainty. You’re making production decisions, supply chain decisions, purchasing decisions five years out.”

Trump views tariffs as a fix-it for most of what ails the economy. He said they raise money for cuts in income and corporate taxes, encourage companies to move production to the U.S. and offer useful leverage in pressuring other countries to make concessions on trade and other issues.

Trump administration officials also say critics of potential tariffs shouldn’t view them in isolation, arguing that their other policies, including lowering taxes and easing regulations, will strengthen the economy.

Impact of tariffs on consumers

Companies are scrambling to prepare. Some bought goods and shipped them to the United States ahead of time to beat the tariffs. Others are calculating how much of the cost they can pass along to their customers.

“Unfortunately, it’s going to impact a lot of consumers,” said Dave Evans, co-founder and CEO of Fictiv, a San Francisco company that helps clients manage their supply chains in plastics and metals. “We saw this in his first term. A tariff isn’t fully absorbed by the companies.”

Gee Scott slams Trump’s plane crash comments: ‘This is what 60% of the country voted for’

Canada and Mexico are bracing, too. Chrystia Freeland, the former finance minister who represented Canada in USMCA negotiations, has called for retaliation if Trump moves ahead with tariffs.

“Being smart means retaliating where it hurts,” said Freeland, who is running to replace Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

“Our counterpunch must be dollar-for-dollar — and it must be precisely and painfully targeted: Florida orange growers, Wisconsin dairy farmers, Michigan dishwasher manufacturers and much more.”

Mexico President Claudia Sheinbaum said Friday that Mexico has maintained a dialogue with Trump’s team since before he returned to the White House. She emphasized that the communication has been constant and continuing.

Trump has made clear that he has two main interests: immigration and fentanyl, Sheinbaum said. Her team is coordinating with the U.S. government on both of those issues, she said.

On trade, “We shouldn’t see ourselves as competitors,” she said, but rather partners. But if the U.S. imposes tariffs, Mexico is prepared and has been for months, Sheinbaum said.

“Now it is very important that the Mexican people know that we are always going to defend the dignity of our people, we are always going to defend the respect of our sovereignty and a dialogue between equals, as we have always said, without subordination,” Sheinbaum said.

Contributing: The Associated Press; Julia Dallas, MyNorthwest; Heather Bosch, KIRO Newsradio

MyNorthwest Politics

Photo: Woman scanning groceries at self-checkout line in Costco....

Matt Markovich

Scanning for safety: Clerks pushing WA bill to end chaos at the self-checkout line

As self-checkout stations continue to proliferate across grocery stores in Washington, concerns have sparked a need for new legislation.

4 hours ago

ranked choice voting washington...

Sam Campbell

WA Secretary of State warns Trump admin. may undermine election security

Our Secretary of State said the Trump administration could be undermining election security here in Washington.

6 hours ago

Photo: President Donald Trump speaks as Tulsi Gabbard is sworn in as the Director of National Intel...

Associated Press

Judge clears way for Trump’s plan to downsize federal workforce with deferred resignation program

A federal judge on Wednesday cleared the way for President Donald Trump’s plan to downsize the federal workforce with a deferred resignation program.

8 hours ago

tax democrat washington...

Matt Markovich

WA Democrats debating ‘tax the rich’ property plan as alternative to cap increase

Pedersen said lawmakers are exploring a plan to create a tax exemption for primary homes while placing a heavier burden on luxury properties and wealthy investors.

14 hours ago

minimum wage burien...

Brandon Thompson, KIRO 7 News

Burien Special Election: Measure to increase minimum wage leading in votes

As early results rolled on Tuesday night, a measure in Burien to create a minimum wage increase is leading by several hundred votes.

14 hours ago

deport illegal immigrants...

MyNorthwest Staff

Curley blasts latest Senate bill: ‘God forbid we deport a criminal’

Washington legislators have passed a bill in the Senate that could help block undocumented immigrants with criminal records from being deported.

17 hours ago

‘Trade means jobs:’ Trump tariffs on Canada and Mexico could hit close to home