NATIONAL NEWS

Appeals court appears divided in case over Venezuelan migrants deported to El Salvador prison

Sep 25, 2026, 11:22 AM

WASHINGTON (AP) — A panel of appeals court judges deported from the U.S. to a notorious prison in El Salvador last year.

A three-judge panel from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit didn’t indicate how soon they would rule after hearing arguments from attorneys for the government and the migrants who were flown to El Salvador without any notice or opportunity to challenge their removals from the U.S.

The Justice Department appealed after District Court Chief Judge James Boasberg in February ordered the Trump administration to make arrangements for some of the deported Venezuelan migrants to return to the U.S. at the government’s expense. Boasberg said the administration has essentially told him to “pound sand.”

Two panel members — Judges A. Raymond Randolph and Neomi Rao — appeared to be skeptical that the migrants have a right to return to the U.S. to challenge their March 2025 deportations.

A key question for the panel is whether the U.S. courts have jurisdiction over the migrants’ claims because the U.S. government maintained “constructive custody” of them even after they arrived in El Salvador. Rao questioned whether the migrants can meet that legal burden through their “habeas corpus” petitions.

“There needs to be some showing that the U.S. had that type of control — the control that they could produce a detainee on command — and I don’t see that evidence from petitioners,” said Rao, who was nominated by Republican President Donald Trump.

Circuit Judge Harry Edwards, who was nominated by Democratic President Jimmy Carter, said Boasberg cited plenty of evidence that the Trump administration “retained co-control” over the deported migrants and was “fully engaged and kept itself in a position of control throughout.”

Edwards also said that Supreme Court precedent holds that the plaintiffs have a right to pursue their due process claims.

“Judge Boasberg was merely attempting to facilitate the exercise of their rights. That’s all,” Edwards said.

Justice Department attorney Tiberius Davis argued that Boasberg didn’t have the jurisdiction to issue the order under appeal. Boasberg’s “freewheeling” decision would “open the floodgates to claims that the United States has constructive custody over prisons across the globe,” Davis said.

“This court is not supposed to second-guess sensitive matters of foreign affairs or undermine the United States’ ability to speak with one voice on the international stage. That is exactly what the district court is doing here,” Davis added.

American Civil Liberties Union attorney Lee Gelernt, who represents the deported migrants, said the Trump administration has conceded that it violated the plaintiffs’ constitutional rights but isn’t trying to rectify the problem.

“They concede we rushed them out, gave them no due process,” Gelernt said. “It can’t be the end of the game. That would be such an untenable rule for this court to adopt.”

Randolph noted that the plaintiffs already have been released from custody in El Salvador and taken to Venezuela. He suggested that they already have received the legal remedy to which they are entitled.

“We’re talking about habeas corpus. And (with) habeas corpus, the remedy is release from confinement. They’re already released,” said Randolph, who was nominated by Republican President George H. W. Bush.

“The remedy for this is not release in a country from which they fled. It’s to come back,” Gelernt said.

Randolph also questioned whether the plaintiffs’ underlying case is moot since the migrants are no longer in custody.

ACLU attorneys have been in contact with roughly two-thirds of 137 migrants since their release from the El Salvador mega-prison known as the Terrorism Confinement Center, or CECOT.

Boasberg, who was nominated by Democratic President Barack Obama, has repeatedly clashed with the administration since Trump invoked the 18th-century Alien Enemies Act to deport planeloads of Venezuelan migrants accused of being gang members.

Boasberg gave a verbal order for the aircraft to turn around. The administration denied violating it. Boasberg subsequently started a contempt investigation, leading to a separate appeal for which the full D.C. Circuit will hear arguments next Tuesday.

National News

FILE - Dr. Heidi Overton testifies at the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Comm...

Associated Press

White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans

WASHINGTON (AP) — The White House said Tuesday it has pulled the nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration amid growing indications she didn’t have the votes needed to win Senate confirmation. Overton, a physician and White House domestic policy adviser, has spent most of her professional career working directly […]

29 minutes ago

FILE - In this U.S. Navy provided photo, the USS Gerald R. Ford embarks on the first of its sea tri...

Associated Press

Trump faces GOP pushback to his order to use steam to launch jets from aircraft carriers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senators want to scuttle President Donald Trump’s order to retrofit new aircraft carriers with old steam catapults to launch fighter jets, a directive that would cost billions of taxpayer dollars and could even blunt the lethality of America’s most advanced warships. Sen. Roger Wicker, the Mississippi Republican who chairs the Senate Armed […]

1 hour ago

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at Semafor's Silicon Valley and The World conference in Menlo Park, Ca...

Associated Press

What tech CEOs are saying about the saga around Jensen Huang’s exit from Nvidia

MENLO PARK, Calif. (AP) — The saga surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has riveted Silicon Valley like few other stories, from reports of extramarital affairs to his resignation last week and short-lived comeback bid. Huang and Nvidia, a computer chip company that has been driving the AI boom, were top of mind this week […]

1 hour ago

Philadelphia 76ers forward LeBron James (23) signals a teammate against the Detroit Pistons in the ...

Associated Press

LeBron James sues makers of AI sports-betting app, saying they used his likeness and nickname

NBA superstar LeBron James sued the makers of an AI sports-betting app Tuesday, saying they have deliberately violated his publicity rights and trademarks by calling it “Bron” and using artificially generated images of him in their marketing. In a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in New York, James’ attorneys called it “a willful, bad-faith […]

2 hours ago

FILE - This image provided by the Justice Department, contained in the complaint supporting the arr...

Associated Press

Man gets more than 27 years in US prison for assassination plot that he said was steered from Iran

NEW YORK (AP) — A man who admitted trying to get a U.S. politician killed — and said Iran’s paramilitary Revolutionary Guard drove him to it — was sentenced Tuesday to nearly three decades in prison. Asif Merchant, a Pakistani businessman, had faced the possibility of life in prison for what the judge called an […]

2 hours ago

US measles mexico...

Mike Stobbe and Devi Shastri, The Associated Press

Sen. Patty Murray criticizes Trump, RFK Jr. as U.S. and Mexico lose measles elimination status

U.S. Senator Patty Murray released a statement directed at President Trump and RFK Jr. in response to the U.S. losing its measles-free status.

2 hours ago

Appeals court appears divided in case over Venezuelan migrants deported to El Salvador prison