NATIONAL NEWS

Defense: Ex-corrections guards in upstate New York are not guilty of murder in inmate’s beating

Oct 15, 2025, 10:40 AM | Updated: 1:48 pm

FILE - This image provided by the New York State Attorney General office shows body camera footage ...

FILE - This image provided by the New York State Attorney General office shows body camera footage of correction officers beating a handcuffed man, Robert Brooks, at the Marcy Correctional Facility in Oneida County, N.Y., Dec. 9, 2024. (New York State Attorney General office via AP, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(New York State Attorney General office via AP, File)

UTICA, N.Y. (AP) — Three former New York state corrections officers charged in the fatal beating of an inmate that was captured on bodycam video were trying to do their jobs in difficult circumstances and should not be judged for the violent acts of other guards involved in the beating, defense lawyers told a jury Wednesday.

Closing arguments began in a Utica court in the trial of Mathew Galliher, Nicholas Kieffer and David Kingsley, who face charges of murder and first-degree manslaughter in the death of Robert Brooks. The 43-year-old man was beaten by multiple guards upon his arrival at the Marcy Correctional Facility on Dec. 9. Five officers indicted in February have previously pleaded guilty to manslaughter in Brooks’ death under plea deals.

Defense lawyers told the jury their clients were not among the guards who struck Brooks and that they made quick decisions in a chaotic situation that night.

“Just because corrections officers wear the same uniform, doesn’t mean they’re part of the same gang. It doesn’t mean they have the same motivations, the same knowledge or the same intent,” said Kingsley’s attorney, Luke Nebush. “The acts of some, even those that look violent on video, do not make everyone in that room equally culpable.”

Kingsley lifted Brooks by the neck on the night he was beaten.

William Fitzpatrick, the special prosecutor, has said Brooks was beaten three separate times when he arrived at the prison, the last a fatal beating in the infirmary caught on the silent body-camera footage.

Brooks suffered a broken nose, a black eye and injuries to the spleen, liver and groin. Blood leaked into his lungs and stomach, officials said.

The publicly released footage of the brutal pummeling stirred outrage and calls for prison reform.

Galliher’s attorney showed portions of those bodycam videos Wednesday to demonstrate that Galliher showed up partway through the incidents started to bring leg shackles, as requested by a supervisor. Kevin Luibrand said Galliher orchestrated nothing and tried to do his job despite minimal training and lack of guidance from his sergeants.

“These were circumstances that Mathew Galliher did not create,” Luibrand said.

Luibrand blamed Brooks’ death on other officers who worked out plea deals.

Closing arguments were to continue Wednesday afternoon.

A grand jury indicted 10 guards on murder and lesser charges. In addition to the five men who pleaded guilty to either first- or second-degree manslaughter, another pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of attempted tampering with physical evidence.

Another corrections officer is scheduled to go on trial for second-degree manslaughter in January.

Three more employees have agreed to plead guilty to reduced charges and are cooperating with prosecutors, including two former guards who testified at the trial.

Kieffer and Galliher also were charged with second-degree gang assault. Kieffer faces a fourth charge of filing a false instrument.

The prison is about 180 miles (290 kilometers) northwest of New York City.

Fitzpatrick, the Onondaga County district attorney, also is prosecuting guards in the fatal beating of Messiah Nantwi on March 1 at a nearby prison, the Mid-State Correctional Facility. Ten guards were indicted in April, including two who are charged with murder, in Nantwi’s death.

National News

With the Washington Monument seen in the distance, a person golfs at the East Potomac Golf Links go...

Associated Press

Trump administration signals plan for seawall work at Washington golf course as legal fight drags on

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Interior Department has issued a notice that it intends to seek bids for a contractor to begin work on the seawall at a Washington park where President Donald Trump plans to redevelop a historic public golf course into a world-class venue. Those plans were put on hold by a judge over […]

24 minutes ago

FILE - Federal Reserve Board of Governors member Lisa Cook leaves the Supreme Court in Washington, ...

Associated Press

Federal Reserve’s Cook refuses to participate in White House hearing

WASHINGTON (AP) — Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook declined through her lawyers to appear next month before a Trump administration committee that is considering whether she should be fired, calling the process unfair and committed to a predetermined outcome. The refusal extends the wrangling between the White House and Cook’s lawyers regarding her appearance before […]

36 minutes ago

FILE -Russian President Vladimir Putin, 2nd right, speaks with workers as he inspects the road sect...

Associated Press

The Kerch Bridge is crucial to Russia’s war effort and for asserting Moscow’s control of Crimea

There is perhaps no more potent symbol of Moscow’s illegal annexation of Crimea than the bridge connecting the peninsula with Russia over the Kerch Strait — and it has come under repeated Ukrainian attacks since the nearly 5-year-old war began. The Kerch Bridge is a key artery for military and civilian supplies to Crimea, which […]

2 hours ago

Attendees gather for a talking circle at the late Gloria Steinem’s brownstone, Tuesday, Nov. 10, ...

Associated Press

Gloria Steinem’s famed talking circles are still going strong. This one had a twist: Men only

NEW YORK (AP) — For more than half a century, Gloria Steinem welcomed guests into her inviting, art-filled Manhattan living room, gathering women from all walks of life to discuss issues of vital importance in health, education, business, politics and beyond. It was her long-held dream that these “talking circles” continue after she was gone […]

2 hours ago

FILE - U.S. Catholic bishops are seated at the Basilica of the National Shrine of Mary, Queen of th...

Associated Press

US Catholic bishops meet after Democrats’ big wins help reshape immigration and abortion debates

U.S. Catholic bishops are holding their annual fall meeting in Baltimore this week. The gathering comes just after Democrats’ sweeping midterm victories reset the political dynamics around some of the bishops’ priorities, including immigration, abortion and artificial intelligence. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops is now facing a divided government as it seeks to influence […]

4 hours ago

A person walks up the stairs outside Nvidia HQ in Santa Clara, Calif., on Thursday, Nov. 12, 2026. ...

Associated Press

Nvidia establishes committee to oversee national security after abrupt departure of CEO Jensen Huang

Nvidia is creating a new board committee to oversee national security and global trade compliance following revelations that former CEO Jensen Huang had an extramarital affair with an alleged spy for China. Nvidia’s National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee will be responsible for oversight of national security policies and compliance with export controls, the […]

4 hours ago

Defense: Ex-corrections guards in upstate New York are not guilty of murder in inmate’s beating