NATIONAL NEWS

Judge accuses the Trump administration of ‘manufacturing’ chaos in migrant deportation case

May 27, 2025, 9:27 AM | Updated: 2:44 pm

Deputy director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Madison Sheahan, flanked by Acting dire...

Deputy director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Madison Sheahan, flanked by Acting director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Todd Lyons, speaks during a news conference at ICE Headquarters, in Washington, Wednesday, May 21, 2025. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge suggested the Trump administration was “manufacturing” chaos and said he hoped that “reason can get the better of rhetoric” in a scathing order in a case about government efforts to deport a handful of migrants from various countries to South Sudan.

In the order published Monday evening, Judge Brian Murphy wrote that he had given the Trump administration “remarkable flexibility with minimal oversight” in the case and emphasized the numerous times he attempted to work with the government.

“From the course of conduct, it is hard to come to any conclusion other than that Defendants invite a lack of clarity as a means of evasion,” the Boston-based Murphy wrote in the 17-page order.

Murphy oversees a case in which immigration advocates are attempting to prevent the Trump administration from sending migrants they’re trying to deport from the U.S. to countries that they’re not from without giving them a meaningful chance to protest their removal.

The judge said the men couldn’t advocate for themselves

In a hearing last week called to address reports that eight immigrants had been sent to South Sudan, Murphy said the men hadn’t been able to argue that the deportation could put them in danger.

But instead of ordering the government to return the men to the U.S. for hearings — as the plaintiffs wanted — he gave the government the option of holding the hearings in Djibouti where the plane had flown on its way to South Sudan as long as the men remained in U.S. government custody. Days later, the Trump administration filed another motion saying that Murphy was requiring them to hold “dangerous criminals in a sensitive location.”

But in his order Monday he emphasized repeatedly that it was the government’s “own suggestion” that they be allowed to process the men’s claims while they were still abroad.

“It turns out that having immigration proceedings on another continent is harder and more logistically cumbersome than Defendants anticipated,” Murphy wrote.

The government has argued that the men had a history with the immigration system, giving them prior opportunities to express a fear of being deported to a country outside their homeland. And they’ve said that the men’s home — Cuba, Laos, Mexico, Myanmar, Vietnam and South Sudan — would not take them back.

The administration has also repeatedly emphasized the men’s criminal histories in the U.S. and portrayed them as national security threats.

The administration is relying on third countries

The Trump administration has increasingly relied on third countries to take immigrants who cannot be sent to their home countries for various reasons. Some countries simply refuse to take back their citizens being deported while others take back some but not all of their citizens. And some cannot be sent to their home countries because of concerns they’ll be tortured or harmed.

Historically that has meant that immigration enforcement officials have had to release people into the U.S. that it wants to deport but can’t.

But the Trump administration has leaned on other countries to take them. In the Western Hemisphere, El Salvador, Costa Rica and Panama have all agreed to take some people being removed from the U.S., with El Salvador being the most controversial example because it is holding people deported from the U.S. in a notorious prison.

The Trump administration has said it’s exploring other third countries for deportations.

Murphy said in his order that the eight men were initially told May 19 they’d be going to South Africa and then later that same day were told they were going to South Sudan. He noted that the U.S. government “has issued stark warnings regarding South Sudan.”

He said the men had fewer than 16 hours between being told they were going to be removed and going to the airport “most of which were non-waking hours” and “limited, if any” ability to talk to family or a lawyer. “Given the totality of the circumstances, it is hard to take seriously the idea that Defendants intended these individuals to have any real opportunity to make a valid claim,” the judge wrote.

National News

FILE - In this U.S. Navy provided photo, the USS Gerald R. Ford embarks on the first of its sea tri...

Associated Press

Trump faces GOP pushback to his order to use steam to launch jets from aircraft carriers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senators want to scuttle President Donald Trump’s order to retrofit new aircraft carriers with old steam catapults to launch fighter jets, a directive that would cost billions of taxpayer dollars and could even blunt the lethality of America’s most advanced warships. Sen. Roger Wicker, the Mississippi Republican who chairs the Senate Armed […]

25 minutes ago

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at Semafor's Silicon Valley and The World conference in Menlo Park, Ca...

Associated Press

What tech CEOs are saying about the saga around Jensen Huang’s exit from Nvidia

MENLO PARK, Calif. (AP) — The saga surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has riveted Silicon Valley like few other stories, from reports of extramarital affairs to his resignation last week and short-lived comeback bid. Huang and Nvidia, a computer chip company that has been driving the AI boom, were top of mind this week […]

29 minutes ago

Philadelphia 76ers forward LeBron James (23) signals a teammate against the Detroit Pistons in the ...

Associated Press

LeBron James sues makers of AI sports-betting app, saying they used his likeness and nickname

NBA superstar LeBron James sued the makers of an AI sports-betting app Tuesday, saying they have deliberately violated his publicity rights and trademarks by calling it “Bron” and using artificially generated images of him in their marketing. In a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in New York, James’ attorneys called it “a willful, bad-faith […]

1 hour ago

FILE - This image provided by the Justice Department, contained in the complaint supporting the arr...

Associated Press

Man gets more than 27 years in US prison for assassination plot that he said was steered from Iran

NEW YORK (AP) — A man who admitted trying to get a U.S. politician killed — and said Iran’s paramilitary Revolutionary Guard drove him to it — was sentenced Tuesday to nearly three decades in prison. Asif Merchant, a Pakistani businessman, had faced the possibility of life in prison for what the judge called an […]

2 hours ago

US measles mexico...

Mike Stobbe and Devi Shastri, The Associated Press

Sen. Patty Murray criticizes Trump, RFK Jr. as U.S. and Mexico lose measles elimination status

U.S. Senator Patty Murray released a statement directed at President Trump and RFK Jr. in response to the U.S. losing its measles-free status.

2 hours ago

Planes are parked at Harry Reid International Airport during a nationwide ground stop, Friday, Nov....

Associated Press

Trump faces criticism as allies press the White House for answers on tech problems

President Donald Trump faced a groundswell of criticism Tuesday as friends and foes alike said the White House must answer for a cascade of service outages that snarled travel, cut off work, limited bank access and disrupted classified communications. Even staunch Trump allies accused the administration of lying to Americans or hiding information about the […]

2 hours ago

Judge accuses the Trump administration of ‘manufacturing’ chaos in migrant deportation case