NATIONAL NEWS

Justice Department defends Trump’s post as it urges judge to reject Comey’s effort to dismiss case

Nov 3, 2025, 3:11 PM

FILE - Former FBI director James Comey speaks during a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on Cap...

FILE - Former FBI director James Comey speaks during a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on Capitol Hill, in Washington, June 8, 2017. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Andrew Harnik, File)

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department urged a federal judge Monday to reject James Comey’s claim that his prosecution amounts to political retribution, arguing the former FBI director has failed to show that he’s being targeted as punishment for his criticism of the Republican president.

Prosecutors defended President Donald Trump’s September social media post demanding that action be taken in the Comey investigation, contending it reflects “legitimate prosecutorial motive” and is no basis to dismiss the indictment accusing Comey of lying to Congress in 2020.

The filing underscores how Trump’s comments have put the Justice Department in a difficult position as Comey and other defendants seize on the president’s remarks in efforts to have their cases dismissed ahead of trial. Comey’s lawyers told the judge last month that the charges must be thrown out because they were brought out of “personal spite” at the direction of the president. A lawyer for New York Attorney General Letitia James, another Trump foe who’s been charged in a mortgage fraud investigation, has signaled that he will make a similar argument.

The Justice Department acknowledged that Trump’s social media posts reflect the president’s view that Comey “committed crimes that should be met with prosecution” and “may even suggest that the President disfavors the defendant.” But, prosecutors argued, there is ”not direct evidence of a vindictive motive.”

“The defendant spins a tale that requires leaps of logic and a big dose of cynicism, then he calls the President’s post a direct admission,” prosecutors wrote. “There is no direct admission of discriminatory purpose. To the contrary, the only direct admission from the President is that DOJ officials decided whether to prosecute, not him.”

The dispute concerns arguably the most closely watched of several challenges Comey has brought over the indictment, with Comey’s attorneys citing not only Trump’s public demands for prosecutions of his perceived enemies but also his longtime disdain for the former FBI director, whom he fired during his first term amid the Russia election interference investigation.

Patrick Fitzgerald, the former U.S. attorney in Chicago and a longtime Comey friend, has argued that Trump’s social media post calling on Attorney General Pam Bondi to prosecute Comey and other longtime foes “constitutes a direct admission of discriminatory purpose to single out a perceived political enemy.”

The defense is separately challenging the appointment of the White House aide who was brought in as U.S. attorney after the head of the elite office handling the investigation was pushed out by the Trump administration.

The indictment came days after Trump installed Lindsey Halligan, a White House aide who had been one of Trump’s personal lawyers but had no prior experience as a federal prosecutor, as the U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia to replace Erik Siebert. Trump announced his support for Halligan one day after Siebert resigned as U.S. attorney amid administration pressure to charge Comey and James.

Comey’s lawyers last week asked to review transcripts and audio recordings of grand jury proceedings in the case, saying factual and legal errors may have been presented to the grand jury that returned the indictment, which could warrant the charges being thrown out.

The case accuses Comey of lying to the Senate Judiciary Committee on Sept. 30, 2020, in response to questions about whether he had authorized FBI leaks to members of the news media.

The government’s filing lays out a litany of messages between Comey and Daniel Richman, a close friend and Columbia University law professor, meant to show that Richman engaged with reporters on Comey’s behalf and communicated the then-FBI director’s perspective on politically fraught issues such as the bureau’s investigation during the 2016 presidential election into Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server as Secretary of State.

The filing notes that after Comey was fired, he asked Richman — who had also served as an FBI special government employee — to share with a reporter the contents of a memorandum he had written documenting a one-on-one conversation Comey had with Trump.

Prosecutors, pointing to the interactions with Richman, say Comey lied to the Senate panel about whether he had authorized disclosures about those investigations to reporters.

But Comey’s lawyers say the case must be dismissed because the questions Comey responded to, from Sen. Ted Cruz, were so vague and ambiguous that it was impossible for Comey to have had the necessary intent to lie.

They note, for instance, that the windup to Cruz’s questions about whether Comey had given the green light for news media disclosures did not mention Richman but were instead about another individual, former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe.

“In doing so, Senator Cruz never indicated that he wanted Mr. Comey to address the statements or activities of any person except for Mr. McCabe,” Comey’s lawyers said.

National News

Associated Press

3 people shot, including 2 public safety officers, at New York City apartment complex

NEW YORK (AP) — Three people, including two public safety officers, were shot Monday at a New York City apartment complex, police said. Their injuries are not believed to be life-threatening. The suspected gunman remained barricaded after the shooting at the massive Co-op City complex in the Bronx, police said. Authorities advised people to avoid […]

15 minutes ago

FILE - Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick speaks at a campaign rally, Oct. 13, 2026, in Wasilla, Ala...

Associated Press

Trump administration moves to block China from indirect access to American AI technology

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration on Monday issued new rules to restrict remote access to advanced U.S. computing chips and servers, marking the latest step to limit China’s abilities to use U.S. chips to train their best artificial intelligence models. The rule also was issued days after Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang resigned as CEO […]

38 minutes ago

Federal Reserve Board Chairman Kevin Warsh speaks during a news conference at the Federal Reserve, ...

Associated Press

Warsh grapples with AI’s potential economic impact, steers clear of its inflation risk

WASHINGTON (AP) — Artificial intelligence could accelerate innovation and usher in an era of faster economic growth, Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh said Monday in remarks that underscored his generally optimistic outlook on the new technology, a view at odds with many of his colleagues. At the same time, Warsh acknowledged that the development of […]

46 minutes ago

Associated Press

Person of interest taken into custody for questioning after bomb found at Illinois ethanol plant

A person of interest was taken into custody for questioning Monday morning related to a bomb located at an ethanol plant in central Illinois, Peoria police said. The person was taken into custody Monday morning at the BioUrja Renewables facility in Peoria, the same place where an explosive device was found on Friday, Peoria police […]

2 hours ago

FILE - The Supreme Court is seen at day's end in Washington, Oct. 1, 2026. (AP Photo/J. Scott Apple...

Associated Press

Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to Maryland ‘sensitive places’ gun law

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court declined Monday to consider a challenge to a Maryland law restricting where people can carry guns. The law prohibits carrying concealed weapons into schools, mass transit, bars and other areas deemed sensitive places. The high court declined the case without comment. But Justice Clarence Thomas wrote to say he’s […]

2 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before departing on Marine One from the South Lawn of ...

Associated Press

Third American aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war

WASHINGTON (AP) — The USS Theodore Roosevelt has arrived in the Middle East, once again bringing the total number of U.S. aircraft carriers in the Middle East to three — an unusually high number. A U.S. official, who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive military operations, on Monday confirmed the carrier’s arrival in […]

2 hours ago

Justice Department defends Trump’s post as it urges judge to reject Comey’s effort to dismiss case