NATIONAL NEWS

North Carolina court says it’s OK to swap jurors while they are deliberating

May 23, 2025, 12:05 PM

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — North Carolina’s highest court on Friday left intact a murder conviction that a lower appeals court had thrown out on the grounds that a jury shake-up during deliberations violated the defendant’s rights and required a new trial.

By a 5-2 decision, the state Supreme Court reversed last year’s decision of a state Court of Appeals panel that had sided with Eric Ramond Chambers, who has been serving a sentence of life in prison without parole.

The state constitution says no one can be convicted of a crime except by “the unanimous verdict of a jury in open court” that state justices have declared in the past repeatedly must be composed of 12 people.

A 2021 state law says an alternate juror can be substituted for one of the 12 after deliberations begin as long as the judge instructs the amended jury to begin deliberations anew. The judge at Chambers’ 2022 trial did just that when an alternate juror joined deliberations because an original juror couldn’t continue the next day due to a medical appointment.

The original 12 had deliberated for less than 30 minutes the day before. Chambers, who was representing himself in the trial, was not in the courtroom when the substitution occurred. By midday the reconstituted jury had reached a verdict, and Chambers was convicted of first-degree murder and a serious assault charge for the 2018 shooting in a Raleigh motel room.

Chambers petitioned the Court of Appeals, which later ruled that his right to a “properly constituted jury” had been violated and the 2021 law couldn’t supersede the state constitution because 13 people had reached the verdict. State attorneys then appealed.

Writing for Friday’s majority, Chief Justice Paul Newby said the 2021 law doesn’t violate Chamber’s right because it provides “critical safeguards that ensure that the twelve-juror threshold remains sacrosanct.”

Newby wrote the law says no more than 12 jurors can participate in the jury’s deliberations and that a judge’s instruction to begin deliberations anew means “any discussion in which the excused juror participated is disregarded and entirely new deliberations are commenced by the newly-constituted twelve.”

The four other justices who are registered Republicans joined Newby in his opinion.

In a dissenting opinion to retain the new trial, Associate Justice Allison Riggs wrote the 2021 law is an unconstitutional departure from the concept of 12-member juries and “endangers the impartiality and unanimity of the jury.”

No matter what directions a trial judge gives to jurors to begin deliberations anew, Riggs added, “we must assume by law that the original juror’s mere presence impacted the verdict.”

Associate Justice Anita Earls — who with Riggs are the court’s two registered Democrats — also dissented.

National News

Costco recall (1)...

MyNorthwest Staff

Costco recalls popular holiday item in 12 states

Costco is recalling a widely used topping ahead of the holiday rush.

25 minutes ago

FILE - Dr. Heidi Overton testifies at the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Comm...

Associated Press

White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans

WASHINGTON (AP) — The White House said Tuesday it has pulled the nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration amid growing indications she didn’t have the votes needed to win Senate confirmation. Overton, a physician and White House domestic policy adviser, has spent most of her professional career working directly […]

1 hour ago

FILE - In this U.S. Navy provided photo, the USS Gerald R. Ford embarks on the first of its sea tri...

Associated Press

Trump faces GOP pushback to his order to use steam to launch jets from aircraft carriers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senators want to scuttle President Donald Trump’s order to retrofit new aircraft carriers with old steam catapults to launch fighter jets, a directive that would cost billions of taxpayer dollars and could even blunt the lethality of America’s most advanced warships. Sen. Roger Wicker, the Mississippi Republican who chairs the Senate Armed […]

2 hours ago

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at Semafor's Silicon Valley and The World conference in Menlo Park, Ca...

Associated Press

What tech CEOs are saying about the saga around Jensen Huang’s exit from Nvidia

MENLO PARK, Calif. (AP) — The saga surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has riveted Silicon Valley like few other stories, from reports of extramarital affairs to his resignation last week and short-lived comeback bid. Huang and Nvidia, a computer chip company that has been driving the AI boom, were top of mind this week […]

2 hours ago

Philadelphia 76ers forward LeBron James (23) signals a teammate against the Detroit Pistons in the ...

Associated Press

LeBron James sues makers of AI sports-betting app, saying they used his likeness and nickname

NBA superstar LeBron James sued the makers of an AI sports-betting app Tuesday, saying they have deliberately violated his publicity rights and trademarks by calling it “Bron” and using artificially generated images of him in their marketing. In a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in New York, James’ attorneys called it “a willful, bad-faith […]

3 hours ago

FILE - This image provided by the Justice Department, contained in the complaint supporting the arr...

Associated Press

Man gets more than 27 years in US prison for assassination plot that he said was steered from Iran

NEW YORK (AP) — A man who admitted trying to get a U.S. politician killed — and said Iran’s paramilitary Revolutionary Guard drove him to it — was sentenced Tuesday to nearly three decades in prison. Asif Merchant, a Pakistani businessman, had faced the possibility of life in prison for what the judge called an […]

3 hours ago

North Carolina court says it’s OK to swap jurors while they are deliberating