NATIONAL NEWS

North Carolina Supreme Court says bar owners’ COVID-19 lawsuits can continue

Aug 22, 2025, 1:40 PM

FILE - Health Director Lillian B. Koontz leads North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper on a tour of the COVI...

FILE - Health Director Lillian B. Koontz leads North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper on a tour of the COVID-19 vaccine clinic at the Davidson County Health Department in Lexington, N.C., June 17, 2021. (Woody Marshall/News & Record via AP, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(Woody Marshall/News & Record via AP, File)

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — The North Carolina Supreme Court issued favorable rulings Friday for bars and their operators in litigation seeking monetary compensation from the state for COVID-19 restrictions first issued by then-Gov. Roy Cooper that shuttered their doors and, in their view, treated them unfairly compared to the way restaurants were regulated.

The majority decisions by the justices mean a pair of lawsuits — one filed by several North Carolina bars and their operators and the second by the North Carolina Bar and Tavern Association and other private bars — remain alive, and future court orders directing the state pay them financial damages are possible.

As a way to ease the spread of coronavirus, Cooper — a Democrat who left office last December and is now running for U.S. Senate — issued a series of executive orders that closed bars starting in March 2020. By that summer, bars still had to remain closed, but restaurants and breweries could serve alcohol during certain hours. Later in 2020, bars could serve alcoholic drinks in outdoor seating, with time limits later added, but the plaintiffs said it was unprofitable to operate. All temporary restrictions on bars were lifted in May 2021.

Lawyers defending Cooper have said the orders in the ninth-largest state were based on the most current scientific studies and public health data available at a time when thousands were ill and dying and vaccines weren’t widely available.

On Friday, the court’s five Republican justices in one lawsuit agreed it could continue to trial, rejecting arguments from state attorneys that the litigation must be halted based on a legal doctrine that exempts state government from most lawsuits. That decision largely upheld a Court of Appeals decision from two years ago that had affirmed a trial judge’s order to allow the action filed by Tiffany Howell, seven other individuals and nine businesses to be heard.

“We acknowledge that the COVID-19 pandemic was a chaotic period of time,” Chief Justice Paul Newby wrote in the prevailing opinion. “It is important to remember, however, that the Governor was not the only person facing uncertainty. Small business owners across the state dutifully shuttered their doors and scaled back operations without knowing exactly when they could open or operate fully again.”

A broader group of plaintiffs — the North Carolina Bar and Tavern Association and private bars — that sued separately but made similar claims received a favorable ruling last year from a Court of Appeals panel that reversed a trial judge’s decision to dismiss the lawsuit.

Friday, the same five justices ruled that the Court of Appeals shouldn’t have allowed the association to sue based on claims its members’ constitutional rights for equal treatment were violated.

But the plaintiffs can return to a trial judge now and present evidence on the claim that their right under the state constitution to earn a living was violated, Associate Justice Phil Berger Jr. wrote in the majority opinion. A trial judge had previously dismissed the case.

The association and the private bars “sufficiently alleged unconstitutional interference, and thus have a right to seek discovery to prove those allegations are true,” Berger wrote.

The Supreme Court’s two Democratic justices opposed decisions made by the majority in both cases and said the lawsuits should be dismissed. Associate Justice Allison Riggs wrote that the Bar and Tavern Association failed to signal it had evidence of a more reasonable plan to contain the virus’ impact than what Cooper chose.

Writing the dissent in the Howell case, Associate Justice Anita Earls said the majority “grants itself a roving license to second-guess policy choices, reweigh trade-offs, and displace decisions appropriately made by the political branches.”

The state Attorney General’s Office, which represented Cooper in both cases, said Friday it was reviewing the decisions. Through a spokesperson, Cooper’s Senate campaign declined to comment.

The Bar and Tavern Association called the decision in its case a “major victory” because the lawsuit can proceed on so-called “fruits of their own labor” claims in the state constitution. ”From the beginning, we never asked for special treatment, only equal treatment,” association President Zack Medford said.

Chuck Kitchen, a lawyer representing plaintiffs in the Howell case, also praised the ruling in their litigation.

National News

FILE - A makeshift memorial honouring Tasia Fortune stands in the backyard of the property where he...

Associated Press

Man charged in killing of a Black woman found hanging from a Mississippi tree is due in court

JACKSON, Miss. (AP) — One of three men charged in the death of a Black woman whose body was found hanging from a Jackson, Mississippi, tree last summer is due in court on Tuesday. Earnest Lloyd Jr., 25, is expected to appear for the preliminary hearing on a charge of murder. The positioning of Tasia […]

2 hours ago

Del.-elect Robert White, D-D.C., the non-voting representative for the District of Columbia, talks ...

Associated Press

First new DC delegate since 1991 hopes that Democratic victories mean statehood is coming

WASHINGTON (AP) — The last time the District of Columbia had a freshman delegate going through new member orientation on Capitol Hill, the Soviet Union still existed, George H.W. Bush was president and the first Gulf War in Iraq hadn’t started yet. Now Robert White Jr. is stepping into the role held by Eleanor Holmes […]

6 hours ago

Associated Press

Large plume of gas billows out of California landfill

CASTAIC, Calif. (AP) — A large plume of gas billowed high into the air Monday after crews drilling at a landfill in Los Angeles County caused a rush of gas to escape along with decomposing garbage. Six people were taken to the hospital with minor injuries, said Jonathan Torres, a spokesperson for the county’s fire […]

6 hours ago

The Kaseya Center, home of the Miami Heat basketball team, features signage for the "Grand Theft Au...

Associated Press

Miami embraces its Vice City alter ego, seizing buzz around ‘GTA VI’ release

MIAMI (AP) — As gamers worldwide prepare to race stolen supercars, pull off heists and eliminate enemies in a Miami-inspired Vice City, this week’s “Grand Theft Auto VI” release will feel especially personal to Florida residents. Felix Jarquin is among those who can barely wait to install the massive 200-plus gigabyte game file. “GTA VI” […]

6 hours ago

Adam R. Telle, the Acting Secretary of the Army, right, and Acting Secretary of the Navy Hung Cao, ...

Associated Press

Trump’s pick for Navy secretary likely to face Iran war questions during confirmation hearing

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump’s pick to lead the U.S. Navy is scheduled to testify before a Senate committee on Tuesday, the first step in a nomination process that could turn into a fierce debate over the Iran war, military transparency and the well-being of American sailors. Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao, a Trump […]

6 hours ago

Workers finish up decorating the Bellagio hotel-casino's Conservatory and Botanical Gardens as peop...

Associated Press

Bellagio’s annual holiday flower show opens with tens of thousands of blooms

LAS VEGAS (AP) — As giant, silver snowflakes were hoisted toward the high glass ceiling at the Bellagio’s Conservatory and Botanical Gardens, tourists snapped photos of the tens of thousands of flowers arranged underneath in one of Las Vegas’ most popular holiday displays. Visitors over the weekend got a first look at “Postcards From Christmas,” […]

6 hours ago

North Carolina Supreme Court says bar owners’ COVID-19 lawsuits can continue