NATIONAL NEWS

Trump allies, undeterred by setbacks in courts and Congress, push anew for citizenship proof to vote

Oct 23, 2025, 5:14 AM

FILE - A person arrives for a U.S. Election Assistance Commission Standards Board public meeting, A...

FILE - A person arrives for a U.S. Election Assistance Commission Standards Board public meeting, April 24, 2025, in Charlotte, N.C. (AP Photo/Chris Carlson, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Chris Carlson, File)

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — A documentary proof-of-citizenship requirement for voting in U.S. elections hasn’t been able to pass Congress and has been blocked by the courts, so allies of President Donald Trump’s administration are pursuing another avenue to try to impose the idea — asking a little-known federal agency to do it.

By a deadline earlier this week, the independent U.S. Election Assistance Commission had received more than 380,000 public comments reacting to a petition to add the requirement. The proposal is being pushed by America First Legal, a conservative group co-founded by Stephen Miller, the Republican president’s deputy chief of staff.

The group is asking the commission, composed of two Republicans and two Democrats, to add the mandate to the federal voter registration form. It says requiring people to produce documents proving their citizenship is “essential to enhance the integrity and reliability of voter registration processes, ensuring that only eligible U.S. citizens are permitted to register and vote in federal elections.” A group of Republican U.S. senators and representatives described it as “simple, common-sense reform,” little different from showing ID to board an airplane or open a bank account.

Voting rights groups characterize such a requirement as unnecessary, cumbersome and a potential tool for voter disenfranchisement.

Noncitizen voting is illegal and extremely rare

The gambit before the Washington-based election commission is the latest attempt by conservatives to push a nationwide proof-of-citizenship requirement while raising the specter of noncitizen voting as a significant problem, when it fact it is extremely rare. Making claims about noncitizens voting was a major part of the Republican playbook during the 2024 presidential election, even though it is already illegal and punishable as a felony.

The petition to the Election Assistance Commission comes after Trump sought to force the body to enact an identical provision through an executive order on elections he issued in March. That order has been temporarily blocked by two federal courts, which found the action unconstitutionally exceeded his presidential authority. The Constitution gives states and Congress the power to set election rules.

In its petition, America First Legal dismissed those losses: “This premise remains contested in court, but it also leaves this Commission with the freedom to take commonsense election integrity measures on its own volition.”

What does the federal voter form require?

The federal voter form already requires registrants to affirm their U.S. citizenship under penalty of perjury. Violating it is a felony that can lead to imprisonment, fines and deportation. Congress deemed that approach adequate when it approved the Help America Vote Act, which established the commission in 2002.

The commission has discretion to make changes to the form, but there’s disagreement over whether that includes being able to unilaterally impose such a significant new requirement on voters across the country. A spokesperson for the commission is on furlough during the federal government shutdown and did not respond to a request for comment.

America First Legal told the commissioners they have sufficient authority to act under a provision of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993. But Jonathan Diaz, director of voting advocacy and partnerships for the Campaign Legal Center, said the election commission first would need to determine that requiring documentation of citizenship is “necessary” to determine people’s eligibility.

“In my view, asking for information is one thing. Asking for additional documents and evidence beyond the information the form collects is another thing,” he said.

The consequences of noncitizen voting

Susannah Goodman, director of election security for the good-government group Common Cause, said cases of noncitizens voting in U.S. elections remain “extraordinarily rare” because the risks outweigh the rewards.

“The consequences of doing it are so great and citizenship is so precious, we don’t believe that this is the problem that they are trying to solve. Numbers don’t prove it out,” she said. “There is no threat to our democracy from noncitizens voting.”

In its petition, America First Legal said enforcement of the perjury provision is “nearly non-existent” and a system dependent “entirely on the honesty of applicants” is a recipe for fraud. The organization did not respond to an interview request.

“States are relying on a broken ‘trust but don’t verify’ system for registering voters,” Justin Riemer, president of the nonprofit Restoring Integrity and Trust in Elections, which filed public comment in support of the proposal, said in a statement. “The EAC’s registration form ties the hands of states trying to ensure that only citizens register and vote. That must change.”

Democratic Sen. Alex Padilla of California and Rep. Joseph Morelle of New York, outspoken proponents of voting rights, said adding such a requirement was unnecessary.

“States already have multiple systems in place to ensure that only eligible Americans vote in elections; states already determine voters’ citizenship statuses without the burdensome requirement requested in the petition,” they said in comments to the commission.

Legislation imposing a proof-of-citizenship requirement — the SAVE Act — passed the U.S. House earlier this year but has stalled in the Senate in the face of bipartisan opposition. Similar efforts also have run into obstacles when introduced in the states.

What kind of ID would be acceptable?

America First Legal’s petition lists four types of documentation that would meet the requirement: a U.S. passport; a state-issued REAL ID-compliant driver’s license that lists citizenship status; a military ID that indicates citizenship status; or a valid federal or state photo ID that either indicates citizenship or is “accompanied by proof of United States citizenship.”

Of the four, only a passport would be a universally reliable form of qualifying identification, although only about half of Americans have one. Only five states offer REAL ID driver’s licenses that indicate citizenship, and military IDs often don’t. Those invoking the other forms of federal and state photo ID that lack a citizenship indicator would need to present other documentation that’s not listed, such as a birth certificate.

Diaz, of the Campaign Legal Center, said women who change their last name when they marry might have to present their birth certificate, their marriage certificate and a valid government identification. That was shown to be a barrier for some women who voted in a primary election earlier this year in New Hampshire, which was imposing a similar requirement for the first time.

“It’s just creating hurdle after hurdle after hurdle for eligible U.S. citizens to be able to vote,” Diaz said.

The commission’s next step is to review the comments and determine by a majority vote whether to proceed on the petition. Approval would be followed by more formal proceedings, including another comment period and public hearings.

National News

FILE - Smoke rises from the Dragon Bravo Fire at the Grand Canyon as seen from Mather Point near Gr...

Associated Press

Federal review faults leadership failures in Grand Canyon fire that destroyed lodge

Leadership failures along with a lack of preparedness and poor communication were the driving factors of a wildfire that destroyed a historic lodge and dozens of structures along the North Rim of Grand Canyon National Park. A federal review of the Dragon Bravo Fire recently made public noted that while drought conditions and extreme fire […]

55 minutes ago

President Donald Trump walks to board Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Md., on his way to atten...

Associated Press

Trump appeals to state and federal courts to erase hush money conviction

NEW YORK (AP) — A federal appeals court is weighing whether it can — or should — intervene in President Donald Trump’s hush money case after a New York State appellate court heard arguments to get his historic conviction thrown out. A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday spent […]

2 hours ago

Shown is a Chase Bank location in Media, Pa., Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke)Credit: ...

Associated Press

What to know about the online banking delays affecting major US banks

A technical issue at JPMorgan Chase caused problems throughout the financial system Monday, resulting in thousands of customers reporting difficulty accessing online accounts at several major U.S. banks and the money transfer service Zelle. Here’s what we know. What’s behind the outage? JPMorgan Chase, the largest U.S. bank by total assets, said a software bug […]

3 hours ago

Travelers wait for their luggage at Los Angeles International Airport on Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, in ...

Associated Press

Trump clipped Biden’s payouts for stranded travelers. It may not have helped during the ground stop

President Donald Trump has blamed the nationwide grounding of all planes last week on old technology, as well as on his Democratic predecessor, Joe Biden. Trump’s administration weakened Biden-era rules to help stranded travelers — though it would not likely have helped many after Friday’s FAA-ordered ground stop. That remuneration was tied to issues with […]

3 hours ago

Associated Press

Arkansas city of El Dorado uses travel spotlight to clear its name. Call us ‘El Duh Ray Duh’

LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — When a system failure grounded airplanes nationwide, led to thousands of flight cancellations and disrupted air travel worldwide, a little place called El Dorado suddenly found itself in the spotlight. The southern Arkansas city of about 18,000 people gained unwanted attention when a radio communications site based there was identified […]

3 hours ago

A photo of the late Dolores Huerta is on display as part of a "Dia de los Muertos" altar display at...

Associated Press

Dolores Huerta, the late labor leader and civil rights icon, honored at memorial in California

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California officials paid tribute to Dolores Huerta, one of the nation’s most influential labor leaders, civil rights icons and feminist activists, at a memorial ceremony Monday at the state Capitol. They remembered her as a relentless advocate for a more just and fair world. Huerta co-founded a union that became the […]

4 hours ago

Trump allies, undeterred by setbacks in courts and Congress, push anew for citizenship proof to vote