SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Carmen Best: The First Amendment expires weekdays at 3 pm

Mar 9, 2018, 8:44 AM

protest, protesters, Carmen Best...

Protesters opposed to a youth jail block traffic during the Friday morning commute in Seattle. (SDOT)

(SDOT)

Seattle’s so-called Interim Police Chief, Carmen Best was in a tough spot. There she was, in front of a group of citizens who were justifiably angry that Best had allowed seven people to take over downtown Seattle by laying down in the middle of the road. Best did what she could to play her duel roles: pretend cop and real panderer. But, in walking that balance beam she became dizzy, veered off course and tried to discuss constitutional rights. That was a bad decision, but at least it was hilarious. You can hear Best veering off course here, recorded by a listener to KIRO Radio and aired on our show.

Carmen Best, constitutional scholar: Congress shall make no law prohibiting some citizens from limiting the movement of other citizens

Best lectured people who had their universally recognized constitutional right to freely associate stolen by seven people that it’s an issue of free speech. She explained that the First Amendment means seven people laying in a street get to prevent them from freely associating with their peers at work, their doctors at Harborview or their families. Speech, she taught, means some people get to physically limit the movement of other people. Best then attempted to wax philosophical. She asked where the First Amendment said free speech was okay unless it was inconvenient. She is afraid to come on the show, or I would ask her where the First Amendment says you can force people to listen or steal their enumerated First Amendment right to peaceable assemble. Of course, Best had ceased to talk about free speech when she began endorsing forced restraint.

The right of the people to petition the government to address grievances . . . and to to call out blatant horse droppings shall not be infringed

Oddly, citizens were not mollified with Best’s endorsement of breaking Washington State’s Disorderly Conduct Law that specifically bans pedestrians blocking the streets. Nor were they made to feel better with Seattle’s so-called Police Chief’s official position that, at any time during your day, a fellow citizen can stop your movement, lock you in place, and make you watch their temper tantrum. So, Best tried to put her fake cop mask back on. Best said that Seattle police only allowed seven people to limit the physical movement of tens of thousands until 3:00. After 3:00, Best said, Seattle police cannot allow people to block the streets.

Remember: The Constitution says your God-given rights expire at 3:00

Carmen Best’s pretend First Amendment right to block people’s movement, which moments ago she held as sacred and inviolable, suddenly expired at 3:00. Free Speech, according to Seattle’s so-called Interim Police Chief, shuts down at 3:00 on weekdays. This is what happens when you operate with no principle higher than keeping your party bosses happy: you find yourself uttering objective gibberish.

This is really quite sad for Seattle, but also for Carmen Best

Once upon a time, Carmen Best was probably an actual cop. Somewhere in her muscle memory, she knows we cannot allow seven people to take over downtown. The King County Sheriff said she will make arrests if people block the streets. But, Carmen Best is no longer a cop; she wears the badge, but it’s an ornament of her past. These days, Carmen Best is a Deputy Panderer to Chief Panderer and failed Mayor, Jenny Durkan. That’s why I have my own plan for dealing with people who block my car in protest.

FILE - Malaysia's Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, left, and U.S. President Donald Trump, right, watch...

Associated Press

US will provide $45 million in aid to Thailand and Cambodia in a bid to ensure regional stability

BANGKOK (AP) — The United States, which played a major role in ending border clashes last year between Thailand and Cambodia, will be providing $45 million in aid packages to the two Southeast Asian countries in an effort to ensure regional stability and prosperity, a senior U.S. State Department official said Friday. U.S. Assistant Secretary […]

26 minutes ago

Associated Press

Israeli strikes kill at least 13 across Gaza, as Trump is expected to announce Board of Peace

DEIR AL BALAH (AP) — Israeli strikes across Gaza have killed at least 13 people, according to health officials, as U.S. President Donald Trump was expected to announce his Board of Peace to oversee the fragile ceasefire. Health officials and family members said at least one child was among the dead in northern Gaza following […]

4 hours ago

Law enforcement officials work the scene following reports that federal immigration officers shot a...

Associated Press

Photos show protests over the shooting of 2 people by federal immigration agents in Oregon

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — Federal immigration officers shot and wounded two people in a vehicle outside a hospital in Portland on Thursday, a day after an agent fatally shot a woman in Minnesota. The latest shooting prompted hundreds of people to turn out for a nighttime protest at the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement building […]

6 hours ago

Associated Press

Anger and outrage spills onto Minneapolis streets after ICE officer’s fatal shooting of Renee Good

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — As anger and outrage spilled out onto Minneapolis’ streets Thursday over the fatal shooting of a woman the day before by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer, a new shooting by federal officers in Oregon left two people wounded and elicited more scrutiny of enforcement operations across the U.S. Hundreds of people […]

7 hours ago

Luigi Mangione appears in Manhattan Criminal Court for an evidence hearing, Thursday , Dec. 18, 202...

Associated Press

Luigi Mangione heads to court as he fights to block death penalty, murder charge and key evidence

NEW YORK (AP) — Luigi Mangione is due in federal court Friday for a pivotal hearing in his fight to bar the government from seeking the death penalty against him in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. Mangione’s lawyers contend that authorities prejudiced his case by turning his December 2024 arrest into a “Marvel […]

7 hours ago

Associated Press

Asian shares rise and US futures are flat after modest Wall Street moves

HONG KONG (AP) — Asian shares were mostly higher on Friday following mixed moves on Wall Street, where President Donald Trump’s talk of raising defense spending spurred a rally in military-related shares. Tokyo’s Nikkei 225 gained 1.1% to 51,692,70. Shares of Fast Retailing, the fashion company behind Uniqlo, jumped more than 7% after its quarterly […]

7 hours ago

Carmen Best: The First Amendment expires weekdays at 3 pm